• Hey Guest. Check out your NeoGAF Wrapped 2025 results here!

Supergirl | Official Teaser Trailer

nothing in dc's most recent live action stuff had anyone "feastin", and nothing in their future output will either if this sad trailer is any indication.

Nah, we feastin' alright

lcNYgmk.png


dGOvlNj.png


h6a6sj2.png



Social media has been fun today, lots of enthusiasm for Supergirl. I need to remember to check in early to make sure I can preorder the 4K UHD and not have to wait on it like I did with Superman - which kept selling out at Amazon, Best Buy, and Target. It took me a month to get one. I am not going to repeat that mistake with this movie.
 
As soon as you stick Blondie's Call Me on a Supergirl trailer that's supposed to be the hardcore and traumatized version of the character (quoting Gunn himself here) you've just announced your intentions. They're aiming for the general public, they want it to speak to the TikTok generation, they want YouTube views and memes with Krypto peeing.


sad batman GIF


At this point I'm just tired of Gunn running DC into the ground, WTF is that shit? Woman of Tomorrow should ooze epicenes, drama, desperation. Utterly beautiful and soul crushing at the same time.

Not this light humor and goofiness. Krypto peeing on Superman, really? Is the dog gonna fart in the spaceship? Also glad that Gunn brought GOTG's Ravager with him at DC....

7k3WDccb_o.png


OH WAIT that's Krem LMAO -_-
That's crazy, Gunn didn't even direct this one...
 
Nah, we feastin' alright
nobody's feastin, superman was trash and the season finale for peacemaker was some of the worst tv to date, all right after Joker 2 which was maybe the worst movie I've ever seen.
Now this teaser which completely shits on the source material because of the incessant need to inject "guardians" vibes into everything.

bad movies endless trash GIF
 
If anyone is even remotely, slightly curious about the Supergirl TV series...I've suffered through all of it and the only season I'd truly recommend watching is Season 4. It introduces both Agent Liberty and Lex Luthor and has a good story involving how both managed to slowly sow public distrust against Supergirl. And I promise it's better than using a network of CGI monkeys to type troll comments on social media.

Agent Liberty was played by Sam Witwer, who did a fantastic job.

agent-liberty-was-probably-the-best-villain-on-supergirl-v0-v695okqjc5zc1.jpeg


The writing for the show suddenly shot up in quality this specific season and stayed consistently good with good plot twists. Probably one of the most random good moments to happen for such a mediocre show.
 
If anyone is even remotely, slightly curious about the Supergirl TV series...I've suffered through all of it and the only season I'd truly recommend watching is Season 4. It introduces both Agent Liberty and Lex Luthor and has a good story involving how both managed to slowly sow public distrust against Supergirl. And I promise it's better than using a network of CGI monkeys to type troll comments on social media.

Agent Liberty was played by Sam Witwer, who did a fantastic job.

agent-liberty-was-probably-the-best-villain-on-supergirl-v0-v695okqjc5zc1.jpeg


The writing for the show suddenly shot up in quality this specific season and stayed consistently good with good plot twists. Probably one of the most random good moments to happen for such a mediocre show.
I think I noped out of Supergirl (and the whole berlanti-verse, I think) after s3 of supergirl because I don't recall Witwers character at all. About all I really recall from the show was the leads UNDENIABLE attraction to one of her co-stars over her own husband (I believe she partner swapped at some point) and the morose sister dealing with her lesbian love life. Sheesh.
 
But why?!
I kept up with it because they would do giant crossover episodes with Arrow (which I liked), Black Lightning (which I liked enough), Legends of Tomorrow (which was fun enough), and Flash (which slowly got worse).

Their crossovers were always cool plots that always made me feel they all would have been a better TV series if they had simply combined them into one show to tell individual plot lines, like Justice League Unlimited, instead of doing the 'villain of the week' thing with each individual show.

Edit: The crossovers also had fun moments that would remind me of the cartoons:

Like when Flash and Arrow switched lives:



or when they had to fight their Earth-X dopplegangers:



or when Constantine met Lucifer:



or when the villains of each show teamed up but were ready to backstab each other at a moment's notice:



Is it low budget? Yes. Is it cheesy? Yes. But I had some fun overall 🤷‍♂️
 
Last edited:
At this point I'm just tired of Gunn running DC into the ground, WTF is that shit? Woman of Tomorrow should ooze epicenes, drama, desperation. Utterly beautiful and soul crushing at the same time.

