On the hockey side:
Teemu Selanne started playing in the NHL during the 1992-1993 season. He's still playing to this day, but as he's announced that this season will be his last he won't be in a PS4/XB1 game.
Jaromir Jagr's NHL career began in the 1990-1991 season. He's still playing, and doesn't seem interested in quitting, so I'd say he's got a fair shot at making it in a PS4/XB1 game.