• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Ever been a part of an online community that lived, thrived, and then slowly died?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sad to hear about some communities I used to check out now and then (Shoryuken, Digitpress, neo-geo.com) dying off. Where do people get together to talk about retro games, if sites like the latter two are dying off? Maybe they don't - maybe folks have just moved on with their lives.
 
Back in the day. It was a Sega fan site called Blast city. One of the best around up until the Dreamcast died.

I used to the Super hero hype forums but, a lot of the posters there are trolls except for Corpulent1 to whom I respect. I was banned when I kept posting negative comments about the original civil war(it was trash).

Phantasy Star online forums - the games devolved into the sims and you had people sitting down in lobbies talking while being logged into the forum. Drove me nuts.

VF.com - I still lurk there. I'm one of the original members from waaay back. I always pop-in to see what's going on. Still my favorite fighting game.

Stardestroyer - goes without saying. haha I used to lurk there. I think it's still going strong.
 
C

Contica

Unconfirmed Member
Was really building a name for myself on myspace back in the day, you know, before they destroyed themselves, and Facebook came in and ruined everything that was fun about social networks.

Some pretty big names in the rock industry even approached me.

Then myspace died, and well, back to square one for me, and I never really bothered much with online interactions anymore.

It was so easy just randomly meeting really cool people back then. Now? Now I'd call it work. Hard, tedious work.
 
Despite being hooked on N64.com (starting with the first Mario64 video), I posted on Gamespot in the late 90s. I eventually moved to IGN in 2002 and stayed mostly to the GCB, SFCB and CEB. I posted on bad-cartridge/dayonepatch for a few years and now I'm mostly on GAF.
 
I used to post on this board called Trickology which was mainly about hip-hop and junk. That board died, everyone migrated to tehbored.com but I haven't been there in years.
 
Toonzone: Great forum to talk about cartoons in the early 2000s but members just started leaving and no one came to replace them. Bit of a ghost town now.

Digital Press Forums: This used to be my favorite retro forum, with some fun and funny members. But I recently went back to check it out and there was a thread talking about how members would find each other if it closed soon.
 

Accoun

Member
krokmania.com - a Polish Stepmania and general rhythm games community. I don't remember when I registered there to be honest. I know that by 2012 it was pretty much dead. According to The Internet Archive, it was online until April this year, but it's offline now.

simfile.pl - an short-lived offshoot of the former because of some... personal feuds of some people with one of the admins, I think. Was even smaller, but had some really quality people making songs. Started around 2009, died in 2011. Surprisingly, the "Thank You For Playing" message is online to this day, so looks like the domain is being renewed.

frets.pl - Yeah, another music games forum, this time Frets On Fire. Frankly, this one wasn't very active at all - for a good while it was just forum only visited by moderation and maybe 2 normal users. But hey, it was still a place to hang out (even though it was just kids, and most even younger than me).
After some time the admin just pulled the plug and replaced it with a "willing to sell the domain cheaply" message and never returned. He wasn't active for a good while before that and I couldn't reach him in any way.

Last.fm



On the other hand, I'm kinda surprised that thegamecreators forums are still alive. Not sure how alive, but alive. And there are quite a few old faces there now that I looked there.
 
Lots. Insert Credit (which is a completely different thing now), The Next Level, The Fanitsu Project, Gamengai, a few other import gaming-related places, a number of fan-translation/romhacking forums, lots of IRC channels. GAF is also not the place it was ten years ago, even if it's much bigger.

It sucks to see communities die, especially when they're tightly-knit and feel like home. You share a techno-cultural moment and when that moves on it's hard to find that exact connection again with other people. I still talk to a lot of people I met in those places, just through messaging services or Facebook.

TNL... that place was largely my baby. I should have moderated it a bit more strictly, because it got so toxic that I literally said "fuck it" and handed the keys over to someone else.
 
8549e2631f.png


rip

Yep. (Xbox 360 GB mostly here, tho)

That Circuit City sale post makes me miss them so much
 
Use to always be on the GamecubeXL forums about 15 years ago or so I guess. Around the release of Gamecube. We then turned into NintendoNet, and then it died slowly. Still got a few of those people on Facebook and I know one guy post on GAF. Ran into him many years ago.
 
