Wow this thread got huuuge, but the discussion is running in circles. Still those phone comparisons....
Here's my stance: i don't care anymore, i just bought a new PC, because we're 2,5 years into this generation and honestly, the console hardware doesn't really matter at all. As of now, the only game that really justifies my PS4 purchase is Bloodborne.(+Bought a WiiU for Smash and Bayo2 - not going to happen again) My 2nd favourite game of this gen MGSV is also on PC. I turned 40 and I'm a much more conscious gamer nowadays and I don't get hyped by the formulaic AAA titles, so the overall library of both major console is pretty sparse and unvaried imo (not counting indies) at the moment.
But... don't some people in this thread get the simple psychology that some of us will get into a 2nd class citizen mentality if their dedication to console is not strong enough to support this plan? I totally share/understand this sentiment. For example you buy a IPhone primarily for communicating with others (text messages, via phone) or surfing the inet - a newer IPhone model doesn't change things in this regard, because CPUs and GPU in the mobile sector don't affect this core aspect. The quality of text messages and sound quality hasn't changed drastically in the last years. Those who buy the newest Iphones to be able to run some new demanding apps or games...well, we don't know for sure if this is a driving factor behind the constant success of IPhone. Gaming? Totally different...let's say that consumer x will never consider PC gaming and is dedicated to console gaming = 200-250 mio. people last gen. Let's say he's casual, meaning a person with average income who also buys a new phone, TV, car once in a while. He will spend his hard earned money on one console and -until now- lives in some kind of safe bubble 'I have the best console out there and I'm safe for at least 5 years' - now two years down the line a better version is released. Is it so hard to understand that there may be some people who feel bad about having bought a console which has become a 2nd grade console after 2 years? You can't really compare resolution and fps increases to better processor and design specs of phones.
Well, we will see. If things go horribly wrong, customers will act NOT like mobile phone customers, meaning they will learn to wait, getting most value for their bucks, thus no more day one launch hype, which is a disaster for a front-loaded industry like the gaming industry. If the majority accepts this new launch-schedule, we're ok, but I can see lots of former console only gamers going PC, because they will learn about the technical buzz-words once they they are asking themselves 'what's different in PS4.5?' and when they start doing the math: 3 consoles á 400€ in 6 years= 1200€ (if they want to be on top of their game) and every friggin iteration will still be weaker than a above mid-range PC.
Edit: LOL, I have found a good example concerning the whole 'having more options' topic: You and a girl have survived a plane crash and you find yourself on a deserted island.
The girl by your normal standards (living in city with lots of options an opportunities) is OK. In this case it is way easier to commit to this woman than under your normal living conditions and saying something like 'you are the most beautiful woman in this world' is not that hard. You may engage in a island marriage ritual and you arrange yourself with the conditions given in that situation. Now that situation changes...it turn out that another girl has survived the plane crash and she's 10/10 material going by your past and present living conditions. How do you feel now?