I think my current rating is
Sony = Ubisoft
Bethesda
Microsoft
PC
EA
Devolver
Without any really crazy drops between any of them. I really don't think anyone is crazy wowing this year, but the average presentation is up across the board. No real cringe moments or universal bathroom breaks. If you're someone who came in with your expectations firmly in check I think this has been a pretty tight E3.
Evil Within 2, Mario + Rabbids, Beyond Good and Evil 2, A Way Out, God of War, Monster Hunter World, Spiderman, Battlefront 2, Metro: I think all in all there's a good amount to get excited about.
I think the main concern at this point is just what I'm playing holidays this year; it's totally possible that in some weird twist of fate, the first half of the year will outshine the second. Mario Odyssey might have some weight to carry, unless there's something huge and nonannual I'm forgetting. I guess Destiny is really huge for a lot of people?