digoutyoursoul
Member
1st post nails it.
Why would they lie? Makes no sense
1st post nails it.
One would think you would be used to it by now, judging by the typical levels of sodium found in almost all of your own posts.
Why would they lie? Makes no sense
Drops to 21 on PS4.
Why would they lie? Makes no sense
Pop in on X1 too but appears worse:
They say the X1 has POM but it clearly doesn't:
Now add in better resolution and better framerates. Which version is the clear winner here?
I dont know guys. I think 16x AF over trilinear filtering is a way bigger deal than 1080p vs 900p with a good AA solution. It doesn't mean that they're saying that on a purely technical level the XB1 version is better, but as an all around experience, id rather have the great texture filtering at 900p than bad filtering at 1080p if the AA solution really does make it as close as DF claims. Now, the framerate could be a problem, but they're saying the minimum is 21fps on XB1 and 25fps on PS4, not the average. If its just occasional dips on both, then both are bad, being under 30fps, but not necessarily a huge difference.
Yes, on a technical level, he PS4 version does seem to be more impressive, but I dont at all blame DF for their recommendation of the XB1 version over it, if everything they says is true.
It might seem crazy but no one makes a mistake this big.
I'd be fine with DF simply providing the information and then the reader making their minds up which they find most important. But they don't, they downplay resolution differences and generally make subjective comments which don't fit in a technical comparison IMO.
It's is more likely stupidity, or ignorance. But as a technical specialist, DF are supposed to avoid those.
Sweet, at least I learned something from this thread. Any other razors besides Hanlon's, Occam's, and Mach 3's?Hanlon's razor.
Metrics aren't relevant in a tech analysis? Well I'll be damned, you're more concerned about the bickering that will ensue than a tech site presenting the facts?Well no, the worse thing would be providing numbers without context for people to bicker over. Because those extra pixels and frames aren't very relevant in this situation.
Arguments like these make me wish the death of AAA would hurry up and get here.
Bullshit article. Careful DF, or you guys will be out of a job soon. Your audience does not want to see you pander to one platform or the other, and this one is heavily skewed to the Xbone.
First they say - 900p vs 1080p PS4 advantage does not matter. Then they say less stable and lower frame rate on Xbone is no big deal. Then they say a lessideal AA (apparently, to them) = Xbone version superior, but I thought blurry didn't matter because 900p vs 1080p doesn't matter, right?
Then there are GIFs of texture streaming issues on the Xbone, not the PS4, and screen caps and input from people playing the game saying these texture problems DF saw are nowhere to be found. WTF?
Well no, the worse thing would be providing numbers without context for people to bicker over. Because those extra pixels and frames aren't very relevant in this situation.
I find it funny that on all the games PS4 has been the winner. Noone complains but on the two X1 is the winner theres a huge storm of butt hurt.
DF chose X1, they simply felt as a whole that version was better. Lets all just deal with it lol
I find it funny that on all the games PS4 has been the winner. Noone complains but on the two X1 is the winner theres a huge storm of butt hurt.
No complaints when ps4 version is better than the x1 version.....hmm wonder why. Maybe because its a more powerful system.
When a less powerful system gets the 'better' version apparently, people are right to question it.
The shiniest of two turds. What self respecting dev would release a game this bad techincally. Just lower the resolutions to make your shitty game playable.
That's the thing, just because they "felt as a whole that version was better," doesn't mean it is. Everyone in here is showing and saying facts that disprove that, mostly on a technical standpoint. They're both bad anyway.I find it funny that on all the games PS4 has been the winner. Noone complains but on the two X1 is the winner theres a huge storm of butt hurt.
DF chose X1, they simply felt as a whole that version was better. Lets all just deal with it lol
Makes plenty of dollars though...Why would they lie? Makes no sense
Makes plenty of dollars though...
No complaints when ps4 version is better than the x1 version.....hmm wonder why. Maybe because its a more powerful system.
When a less powerful system gets the 'better' version apparently, people are right to question it.
Sorry, didn't really I needed to put or /s after that rather obvious joke.Means fuck all without proof
I see cheques in the post claims about various sites all the time without any evidence
If it was true, vote with your wallet, buy the PS4 version, you would amazed by how many people there are who don't give a shit about what's posted on the internet.
Yes I'm sure MS paid to have the Xbone version of Thief edge out the PS4 version by the slimmest of margins. All of their hopes were riding on this huge coupe.
Means fuck all without proof
I see cheques in the post claims about various sites all the time without any evidence
If it was true, vote with your wallet, buy the PS4 version, you would amazed by how many people there are who don't give a shit about what's posted on the internet.
Sorry, didn't really I needed to put or /s after that rather obvious joke.
And drops to 20 on the Xbox One. PS4 still has a more consistent FPS even at the higher resolution.
Care to explain what they're right about?I think DF is right. Keep up the good work, guys!
I find it funny that you find it funny that there's a problem when the weaker system's version of a game gets a recommendation over a superior system.I find it funny that on all the games PS4 has been the winner. Noone complains but on the two X1 is the winner theres a huge storm of butt hurt.
DF chose X1, they simply felt as a whole that version was better. Lets all just deal with it lol
GOD forbid a game on XBOX One look better than it's PS4 counterpart!
It's gonna be insane, probably one of the biggest threads of the month.Can't wait for the Titanfall DF thread.
Yep Xbox One version looks superior to PC. /endsarcasm. Or didn't ign have something similar.It's gonna be insane, probably one of the biggest threads of the month.
Picking through turds to decide which one has less sweetcorn in it must be depressing. He probably wasn't expecting his analysis to be picked apart for a game like this.
Yep Xbox One version looks superior to PC. /endsarcasm. Or didn't ign have something similar.
It's gonna be insane, probably one of the biggest threads of the month.
people are debating which one of the 2 crappy looking console version of a crappy game is less crappy, seriously neither side wins here
http://abload.de/img/the_gapqlpov.pngI dont know guys. I think 16x AF over trilinear filtering is a way bigger deal than 1080p vs 900p with a good AA solution. It doesn't mean that they're saying that on a purely technical level the XB1 version is better, but as an all around experience, id rather have the great texture filtering at 900p than bad filtering at 1080p if the AA solution really does make it as close as DF claims.