The Bioware Social Network back around the time Mass Effect 2 came out. Boy did that place go downhill fast. We all migrated to another forum and even that fell apart. I still have friends in made from there that I talk to everyday though.

Neogaf shall last forever. Ano eternal flame to light the dark cesspool that is the internet.
 

gugi40

Member
There was a few sites that were huge back in the day but now have faded hard, mostly because the developers went on to bigger things and just forgot about it.

No naming of the sites as they will cause embarrassment.

But yes I know this feel!
 
Toonzone: Great forum to talk about cartoons in the early 2000s but members just started leaving and no one came to replace them. Bit of a ghost town now.

Ah, completely forgot to mention that before! I used to frequent Toon Zone too. Back when Justice League was airing, guys like Dwayne McDuffie would actually come over to answer questions. I'd say the point where the community went downhill is when some asshole posted a fake audio interview with McDuffie that gave him a racist "plantation worker" voice, which upset him and every other DCAU guy on the forums, so they left and never came back. The DCAU subforum really was the core of the forums, I'd say, so the creators leaving combined with Justice League Unlimited ending led to a lot of others leaving. And then after that, the main page went through a lot of changes. At one point, it took so long for me to load that I changed my bookmark from the front page to just the forums. And then they started covering video games on the front page for some reason.

It was still decently active for a while after that, but then things just kept slowing down, and 2-3 years ago, I couldn't find a reason to continue visiting the site.
 

jmood88

Member
The Bioware Social Network back around the time Mass Effect 2 came out. Boy did that place go downhill fast. We all migrated to another forum and even that fell apart. I still have friends in made from there that I talk to everyday though.

Neogaf shall last forever. Ano eternal flame to light the dark cesspool that is the internet.
Man, the Bioware Social Network turned into a pretty horrible place.

I posted at nfl2kx for awhile leading up to nfl 2k3 but it faded away for some reason and almost everyone moved over to OperationSports.
 

TheMan

Member
I used to post pretty often on the official deftones forums about a decade ago. I was never part of the core group (mostly made up of people from socal), but i learned of a lot of great bands from that site. Worst part of that site was the rampant use of the n-word. Also, chino disliked the forum as at least one album was leaked through some posters there. Plus, most people regularly mocked him for being fat. Anyway, the site was abruptly shut down in the late 2000s (i think), but by that time traffic had died down significantly. Someone eventually opened up a second forum which attracted some of the regulars from the original site, but it never seemed to gain much traction.
 

Mechazawa

Member
Does anyone who used to post at Rotten Tomatoes remember a user named Kim Justice? She has a cool Youtube channel:

https://www.youtube.com/user/elmyrdehory/videos

Yeah, I think most of us who posted in here(except SolidChamp, lol) still have her on our Steam friends list, a holdover from when the big timezone difference occasionally matched up and she could pop in for some Red Faction Guerrilla FFA.

Seeing people occasionally making topics about and discussing her in threads is a bit surreal.
 
TXB was great back in the early xbox days. Great articles and people running the show. Then the forums started turning to crap when the 360/PS3 comparisons became a thing and then the death blow was when IGN started poaching all their good writers.

A while back I checked in on it just for the hell of it and it was just a bunch of spam threads.
 
Yeah, I think most of us who posted in here(except SolidChamp, lol) still have her on our Steam friends list, a holdover from when the big timezone difference occasionally matched up and she could pop in for some Red Faction Guerrilla FFA.

Seeing people occasionally making topics about and discussing her in threads is a bit surreal.

Aside from that I think I once got to play Guwange with her at like 5AM my time, yeah. Timezones suck. Great poster, though.

Which is also true of RT on the larger sense. It's unfortunate a lot of the posting about RT in this thread has revolved around child prostitution and SolidChamp calling other GAFers cunts, because from my own perspective it was a mostly great place and I think most of the other vets would agree with me. I usually stuck to the videogame forum, and for many years it was a fantastic place for discussion. Without discounting the general quality of people posting there, one of the best aspects was it had a nearly perfect population level. It was big enough so you could have lots of active discussion with various perspectives but it didn't move so fast that you were basically just shouting into the void. I like posting on GAF, it's a great place, but there's so much posters and posting that it can be enormously difficult to really discuss things with each other. GVD on RT was truly excellent about that, you would often see a lot of long, interesting debates, and people would commonly reference past discussions. Which could also be a detriment, if you were the paranoid grudge-holding type, but most posters were pretty friendly.

