-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Pineapple Pizza Mafia |OT| The War On Fruit Pizza
- Thread starter Sophia
- Start date
People might listen to you if you didn't turn around and throw personal insults at people who disagree with you. Like hey you're frustrated, sure, but you don't have to go around and ruin everyone else's enjoyment because of it.
Day 2 votes so far
blackbuzzard (1)
dr. worm 640
skyodin 708 (791)
swamped (3)
launchpadmcq 650
lifeline 657 (748)
isaacnukem 851 (855)
isaacnukem 855
lifeline 911
dr. worm (0)
palmer_v1 659 (778)
burbeting (1)
darryl 697
wherearemahdragonz (0)
lifeline 748 (911)
blargonaut (0)
palmer_v1 778 (1015)
palmer_v1 (0)
blargonaut 849 (1019)
isaacnukem (0)
hey_monkey 858 (910)
oreomunsta (1)
blackbuzzard 872
iaaacnukem (1)
wherearemahdragonz 885
acohrs (1)
hey_monkey 910
natiko (1)
acohrs 960
stanleypalmtree (1)
palmer_v1 1018
Majority is 10
Day 2 ends in:
blackbuzzard (1)
dr. worm 640
swamped (3)
launchpadmcq 650
isaacnukem 855
lifeline 911
dr. worm (0)
burbeting (1)
darryl 697
wherearemahdragonz (0)
blargonaut (0)
palmer_v1 (0)
isaacnukem (0)
oreomunsta (1)
blackbuzzard 872
iaaacnukem (1)
wherearemahdragonz 885
acohrs (1)
hey_monkey 910
natiko (1)
acohrs 960
stanleypalmtree (1)
palmer_v1 1018
Majority is 10
Day 2 ends in:
"avoidance of real stuff"
- It's not my fault, i'm the only one seeing this shit.
I asked this question like 3 times last day phase and no one gave a satisfactory answer:
Mafia team:
- Coasters
- Town leaders
- GF wanting to be investigated
Coasters: Dr. Worm, Darryl
Town Leaders: Dragonz (on day 1, on day 2 it seems mafia has switched her over to coasters)
Godfather; Swamped
Like is no one else seeing an obvious mafia team make up all voting and operating in a similar way in day 1.
These are all of the posts acohrs made this day phase, I believe. Anger at unspecified mistakes made by town, attempts to justify scum's choice in target, voting Natiko over the tie vote in a highly confused day end, followed by disapearing into the ether without following up his questions. A superficial attempt at town play and overall scummy behavior.
Vote: acohrs
There is no one way to play scum. I've been in games where the entire scum team was inactive and barely playing. I've been in games where most of the scum team was quite active and contributing without actually being town leaders. You also need to ease up on the jumping to unfounded conclusions. Case in point - what reason do you have to believe there's a godfather in this game? Especially prior to my claim. Most games I've been in have not had that role at all. Trying to read someone as a role you have no clue exists in the game is just weird. It makes it a lot harder to take your posts seriously. If you want people to pay attention then frame your points in a believable manner.
I literally posted about exactly this a while back. I was town every other time. I've never had a problem winning games as scum or neutral so why the fuck would I risk anything on a D1 gambit when I know how badly town has been playing anyway?
I don't know him from anywhere but this game. I have the same issue as you. I don't see the Swamped logic unless BB is scum, and I'd much rather vote him first.
yeah, scum/neutral would totally risk being modkilled by Sophia. That makes sense.
I was fairly nice D1, I think, and look where that got me.
hey_monkey
Banned
Alllllll of this. Twice. To infinity.
Yes, LL, you've noticed some connections. But you're hammering the same flimsy connections as 100% absolute THIS early and it's just not, man. And if anyone doesn't agree, you say they're defending your targets. Meantime you got targeted with something funky AND you misread your role or something but hey! Not important, right? Ignore all questions about that.
hey_monkey
Banned
brb, lynching my damn self as an escape mechanism.
Are you though? You seem awfully focused on this godfather stuff when we've had very little reason to suspect one so far.
To everyone:
What if Lifeline was the Godfather who got lucky with whatever ability targeted them? A normal cop would see they're town, so why wouldn't a weird public cop(or douser or poisoner) end up showing us the same result?
It's a stretch, for sure, but it's possible. Especially in the face of their caginess about any other info they can provide us. LL might already now they're poisoned, and this is scum taking a chance at eliminating Swamped who maybe gave them trouble for one reason or another.
hey_monkey
Banned
It's possible, I guess. Based on fixation with the GF. But the demanding obsession with scum team he was sure he had was also his MO in Arkham. So it would maybe be really lucky if it went down as you just guessed, Palmer.
hey_monkey
Banned
But - his elaborate read on a whole team did start day one. So there's that too. And I'm not sure I can buy it as some weird long con.
LaunchpadMcQ
Banned
That last part was going to be my next point.
Top scum: Swamped, Palmer, Sawneeks
Top town: Lifeline, Natiko
hey_monkey
Banned
Tonight after I get some work done I'm gonna update my reads. I need to focus in on all the stuff that happened today.
Fair point. Still a chance that whatever happened was fully in control of scum team, in which case it could have been planned during D1. It's still a long shot, but I would be remiss if i didn't point out the possibility.
BlackBuzzard
Banned
What is this some kind of code to your scum buddies?
Funny how in your crusade for the truth you forgot all about WMD who you now read as town.
Like Skyodin who you just declared town?
Oh im so glad you could join in and share your reads that will surely make you look town. So your scum list is 3 people coasting and me. Woah man slow down with the risky choices. Your town read includes somebody you wanted answers from that afterwards never responded to you and Skyodin who placed an early vote(post 112) on Oreo and never changed it something you condemned me for and i voted on Darryl(508) 2 hours before the no lynch took place and i actually gave my reason for doing so.
[highight]Vote: Dr.Worm
BlackBuzzard
Banned
Vote: Dr.Worm
Okay, I claim that i am
town
I'm going to be dead by Day 3 anyway, just wait till then if you want to know the details.
Also since going after confirmed town is a waste of time, I'll ask the important questions:
Dr. Worm: Why do think Dragonz is the more believable vanilla than BB?
You started the day of by saying this:
And while you harassed BlackBuzzard plenty, you completely ignored WAMD and didn't ask her any questions or asked for an explanation.
In fact you went on to defend her when we started talking about her role name starting with THAT instead of THE like everyone else.
So you were not at all worried about Dragonz's claim and considered her town, why did you pretend to be worried? Why did you pretend to impartial and saying both BB and WAMD have to explain, but then went on to ignore WAMD completely?
I know people keep saying I'm attacking people for defending Dragonz too much, but look at this shit. How is not suspicious to any of you?
BlackBuzzard
Banned
I now role claim mind reader!
I was just looking through old posts and saw one from SexyFish attacking me and saying something like "shit like this is gonna get you killed". So maybe it was an attempt to frame me.
I agree, also what do you think about Dr. Worm's reasoning behind Sexy's death
Based on my game as scum in DR3, SF being the night kill means there's a decent chance that scum have a player or two amongst those posting frequently. Coasting scum wouldn't target low post count players unless they think there's a significant PR to be found there.
I don't think sexy was a very good scum kill at all, honestly. I wasn't even sure it WAS the scum kill, until the LL poisoner thing got brought up. I thought maybe the scum had been foiled somehow and Sexy was a neutral kill. I say neutral cause I don't think Sexy was a good town vig target either. Now I'm less sure about it because of LL.
If it was scum, it makes me think scum is somewhat active. If they were all coasting, they wouldn't have narrowed it down for us by eliminating someone like sexy.
I was waiting to hear from Palmer first, but Natiko came in and spoiled it, huh.
Nevermind.
More or less what I'm thinking for now. I seriously doubt there is something going on like "oh, BB is getting framed!" or "oh, BB is trying to frame himself to make himself look more towny!"
hey_monkey
Banned
Which would mean the only clue would really be that we can guess we have seasoned scum and then whatever happened to LL, which he won't tell us. Cool, cool.
The way the votes went down was super odd. Didn't help that neither BB nor I were around, or inclined, to vote for one of the other two to save ourselves. I still think we learn a lot from a BB flip, even though I'm like 50/50 on him. It would settle Swamped in my mind for sure, which further illuminates some things from there.
Why are you so interested in what happened to me? Whatever happened to me was between the poisoner and me.
Also is everyone really going to ignore the points we brought up against Dr. Worm and just keep going after confirmed/already dead towns.
I'm little worried about town setting themselves up for a lynch chain.
Another question: Do you think a scum would dare to go for the dumb stunt that was the "Oh, town role names must start with THE, not THAT!?", which was something BB originated.
What the?
You are confirmed town, apparently. So any intel we can get from you should be intel we can actually trust. If you are poisoned, and you keep some vital information until the grave, it was all for nothing.
hey_monkey
Banned
For all the reasons I've already stated. And I'm sure no one has forgotten any of the points raised today but damn, son, one thing at at time.
hey_monkey
Banned
DID BB start it or was LL already on it, too? I'm on mobile atm so it'll take me a minute to dig it up. There were a few people on that idea at the time and BB hollered about a theory but I'm not positive he started it.
Pretty sure this started that bs.
Any information i know has already been put out there, and if you want the direct role quote, that will be provided when i'm dead Day 3.
Yeah, no problem dude. Take all the time scum chat needs to figure out their story and prep the good doc.
hey_monkey
Banned
Okay, just couldn't remember if that was actually first.
Probably not. I wouldn't. So many other weird things happened with BB though. I really struggle to believe that he somehow missed that this was Role Madness when I called it out right before I claimed.
Natiko also brought up some name related crap but I don't know if it was before or after.