This is a barometer of mostly hands-off anticipation months before many of these games release.
Disclaimer: I've tried to come up with the categories before I counted the ballots to reduce my personal bias.
1090 ballots were counted and 151 different games were mentioned.
The scoring goes as follows: (Total mentions / Total points / #1 votes only)
Horizon: Zero Dawn (943 / 2885 / 413) by Guerilla Games
Game of the Show = Highest total points
Passion Award = Top in counting #1 votes only
Universal Appeal = Most frequently appearing game on ballot
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End (777 / 1975 / 91) by Naughty Dog
The Last Guardian (717 / 1702 / 76) by genDesign & Japan Studio
Fallout 4 (575 / 1322 / 90) by Bethesda Game Studios
Final Fantasy VII Remake (499 / 1211 / 97) by Square Enix
Star Wars Battlefront (528 / 1022 / 17) by DICE
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain (354 / 776 / 52) by Kojima Productions
No Man's Sky (371 / 609 / 2) by Hello Games
Super Mario Maker (253 / 578 / 37) by Nintendo EAD Group No. 4
Shenmue 3 (269 / 554 / 37) by YSNet
Fallout 4 (575 / 1322 / 90) by Bethesda Game Studios
Out in 2015 = Announced release date of 2015
NieR New Project (204 / 416 / 26) by Platinum Games
Biggest surprise = Game we knew nothing about going into E3
Shenmue 3 (269 / 554 / 37) by YSNet
Funded with Kickstarter is self explanatory
Street Fighter V (181 / 324 / 9) by Capcom
Forza Motorsport 6 (22 / 46 / 4) by Turn 10 Studios
Destiny: The Taken King (22 / 39 / 1) by Bungie
Full results
Code:
Game rank mentions points top spot
Horizon: Zero Dawn 1 943 2884 413
Uncharted 4: A Thief's End 2 777 1975 91
The Last Guardian 3 717 1702 76
Fallout 4 4 575 1322 90
Final Fantasy VII Remake 5 499 1211 97
Star Wars Battlefront 6 528 1022 17
Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain 7 354 776 52
No Man's Sky 8 371 609 2
Super Mario Maker 9 253 578 37
Shenmue 3 10 269 554 37
Kingdom Hearts III 11 286 538 10
Cuphead 12 293 518 11
Deus Ex: Mankind Divided 13 277 515 10
Dark Souls 3 14 247 469 10
Project NieR 15 204 416 26
Street Fighter V 16 181 324 9
Mirror's Edge: Catalyst 17 180 299 6
Unravel 18 192 296 3
DOOM 19 144 233 4
For Honor 20 133 228 4
Just Cause 3 21 127 226 6
Star Fox Zero 22 122 222 4
Ratchet & Clank 23 113 181 1
Firewatch 24 118 175 2
Dreams 25 112 172 5
Mass Effect: Andromeda 26 96 170 4
Rise Of The Tomb Raider 27 115 165 0
Dishonored 2 28 101 163 3
Halo 5: Guardians 29 79 160 9
South Park: Fractured But Whole 30 99 159 2
Hitman 31 101 155 1
Ghost Recon: Wildlands 32 97 155 5
Shin Megami Tensei X Fire Emblem 33 79 151 4
Fire Emblem: Fates 34 73 125 3
Recore 35 70 106 2
Sea of Thieves 36 63 96 1
Star Ocean 37 58 87 1
The Division 38 56 82 0
Xenoblade Chronicles X 39 43 80 3
Gears of War 4 40 45 75 2
XCOM 2 41 35 74 3
Yoshi's Woolly World 42 41 64 0
Rare Replay 43 32 61 1
Mario & Luigi: Paper Jam 44 27 48 2
Abzû 45 31 48 0
Forza Motorsport 6 46 22 46 4
World Of Final Fantasy 47 25 39 1
Destiny: The Taken King 48 22 39 1