Partially because of this tone and history it was also a perfect place to build strong friendships with other members. Many years later I'm still buddies with a lot of people I met on that site (for example the cool dude I'm technically responding to with this essay here), and while I've sadly lost contact with a bunch more I still think of them fondly. RT wasn't a utopia or anything, obviously, but at least the little corner I made my home in tended to be a mostly wonderful place.

Concerning its 'death', from my perspective there's basically two levels to that. On the larger scale my probably accurate understanding is the site went through a succession of owners who were increasingly disinterested in old-fashioned forums. They kept them running, sort of, which was nice. But the forums weren't getting pushed to potential new poster converts, and coupled with the usual user entropy a forum population sees, posting activity really died down, at least in my preferred GVD stomping grounds. Discussion dried up.

On a personal level the forum died for me because of gross technical problems. This had been an issue for many years, terrible stuff like posts getting eaten when you uploaded them -- I still sometimes reflexively copy and paste long forum posts before I finish them for this very reason. Most of us put up with these indignities because we really loved the community. But finally it reached a point where it stopped even letting me log in. Coupled with the gradual larger, slower death the forum was going through I ended up just saying screw it and stopped visiting entirely.

(I don't visit anymore, so maybe there's been a resurrection of sorts or GD is thriving, I don't know. But in my head the site is dead, sadly.)

Anyway, RT was great. Much love to any other veterans reading this fucking long-ass essay about the place, we had some great times. I'm legitimately grateful for all the time I got to spend there. Thanks.
 
charas-project.net - back when RPG maker was the shit I spent a lot of time on those forums giving scripting and storyboarding suggestions

knights of noblemen - one of those text based browser games, this one was real cool while it was still active, had a bunch of clans with designated roles for many of their members, eventually i moved out of state and neglected the game for a while and by the time I got back to it it was mostly dead. damn shame

myspace video game forums - there was a tiny little tight knit community there that'd have meetups and shit. i bailed around 2007 or so because things were getting a little weird. problem 1 - it was 2007 which meant an influx of crazy ass 2007 fourteen year olds with their console wars horseshit and their horrible horrible proto-memes. shoop da woop! more like go fuck yourself
problem 2 - like two or three of the regulars became punching bags for everyone else on the forum, some horrible shit was said, and that horrible shit became an on-site meme. eventually everyone was memeing and i mean these were stupid fucking memes, and someone or another formed a group (remember myspace groups?) so the quality regulars could convene in (relative) peace and most everything from that point on was just shit. kept up with a few of em via irc for a little while and that was fun at least

wifitournament - was a little tournament site for Wii and DS tournaments with prizes, great super friendly tight knit community but the site became too much of a burden on the owner iirc, it shifted ownership and there was a steady decline afterward. i got a lot of nostalgia for this one in particular.

nsider - i wrote a bunch of reviews and shit on that forum and lost all interest when nintendo shut it down so i never moved to nsider2
 
Yes. I used to be a part of a regional gaming forum, which has since become a club for the same few people.

They were quite rude to me after a while, and the idiots took over the asylum so to speak, so I left and came here.
 

Faddy

Banned
Something Awful.

A long series of staggeringly dumb decisions turned a pretty big community into a dead forum.

Something Awful is still ok, the overall community is still large enough to keep shit interesting.

Now Fark on the other hand is dying a slow death.


I think I have only been part of one forum that closed Whatever-Dude.com which was an entertainment column site, like Grantland but 10 years earlier.
 

MMarston

Was getting caught part of your plan?
I was also part of GameTrailers Forums for a long while - about 4-5 years to be exact. I left before the mass exodus though, and I don't think there's much else to be said about it that hasn't already been mentioned in this thread.

However, before that was my acne, low self-estem 13 year old self that was also a part of the Kingdom Hearts Ultimatum Forums almost 10 years ago. Back then, that place was sprawling with people given it was the heyday of the franchise. However, when KH3 got announced 3 years ago, I went back to see if people to were going crazy about it but (unsurprisingly) only very few people remained. Place was almost a ghost town.