Not this light humor and goofiness. Krypto peeing on Superman, really? Is the dog gonna fart in the spaceship? Also glad that Gunn brought GOTG's Ravager with him at DC....
The story it's based on had lots of humor in it? Did you read Woman of tomorrow?. This seems to be tracking pretty close.

The drinking and partying is covering up the void inside and the loneliness she feels as the last survivor of krypton that actually lived there with memories of it . It pivots between her just trying to forget and have fun and being dragged back into very dark situations.

I really liked the comic series and I trust James Gunn to deliver on this. I have liked everything he has done so far.
 
The story it's based on had lots of humor in it? Did you read Woman of tomorrow?. This seems to be tracking pretty close.
Not this type of humor. Yeah I read it (a few years ago tho for sure) and I don't remember stupid "jokes" like those.

The drinking and partying is covering up the void inside and the loneliness she feels as the last survivor of krypton that actually lived there with memories of it . It pivots between her just trying to forget and have fun and being dragged back into very dark situations.
Yep.

I really liked the comic series and I trust James Gunn to deliver on this. I have liked everything he has done so far.
I hated everything he did with DC :messenger_pensive:
 
I think I noped out of Supergirl (and the whole berlanti-verse, I think) after s3 of supergirl because I don't recall Witwers character at all.
Him and Lex were both introduced in Season 4 and Agent Liberty was only in that season, which ended up being a good thing because the more a character stays on the show the more their writing suffers. Season 4 can technically be seen on it's own because of how it's written.

Right after season 4, it goes right back to it's villain of the week by-the-numbers storytelling, which is why season 4 is such an anomaly.
 
not close at all, the comic has some humorous bits but it's not the focus at all, it's very straight played serious most of the time.
I remember a bunch of goofy stuff in it. Again with underlying dark themes. Most of the interactions with the young girl are written with humor, several of the fight scenes have humor in them. One of the planets is completely ridiculous that they visit.
 
Supergirl: Teen Pop Edition.

Only cool thing was the ending logo had that silhouette thing on it.

Not into superhero movies to begin with unless it's Batman or Blade, but never understood the attraction to Superman. I did like Man of Steel mainly because it was a darker Batman-ish kind of realistic vibe to it. But the character himself, aside from kryptonite sapping his powers, whats the point of all these giant fights if he can always survive them no problem?

Is Supergirl similar? Can only be killed with kryptonite?
 
"Ok it does not look like this is gonna end well... (Dramatic pause) For YOU guys!"

- Some creatively bankrupt Millennial writer

iu
It's her FIRST movie, cut her some slack!!
qYAaYnjagprGEUNy.jpg

n7rGkpY1Anzf66Mc.jpg


I wonder perhaps if she was hired for...other qualities.

But maybe she has been cranking out scripts for years and doing uncredited rewrites, then was just the best of the scripts DC commissioned for a possible supergirl movie. She's a total unknown to us so who kniws?
 
It's her FIRST movie, cut her some slack!!
qYAaYnjagprGEUNy.jpg

n7rGkpY1Anzf66Mc.jpg


I wonder perhaps if she was hired for...other qualities.

But maybe she has been cranking out scripts for years and doing uncredited rewrites, then was just the best of the scripts DC commissioned for a possible supergirl movie. She's a total unknown to us so who kniws?
Unironically her appearance and her past work is exactly what I was imagining. In my mind it was a wine sipping Millennial Karen with little to no interest in comics/superhero stuff that was likely a nepo hire. Probably wrote the whole thing sitting on a window nook while listening to true crime podcasts with scented candles spread around.
 
The best i can say is Milly Alcock looks gorgeous in the movie. The rest... not so much. And, i can't get over Krypto peeing on Superman.
 
The best i can say is Milly Alcock looks gorgeous in the movie. The rest... not so much. And, i can't get over Krypto peeing on Superman.

So irreverent,

I believe hollywood script writers have just walked around with that word written on a piece of paper for the last decade or so.

"Do you have a resume?"
hands over piece of paper with irreverent written on it.

"Do you have a script idea?"
hands over piece of paper with irreverent written on it.

"What trait should our main character espouse?"
hands over piece of paper with irreverent written on it.
 
So they spent lots of time and money promoting the dog to be Superman's friend and all that stuff. Only tou have the dog piss on Superman's pic on a news paper. Why?

What a piece of shit trailer. Hope Ai replaces Hollywood.
 
Is Supergirl similar? Can only be killed with kryptonite?
superman is not some kind of special anomaly per se, every kryptonian under a yellow sun becomes that strong.
They can be killed by other kryptonians, or basically beings as strong or stronger, advanced tech, psychic attacks, magic, after depowering (either removing them long enough from a yellow sun, or forcing red sun radiation on them), or very long exposure to kryptonite radiation.
 
Being in space with various aliens of different worlds with some might have strength that rival hers, there is nothing about the movie that make Supergirl seem special.

The Guardians of the Galaxy vibe here is so strong it makes me think if there will be some characters from the MCU making a cameo.

Gunn universe is a mistake.
 
The problem with superman is already its to boring to watch because he's to overpowered. An C tier version of it isn't going to be remotely interesting. Zero interest in this.

They should make another thor movie.
 
Last edited:
The problem with superman is already its to boring to watch because he's to overpowered. An C tier version of it isn't going to be remotely interesting. Zero interest in this.

They should make another thor movie.
Accurate + they keep trying to make Superman not Super, i.e., they keep trying to humanize his morality even though he's a God on Earth.

Superman/Supergirl/Superdog etc. only works when the enemy is as equally or more powerful than them. A green rock isn't a juicy enough adversary. Without spoiling anything, they sorta understood this with the last Superman movie but failed to stick the landing because they (yet again) tried to humanize Superman.
 
Man, she's rocking that costume like no tomorrow. Did she ever appear alongside Henry Cavill in any of the previous DCEU movies?
No, it was an alternate timeline/earth. She was good as the character but Gunn essentially rebooted everything.

From the comments you get the impression she was amazing but she was not. She did a solid job and looked unique(darker complexion/dark hair) as supergirl but her performance was not something where you would say "what else has she been in I want to see it!"
 
Supergirl: Teen Pop Edition.

Only cool thing was the ending logo had that silhouette thing on it.

Not into superhero movies to begin with unless it's Batman or Blade, but never understood the attraction to Superman. I did like Man of Steel mainly because it was a darker Batman-ish kind of realistic vibe to it. But the character himself, aside from kryptonite sapping his powers, whats the point of all these giant fights if he can always survive them no problem?

Is Supergirl similar? Can only be killed with kryptonite?
When it comes to Supes what should be a draw is the writing, his judgement and wisdom when it comes to using his powers, the restraints he puts on himself to not hurt innocents.
 
Last edited:
superman is not some kind of special anomaly per se, every kryptonian under a yellow sun becomes that strong.
They can be killed by other kryptonians, or basically beings as strong or stronger, advanced tech, psychic attacks, magic, after depowering (either removing them long enough from a yellow sun, or forcing red sun radiation on them), or very long exposure to kryptonite radiation.
Then the question becomes "how well known are kryptonian weaknesses"? Kryptonite, being sequestered inside their planet/not made yet, is exceedingly rare pre-explosion, but the other weaknesses, particularly magic, seem like things Kryptonians would want kept a secret. The Lantern Corps, in particular, sems like a group that would devote significant resources towards thwarting Kryptonians should they go rogue. Or are Kryptonians relatively unknown to the broader universe?
 
"Feastin'"? Gunn's Superman is the lowest box office performer WITHOUT adjusting for inflation. Man of Steel and B v S beat it. And this one has the "premium ticket prices" that the other two didn't have.

It may be a good movie, I'm not discrediting that. But did it move the needle? Not even a bit.
 
Last edited:
When it comes to Supes what should be a draw is the writing, his judgement and wisdom when it comes to using his powers, the restraints he puts on himself to not hurt innocents.
Exactly. Supes should be put into situations where there is an EASY solution, but one that is morally questionable, versus one that is HARD but morally right. He always goes for the hard, but right, choice instead of the easy one. He can't be written like a normal dude with a couple of powers, he is a MYTHIC being. Clark is his attempt to imitate humans with all their frailties, which is why he's a bit of a charicature. Yes, I'm aware that's the QT take from Kill Bill but I think it's astute. You can't really make an engaging film writing him like that, at least not one that heavily focuses on Supes, but that ideal should always be in the writers mind when they construct dialogue for him.
 
Top Bottom