Persona 5 49 19 33 0
Transformers: Devastation 50 20 33 1
Fatal Frame: Maiden of Black Water 51 23 32 0
Need For Speed 52 19 30 0
The Legend of Zelda: Triforce Heroes 53 16 29 0
Batman: Arkham Knight 54 19 29 0
RIGS: Mechanized Combat League 55 19 29 0
Call of Duty: Black Ops 3 56 18 27 0
Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare 2 57 16 27 1
FAST Racing Neo 58 14 26 0
Wattam 59 15 24 1
Shadow Warrior 2 60 10 23 1
Trackmania Turbo 61 11 22 1
Rainbow Six Siege 62 14 22 0
Anno 2205 63 12 18 0
Tearaway Unfolded 64 10 16 0
Yo-kai Watch 65 10 16 1
Trails of Cold Steel 66 9 14 0
Beyond Eyes 67 10 14 0
Mad Max 68 10 13 0
Eitr 69 9 12 1
Metroid Prime Federation Force 70 7 12 1
The Tomorrow Children 71 8 11 0
Earthbound Beginnings 72 5 11 0
Rocket League 73 6 10 1
Rock Band 4 74 4 10 0
Pro Evolution Soccer 2016 75 5 10 0
Yooka-Laylee 76 8 10 0
Divinity: Original Sin Enhanced 77 3 9 1
Persona 4: Dancing All Night 78 7 9 0
Kingdom Come: Deliverance 79 4 9 0
Mother Russia Bleeds 80 6 9 0
Pillar's of Eternity: The White March 81 4 9 1
Summer Lesson 82 5 8 0
Below 83 6 7 0
Gears of War: Ultimate Edition 84 5 6 0
Galak-Z 85 5 6 0
Until Dawn 86 5 6 0
Ashen 87 5 6 0
Tacoma 88 4 6 0
Assassin's Creed Syndicate 89 4 6 0
Hellblade 90 3 6 1
What Remains of Edith Finch 91 5 6 0
SOMA 92 4 6 0
Mega Man Legacy Collection 93 2 5 1
Super Smash Bros DLC (Roy/Ryu) 94 4 5 0
Drawn To Death 95 3 4 0
Everybody's Gone to the Rapture 96 3 4 0
Keep Talking & Nobody Explodes 97 2 4 0
Mario Tennis: Ultra Smash 98 4 4 0
Armikrog 99 1 4 1
FIFA 16 100 2 3 0
Enter the Gungeon 101 2 3 0
Elder Scrolls Online (Dark Brotherhood) 102 1 3 0
Final Fantasy XV 103 1 3 0
Mighty No. 9 104 1 3 0
Legend of Legacy 105 1 3 0
Animal Crossing Amiibo Festival 106 3 3 0
Xbox One backwards compatibility 107 2 3 0
SWTOR Knights of the Fallen 108 2 3 0
Rising Storm 2: Vietnam 109 1 3 0
Rain World 110 1 3 0
Runbow 111 2 3 0
Planet Coaster 112 2 2 0
Minecraft for HoloLens 113 2 2 0
Bravely Second 114 2 2 0
Typoman 115 2 2 0
Farming Simulator 15 116 1 2 0
Oneechanbara Z2 Chaos 117 1 2 0
Corpse Party: Blood Drive 118 1 2 0
Killer Instinct PC 119 1 2 0
King's Quest 120 1 2 0
Disney Infinity 3.0 121 1 2 0
American Truck Driver 122 1 2 0
Rime 123 1 1 0
Project Setsuna 124 1 1 0
Gang Beasts 125 1 1 0
SUPERHOT 126 1 1 0
The Flame in the Flood 127 1 1 0
Strafe 128 1 1 0
Return to PoPoLoCrois: A Story of Seasons F129 1 1 0
Senran Kagura Estival Versus 130 1 1 0
Crossing Souls 131 1 1 0
Elite: Dangerous 132 1 1 0
Headmaster 133 1 1 0
EVE: Valkyrie 134 1 1 0
Skylanders: Super Chargers 135 1 1 0
Edge of Nowhere 136 1 1 0
Alienation 137 1 1 0
Life is Strange 138 1 1 0
Mutant Mudds Super Challenge 139 1 1 0
Banner Saga 2 140 1 1 0
Superhypercube 141 1 1 0
Devil's Third 142 1 1 0
Project X Zone 2 143 1 1 0
Relativity 144 1 1 0
Dragon Quest Heroes 145 1 1 0
Pirates 146 1 1 0
Playstation Vue A la Carte 147 1 1 0
Adr1ft 148 1 1 0
Harmonix Music VR 149 1 1 0
Thumper 150 1 1 0
The London Heist 151 1 1 0
Thanks for participating!