• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Nintendo Switch HD Rumble

Skyzard

Banned
Being able to feel water filling a glass sounds great. Not sure about it outside of when the system is docked though-battery life.
 
The more I read impressions from the hands on, the more excited I'm getting about the Switch. The impressions are even making me want 1,2 Switch, which I didn't think was possible.
 

Linkup

Member
HD haptics isn't new. Steam controller and Vive/Touch controllers have it. What might be new is if they put more than one, but I think the patents showed just one. It would be nice to get a answer about how it compared to Vive/Touch controller haptics.
 

KHlover

Banned
People don't know what they want until you show it to them


=)



I wasn't joking. I think star wars with HD rumble would be good (going by impressions)

Do I think it will happen? No. Atleast not yet.

Won't EVER happen because EA has the exclusive license for Star Wars games on consoles.
 

cyba89

Member
Reading this thread it's just baffling that 1,2 Switch isn't a pack-in game with the console.
Or at least go Wii Play style and bundle it with a Joy-Con controller.
 
HD haptics isn't new. Steam controller and Vive/Touch controllers have it. What might be new is if they put more than one, but I think the patents showed just one. It would be nice to get a answer about how it compared to Vive/Touch controller haptics.

It's new in the console space.
 

Aostia

El Capitan Todd
Reading this thread it's just baffling that 1,2 Switch isn't a pack-in game with the console.
Or at least go Wii Play style and bundle it with a Joy-Con controller.


I agree
I have read great impression on the feature but will be buried at launch
 
Reading this thread it's just baffling that 1,2 Switch isn't a pack-in game with the console.
Or at least go Wii Play style and bundle it with a Joy-Con controller.
The console comes with two Joy-Cons already, which is one of their selling points.

And I don't want to imagine what that bundle would cost.
 

Nerazar

Member
Won't EVER happen because EA has the exclusive license for Star Wars games on consoles.

If the Switch sells some units, it will happen - the Wii even got Force Unleashed.

But on topic:

This is very interesting! I think that this kind of rumble increases immersion in a good way in almost every gaming setting. We're stepping closer towards full VR experiences :)

I sure hope that Zelda uses the feature extensively - the amount of sidequests and minigames inside it (fishing, swimming, horse riding ...) would allow for enhanced gameplay.
 

efyu_lemonardo

May I have a cookie?
If EA think they can make money out of it, they'll do it.
More like: if similar or better tech exists on a number of competing platforms EA will make a game for those platforms. Then if they think they can make money out of it, they'll release a half assed port on Switch.
 

geordiemp

Member
HD haptics isn't new. Steam controller and Vive/Touch controllers have it. What might be new is if they put more than one, but I think the patents showed just one. It would be nice to get a answer about how it compared to Vive/Touch controller haptics.

I can see how haptics may help the feel in VR games when you are doing room scale and interacting with objects.... I have yet to jump into VR yet and still on the fence weather VIVE or other. I need to try it.

However, cant see the point of it for a normal console experience, looks like a pointless gimmick.

A decent IR pointer that would allow absolute light gun games on LED panels would of been more useful imo
 
Surprised there was some skepticism in this thread about the HD Rumble claims. Haptic feedback is legit. Almost 20 years ago I had a mouse with haptic feedback that could simulate different surfaces and sensations including the squeaky scraping of chalk on a chalkboard. I am absolutely positive you can really feel different ice cubes / liquid and other things "inside" the Joy Cons.

Now, perhaps more relevant is the fact that that mouse was DOA because nothing used the feedback tech except for Black And White.

Edit: Those old MS Sidewinder force feedback joysticks had a lightsaber simulation in the demo settings.
 

Rebel Leader

THE POWER OF BUTTERSCOTCH BOTTOMS
Surprised there was some skepticism in this thread about the HD Rumble claims. Haptic feedback is legit. Almost 20 years ago I had a mouse with haptic feedback that could simulate different surfaces and sensations including the squeaky scraping of chalk on a chalkboard. I am absolutely positive you can really feel different ice cubes / liquid and other things "inside" the Joy Cons.

Now, perhaps more relevant is the fact that that mouse was DOA because nothing used the feedback tech except for Black And White.

Edit: Those old MS Sidewinder force feedback joysticks had a lightsaber simulation in the demo settings.

I think the skepticism also has to do with the price of the switch.and never used anything that had anything like haptic feedback
 
More like: if similar or better tech exists on a number of competing platforms EA will make a game for those platforms. Then if they think they can make money out of it, they'll release a half assed port on Switch.
I'm more thinking that they might make a "light saber battles" type game utilising the Switch tech if they thought it profitable.

I in no way harbour any thoughts that EA would release a big budget AAA Star Wars title exclusively on a Nintendo system.

That's just common sense.


Surprised there was some skepticism in this thread about the HD Rumble claims. Haptic feedback is legit. Almost 20 years ago I had a mouse with haptic feedback that could simulate different surfaces and sensations including the squeaky scraping of chalk on a chalkboard. I am absolutely positive you can really feel different ice cubes / liquid and other things "inside" the Joy Cons.

Now, perhaps more relevant is the fact that that mouse was DOA because nothing used the feedback tech except for Black And White.

Edit: Those old MS Sidewinder force feedback joysticks had a lightsaber simulation in the demo settings.
It's funny, the haptic feedback rumours involving Nintendo systems have been flying around since when we were still calling the Wii "Revolution" and finally, here we are. Better late than never.

Maybe Nintendo have been experimenting with it all this time, like they did with glassless 3D tech back in the Gamecube days?

Makes me wonder what they're experimenting with right now.
 

efyu_lemonardo

May I have a cookie?
I'm more thinking that they might make a "light saber battles" type game utilising the Switch tech if they thought it profitable.

I in no way harbour any thoughts that EA would release a big budget AAA Star Wars title exclusively on a Nintendo system.

That's just common sense.

I have more faith in Namco and/or Grasshopper making a laser sword/beam katana game.
 

marc^o^

Nintendo's Pro Bono PR Firm
HD haptics isn't new. Steam controller and Vive/Touch controllers have it. What might be new is if they put more than one, but I think the patents showed just one. It would be nice to get a answer about how it compared to Vive/Touch controller haptics.
I have a Vive and I have yet to see use cases such as described in 1,2 Switch. It could be just software related, perhaps. I'm not convinced.
 

Formless

Member
This thing I've never experienced isn't what I wanted, so it's a gimmick!

It seems like some people think it's the real deal after impressions, so I can imagine some useful stuff for it (NMH3 will have obvious uses)
 

random25

Member
If anything, I want Nintendo themselves to do some swordfighting game that utilizes HD rumble to the fullest. They have The Mysterious Murasame Castle franchise to revive after all.

I'm not giving suggestions, btw.
 

spekkeh

Banned
I have a Vive and I have yet to see use cases such as described in 1,2 Switch. It could be just software related, perhaps. I'm not convinced.
I think it's just the thumbpad that has it? Same with iphone/macbook. That's very different from feeling it all over your hand.
 
Tell that to EA. Meanwhile Suda has already confirmed he's working on a new Travis Touchdown game for Switch.
He has confirmed he is thinking about starting production of a game that involves a character from one of his past games.

To be exact.

That speech was a shitshow.

EDIT: and something involving indies helping if I understood correctly? (It was confusing)
 

efyu_lemonardo

May I have a cookie?
He has confirmed he is thinking about starting production of a game that involves a character from one of his past games.

To be exact.

That speech was a shitshow.

EDIT: and something involving indies helping if I understood correctly? (It was confusing)

Indeed it was rather pointless and a bit sad. SEGA's appearance I can at least excuse as an "honor and respect" thing.
 

JaseMath

Member
Looking forward to the feature. The only thing that bugs me is—seriously—the name. HD Rumble is so unimaginative; it should've been called Hi-Fi Rumble and there's a good reason why.

Hi-Fi is shorthand for "High Fidelity" and fidelity is defined as the following:
Fidelity: The degree of exactness with which something is copied or reproduced

That definition is exactly what Nintendo is hoping to achieve with this new tech, so, from here on, I'm going to call it Hi-Fi Rumble even if Nintendo doesn't. It makes more sense and sounds better. :D
 

robotrock

Banned
Looking forward to the feature. The only thing that bugs me is—seriously—the name. HD Rumble is so unimaginative; it should've been called Hi-Fi Rumble and there's a good reason why.

Hi-Fi is shorthand for "High Fidelity" and fidelity is defined as the following:
Fidelity: The degree of exactness with which something is copied or reproduced

So, from here on, I'm going to call it Hi-Fi Rumble even if Nintendo doesn't. It makes more sense and sounds better. :D

They both sound just about equally lame
 
Looking forward to the feature. The only thing that bugs me is—seriously—the name. HD Rumble is so unimaginative; it should've been called Hi-Fi Rumble and there's a good reason why.

Hi-Fi is shorthand for "High Fidelity" and fidelity is defined as the following:
Fidelity: The degree of exactness with which something is copied or reproduced

That definition is exactly what Nintendo is hoping to achieve with this new tech, so, from here on, I'm going to call it Hi-Fi Rumble even if Nintendo doesn't. It makes more sense and sounds better. :D

lol nice
 
Looking forward to the feature. The only thing that bugs me is—seriously—the name. HD Rumble is so unimaginative; it should've been called Hi-Fi Rumble and there's a good reason why.

Hi-Fi is shorthand for "High Fidelity" and fidelity is defined as the following:
Fidelity: The degree of exactness with which something is copied or reproduced

That definition is exactly what Nintendo is hoping to achieve with this new tech, so, from here on, I'm going to call it Hi-Fi Rumble even if Nintendo doesn't. It makes more sense and sounds better. :D

By that logic high fidelity makes more sense for resolution as well
 
This thing I've never experienced isn't what I wanted, so it's a gimmick!

It seems like some people think it's the real deal after impressions, so I can imagine some useful stuff for it (NMH3 will have obvious uses)

I'm trying to stay optimistic. Here's hoping it blows me away.
 

Tripolygon

Banned
Looking forward to the feature. The only thing that bugs me is—seriously—the name. HD Rumble is so unimaginative; it should've been called Hi-Fi Rumble and there's a good reason why.

Hi-Fi is shorthand for "High Fidelity" and fidelity is defined as the following:
Fidelity: The degree of exactness with which something is copied or reproduced

That definition is exactly what Nintendo is hoping to achieve with this new tech, so, from here on, I'm going to call it Hi-Fi Rumble even if Nintendo doesn't. It makes more sense and sounds better. :D
The name is gotten from the field of HD Haptics, as in high definition haptics. High definition because these new haptic devices provide a wide degree of fine control compared to the currently popular eccentric rotating mass motors.
 

Rizific

Member
as someone who turns off rumble in any game that allows it, this just screams huge gimmick to me. if hd rumble is the reason for the ridiculous price of the joycon, then i would have rather had a cheaper controller without the gimmick.
 

marc^o^

Nintendo's Pro Bono PR Firm
as someone who turns off rumble in any game that allows it, this just screams huge gimmick to me. if hd rumble is the reason for the ridiculous price of the joycon, then i would have rather had a cheaper controller without the gimmick.
If you can feel the texture of roads in Mario Kart, it means most games can benefit from it. I don't mind we pay few more dollars for controllers. Nintendo shot for the best, not using a cheap rumble component.

Worst case scenario, it will make some other controllers rumble feel like Wii U's GamePad rumble.
 

FallAgain

Member
Only 1-2-Switch really utilises this feature imo. I think the game were you need to guess how many balls are in the box showcases this feature really well. If other games outside 1-2-Switch are utilising this feature, I didn't notice anything while playing them.
 

zroid

Banned
The way it was described by a Switch developer on a certain podcast I listened to today was very illuminating

sounds pretty darn cool, although the question will remain how much will it actually be used
 

marc^o^

Nintendo's Pro Bono PR Firm
The way it was described by a Switch developer on a certain podcast I listened to today was very illuminating

sounds pretty darn cool, although the question will remain how much will it actually be used
Link?
 

Cuburt

Member
He has confirmed he is thinking about starting production of a game that involves a character from one of his past games.

To be exact.

That speech was a shitshow.

EDIT: and something involving indies helping if I understood correctly? (It was confusing)
Well, to be exact, he says
"Travis Touchdown will be making his return on Nintendo Switch."
Then they show a picture of Travis wearing a shirt that says "Travis strikes again."
"This star will be coming onto Nintendo Switch."

He didn't say anything about "a character from one of his past games". Don't know where you got that from. It may not be a No More Heroes sequel per se, but it involves Travis Touchdown again.
 
Top Bottom