Having seen just about all of these, here are my thoughts:
SUPERMAN: DOOMSDAY
- This one is decent. It kind of feels like a middling 3-part Superman TAS story. Also, the weird cheekbone details are back from Season 1 of Justice League.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: THE NEW FRONTIER
- One of the best films released under this imprint. It does a great job adapting the maxi-series and Cooke's artwork is beautifully brought to life. Very, very good.
BATMAN: GOTHAM KNIGHT
- This is an anthology collection, so some of the stories are good, some of them bad, some of them mediocre. I remember liking the Deadshot story. There's also a story that essentially copies a great Batman TAS episode (Legends of the Dark Knight) and does a pretty bad job of it.
WONDER WOMAN COMMEMORATIVE EDITION
- One of the better films on the imprint, for sure. Solid story with good structure, good fights, and a compelling lead.
GREEN LANTERN: FIRST FLIGHT
- Mediocre. Hal is an OK protagonist, but the design on Abin Sur is terrible and overall the plot doesn't go anywhere interesting. Very by the numbers. Which is a shame, because doing an adaptation of Geoff Johns' "Secret Origin" arc seems like such a no-brainer.
SUPERMAN/BATMAN: PUBLIC ENEMIES
- Pretty good! Not amazing, but a solid team-up story, Ed McGinnis's art translates well to animation, and it's pulling from a pretty fun comic arc by Jeph Loeb (GASP).
JUSTICE LEAGUE: CRISIS ON TWO EARTHS
- Really good. You've got James Woods doing an eerie Owlman, and we get our last animated Dwayne McDuffie storyline. It was originally written as a special to bridge Justice League and Unlimited before the Starcrossed episodes were thought up. So as a bonus, it fits in really nicely with that continuity (sorta).
BATMAN: UNDER THE RED HOOD
- Man, they were really on a good run here. Under the Red Hood is actually better than the comic arc it adapts, if I'm being honest. It's tighter, Jason comes off as WAY more interesting, and we even get some fun Nightwing action.
SUPERMAN/BATMAN: APOCALYPSE
- S'Ok. This is another arc adapted from Jeph Loeb's run on the comic series, though its Michael Turner's art instead, and they don't pull it off as well as they did in Public Enemies. Supergirl's arrival is a fun concept, but the Apokalips stuff is middling. There is a fun fight with Wonder Woman and Granny Goodness's goons, though.
ALL-STAR SUPERMAN
- Great story that becomes a pretty good animated movie. Without distinct chapters, the charm of the book doesn't come through as much, but it's still a very good Superman story with some real stand-out moments.
GREEN LANTERN: EMERALD KNIGHTS
- Another anthology, and much like Gotham Knight, it's hit or miss. I liked the Mogo Doesn't Socialize adaptation.
BATMAN: YEAR ONE
- The problem with Year One is that it's been mined so hard in regards to other adaptations (especially the Nolan movies) that, even if you never read the comic arc, this movie will come off as VERY familiar. But you've also got Bryan Cranston giving a fucking amazing performance as Jim Gordon. That makes it worth checking out.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: DOOM
- With the exception of Justice League, they've never been able to nail Vandal Savage - he's just not used great here. They also kinda-adapt Tower of Babel, Mark Waid's Justice League story, with the concept of a villain using Batman's just-in-case-I-need-to-take-out-the-Justice-League plans against them. The comic arc is a lot better. I think this is also one of the first movies to use the "DC house style" instead of adapting the comic story's art, which sucks.
SUPERMAN VS. THE ELITE
- An adaptation of a one-off story, "What's So Funny About Truth, Justice, and the American Way" by Joe Kelly. It's a fun story, and there's juice to the concept of making Superman inspect his own simplistic views on heroism, but it feels stretched to accommodate a whole movie. As a result, it ultimately comes off as mediocre.
THE DARK KNIGHT RETURNS, PART 1
- This is a very straight adaptation of Frank Miller's prestige series. The art ain't great, though. If you're a fan of the original story, you'll like it here, even if it's not great to look at.
THE DARK KNIGHTS RETURNS, PART 2
- Ditto.
SUPERMAN: UNBOUND
- What a missed opportunity. It's adapting a great comic arc (Brainiac by Geoff Johns and Gary Frank), but they ditch Pa Kent, which removes a lot of heart and impact. Another entry in the "s'fine" tier.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: THE FLASHPOINT PARADOX
- I think this movie is actually a lot better than the comic. It's more succinct, and the brutality of the alternate universe comes through a lot better. The downside is that it's elevated a crappy event into being something worthy of emulating.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: WAR
- Adapting Geoff Johns and Jim Lee's New 52 run that kicked off the new Justice League. Much like the story it's based on, it's got some fun crowd-pleaser moments, but it's otherwise not worth your time.
SON OF BATMAN
- Oof, this is actually terrible. Damien's intro arc in Grant Morrison's Batman run had highs and lows, but this is all lows. It also makes Deathstroke look like a fucking chump.
BATMAN: ASSAULT ON ARKHAM
- This movie is a total misnomer, because Batman is barely in it. This is a Suicide Squad movie, and it's WAY better than the theatrical film. They play it like a 70s heist/crime movie, and it works really well. There are a couple cringe-worthy moments, but otherwise, this is one of the better movies in the catalogue.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: THRONE OF ATLANTIS
- A forgettable Aquaman movie based on a forgettable Aquaman arc. Ocean Master has never been interesting, and probably never will be.
BATMAN VS. ROBIN
- What a disappointment. I remember being psyched about this when I heard the title, because I assumed it was adapting Morrison's story from Batman & Robin, but it's actually kind of a hybrid with elements from Scott Snyder's Court of Owls. It ends up being sloppy and disloyal to both arcs, and much like Son of Batman, it's not worth your time.
JUSTICE LEAGUE: GODS AND MONSTERS
- This is the best movie in the collection. It's a total Elseworlds tale, and I fucking LOVED it. People have given Bruce Timm some (deserved) hate, but man, he knocked this one out of the park.
BATMAN: BAD BLOOD
- This movie actually takes a lot of cues from the aforementioned Grant Morrison Batman & Robin arc, though it also mixes in Batwoman (in her first animated movie, I think), and again, it just doesn't work. The whole thread they've been doing with Batman and Damien just sucks. It hasn't worked from the jump, and it sure as shit isn't working here.
JUSTICE LEAGUE VS. TEEN TITANS
- This is another hodgepodge adaptation borrowing concepts from Geoff Johns' mid-2000s Teen Titans run, some stuff from the New 52 Teen Titans series, and also Raven's origin with Trigon from the Marv Wolfman/George Perez 80s Teen Titans series. It's all over the map, and the fact that Cyborg features here as a JL member and not a Titan just reminds me how much I hate that status quo change. This is middling to bad.
BATMAN: THE KILLING JOKE
- Look, The Killing Joke is a great comic story, but it's adapted poorly here, the art is bad, and the stuff added where Batman and Batgirl are fucking is AWFUL. Avoid avoid avoid.
JUSTICE LEAGUE DARK
- I like that they cast the NBC/CW Constantine for the voice role, but other than that, this is a very forgettable adaptation of the Mike Carey New 52 story.
TEEN TITANS: THE JUDAS CONTRACT
- I fell asleep like three times trying to watch this. 'Nuff said.
BATMAN AND HARLEY QUINN
- Is this out yet? I haven't seen it, if it is.
So yeah, some good, some OK, lots of mediocre-to-bad.