Also, I just revisited the site again just now and they apparently went offline indefinitely.
 
The old Day of Defeat Source forum was great around 2005-6. It was never huge, but always active. Then all the source game forums got rolled into what is now the steam forums which are a dumpster fire, and that was the end of the good old DoD forums
 
The Trials forums used to be really lively and busy. Lots of community competitions and discussions, help with track building, speed runs etc. Then Ubisoft took over and changed the forum without any notice and all the fans went a bit nuts. It never really recovered. There are still people posting and chatting there but no where near what it used to be like. Shame.
 
F.E.A.R Community Forum.

First game was huge and we all jumped into it. The Community was great, the theories about the game were always call to debate.

Then post the second game things really started to go south. The Forum had a lot of people still post it, but the games just weren't as good. By the time the last one came out, most of the site was dead. A few avid posters, but we were barley hitting 22 people online when at it's prime we had over 5000. Sad times.
 

faridmon

Member
My chess club in School. Me and another person found it after both of us started playing during the lunch breaks everyday, people started getting invested in it and actually boomed. We had tournaments, actual club activities, we even traveled away to other schools to compete with them.

The moment I was about to finish year 13 (which was the last year of Sixth Form before Uni), Everyone started to be busy with exams and then, the whole chess interest died.

Later I found out that no one have actually attempted to play the game after I left the school. At least it was fun while it lasted.
 

Dr. Buni

Member
Some orkut communities. I got into them when they were created and stopped visiting altogether when the site was shut down, but by then the communities weren't the same anyways, many people had moved on to facebook, etc.
 
gamingworld.net a site for indie game development... in which very few people actually made anything of note(god knows none of the shit i worked on went anywhere). That said, it is where much tales of games studios(the guys who made Barkley shut up and jam gaiden) started.
While not, 100% dead, its not nearly as busy it used to be. Whats left of it is now on saltworld.net, but not a whole lot to see there now, at least last i checked. Makes me feel sad... and old.
 

Mikeside

Member
I posted on a board for the band Say Anything back when their first couple of Albums were coming out. That was pretty jumping with a great community back then. Went dead soon after.

Before that I posted on CNCDEN/RADEN - a Command & Conquer fan site that had a great community. it since died but most of the core members have found each other on Facebook recently which is nice
 

dc89

Member
www.thefuselage.com is one I just remembered.
That place was amazing when LOST was airing. Certain members of the cast and crew posted there too.
IIRC there was some kinda secret to the forum, a mini game / puzzle if you will. I think it was linked to the numbers of the show. If you solved it you got a certain colour name or an icon next to your name or something like that. So meta.
 

Firemind

Member
Penny Arcade. It used to have a thriving community. Then chat threads, megathreads, animated GIFs, anime, swearing, image spam, troll threads got banned for different, sometimes dumb, reasons. Shame because it had a lot of chill and very funny people.
 

lazygecko

Member
Before that I posted on CNCDEN/RADEN - a Command & Conquer fan site that had a great community. it since died but most of the core members have found each other on Facebook recently which is nice

The overall C&C community is one of the most resilient out there, in spite of EA trying their best to bury the franchise. There are sites like PPM which I frequented 13 years ago that are still active.
 

Hanso

Member
We still are in the dying process. The community startet back in 2001 and it was a german board for emulation. It was the biggest (semi-legal) emulation board with over 200k users. It became a legal board over time with crazy crazy stories, the admin went missing, police raids, takeovers from former co-admins, a time were the board split into two boards, the rivaling admin buying the domain etc.

Was really crazy at times. Also a very active and creative userbase held it together at tines with own boards to hold the users.

Now we are in maybe the 12th Generation (I stopped counting) and have 15-20 users left. We all know each other very well, met us and helped us out. We skype from time to time, have our mobile numbers and became "real" friends. Not much anonymity anymore.

It's sad but on the other side I met a lot of great people. We die since 5-6 years.
 

Acorn

Member
Allhiphop.com, got too big in the mid 00's and turned into an echo chamber of b.s instead of examinations of the art of hip hop.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom