MistakenMobius
Member
Trying to catch replicants.... why are you doing this..
The marketing for Blade Runner 2049 is out of control.
Trying to catch replicants.... why are you doing this..
Hypothetical:
What if Nazi guy was a girl and everything else in the video is exactly the same.
She gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys and one of them punches her out.
Does anyone's opinion of the situation change?
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
pretty funny how this thread is FULL of ''hypotheticals'' and whataboutism
your situation isn't what happened, what is the point of posting it here? trying to make us feel bad because ''what if'' for supporting a nazi getting punched?
Absolutely agree. But that doesn't have to mean that you use violence.
Don't get me wrong, i also have the same sadistic urges as the next guy when i see intolerance in the shape of a racist or a neonazi. But i just think we need to try and stand above that. Legislation should be constructed in a way that intolerance isn't accepted in any way.
And the punishment should not be just jail-time but also a long period of education and reintegration.
edit: lol at the Hypothetical posts...
I'm trying to guage what people find acceptable when it comes to vigilante violence.
What is an acceptable response vs. what is not.
You don't have to answer it if it makes you uncomfortable. It's just a hypothetical question.
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
... why are you doing this..
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
It's basically a slippery slope test.
As I posted above, I'm trying to guage how much violence is acceptable to some people when stuff like this happens.
A punch? Murder?
I think people are being way to cavalier with their responses in here.
But maybe it's just me that's concerned about it?
I don't know. That's why I'm asking hypotheticals.
Just stop.
Are you trying to paint nazis as victims of their upbringing? They're fucking nazis. I can understand being a little racist because of your upbringing (tho even then with the Internet it should be pretty easy to educate yourself), but being a nazi? Nope. They should be glad to get away with just a punch to the face.
Wearing a swastika and harassing people on public transit are choices that have consequences.
Everybody who comes into these threads decrying violence seems to fail to provide doable alternative forms of punishment for abhorrent acts of free will.
But maybe it's just me that's concerned about it?
I don't know. That's why I'm asking hypotheticals.
It's ironic how fascist sympathizers are now trying to defend Nazis by claiming they're mentally ill like many of those unfortunate mentally and physically disabled people Nazis sent to the ovens in their concentration camps in the first place along with gays, jews, gypsies and others.Fuck the people giving Nazis an out with some mental illness defense. I have family members who deal with real mental illness. You people should be knocked out too stigmatizing mental illness by basically equating it to being a Nazi. Fuck you.
Not like right leaning sympathizers don't often use the language of the left when they cry foul
TIL David Wong is a white dude's pen name.
What did I miss about David Wong? And he's a white dude?!I'm surprised he's writing for cracked.com given his history of racism and islamophobic stances. Are they aware of this?
Is anyone surprised he jumped to Muslims = Nazis in like 2 posts?
What if the Nazi was actually your grandmother and instead of a Nazi your grandmother was a communist and instead of getting punched she's getting flowers?
Really makes you think.
It's basically a slippery slope test.
As I posted above, I'm trying to guage how much violence is acceptable to some people when stuff like this happens.
A punch? Murder?
I think people are being way to cavalier with their responses in here.
But maybe it's just me that's concerned about it?
I don't know. That's why I'm asking hypotheticals.
I'm torn on this on. On the one hand vigilante justice tends to get out of hand and end badly incredible quickly.
On the other hand, he is a Nazi. If the USA had kept punching Nazi's after WWII maybe people wouldn't think it was still acceptable to be one and a white supremacist wouldn't be in the oval office.
What always confuses me is how nazism is becoming so popular in the country that is to thank for ending the tyranny of Nazi Germany.
Are these people now saying that helping end WW2 wasn't for the best of all mankind or what?
To those who say violence against Nazis is never the answer....
What if it was an ISIS sympathizer carrying their flag and was harassing you and thought of you as an infidel?
Would you take the abuse or hit low?
What always confuses me is how nazism is becoming so popular in the country that is to thank for ending the tyranny of Nazi Germany.
Are these people now saying that helping end WW2 wasn't for the best of all mankind or what?
But your hypothetical isn't necessarily fair and your hypotheticals make it seem like you're attempting to make a false equivalence between people who are happy a Nazi, a literal Nazi, got punched in the face and people either murdering or raping a Nazi.It's basically a slippery slope test.
As I posted above, I'm trying to guage how much violence is acceptable to some people when stuff like this happens.
A punch? Murder?
I think people are being way to cavalier with their responses in here.
But maybe it's just me that's concerned about it?
I don't know. That's why I'm asking hypotheticals.
It's ironic how fascist sympathizers are now trying to defend Nazis by claiming they're mentally ill like many of those unfortunate mentally and physically disabled people Nazis sent to the ovens in their concentration camps in the first place along with gays, jews, gypsies and others.
The irony
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
What if I came into the thread, ignored everything and made up my own scenario so I can feel smug and superior while offering nothing?
Makes you think, right?
.
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
The USA had it's very own growing American Nazi movement that both parties tried to quash back in the early 20th century. There were a lot of immigrants of German descent in the USA and many heard the call of the Fatherland. I didn't even know about it until this year. Never heard or saw pictures about the subject in grade, middle, high school or even college. We're really bad at teaching when it comes to the subject of white supremacy.What always confuses me is how nazism is becoming so popular in the country that is to thank for ending the tyranny of Nazi Germany.
Are these people now saying that helping end WW2 wasn't for the best of all mankind or what?
Hypothetically, I think it would be totally okay to punch any of these people in the face if you saw them out on the street spewing hate:
At one point in history, anyone who shot them dead would probably be called a hero.
What did I miss about David Wong? And he's a white dude?!
What always confuses me is how nazism is becoming so popular in the country that is to thank for ending the tyranny of Nazi Germany.
Are these people now saying that helping end WW2 wasn't for the best of all mankind or what?
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.
Seriously. These people think they're slick?You claim to wanna have a nuanced discussion about violence while insinuating that punching eventually leads to rape.
Mmmkay. Sure.
lol exactlyWhat if I came into the thread, ignored everything and made up my own scenario so I can feel smug and superior while offering nothing?
Makes you think, right?
No they're on the rise in Russia.It was Russia who defeated Nazi Germany.
Oh my fucking God with these outlandish hypotheticals!
Honestly some of you should just admit "Don't rock the boat. Minorities should just take it"
Worked last time against the Nazis.
And now, Hypothetical Question B:
Nazi Guy or Nazi Girl gets surrounded by 3 or 4 guys.
But instead of punching him/her out, they sexually assault him/her.
Does your opinion of that situation change?
I'm curious where people would draw the line, if at all.