I do like the idea of a female Cid. Cidney is embarrassing, though.
Although she's really no worse than Tifa design wise, her portrayal and personality aren't exactly saving graces.
Tifa was actually hot though, and had the depth of character and competence of battle to complement her status in the game as female heroine alongside Aerith.
CIdney feels like they just designed a female character model, and then made a very impractical outfit for fan service just as a mechanical device to fix the car and then made a whole bunch of pervy DLC and extra content for zooming in on her in creepy angles.