Support NeoGAF

[Link]

December is so far away.....

 

[Unison]

So basically TP is as good as Bully.

It's more on par with Project Gotham Racing 3, I think.

 

[g23]

I LOVE 1up!!!

 

[AniHawk]

it's not as cut and dry as that, I suppose. but I told luke tonight his zelda trolling needs to improve, because I'm totally in the Parish-hausen camp.

Who will be doing the reviews in EGM?

 

[aktham]

more like on par with madden 03

(which was a good game )

 

[skip]

Who will be doing the reviews in EGM?

jeremy, shane and crispin. and that's pretty much all the info I have about the EGM side of things.

 

[Tiktaalik]

I called it!

now IGN and Gamespot have to give it 10/10s and i'll be 100% right.

are there spoilers in the review?

 

[Y2Kev]

Woohoo! I'm loving this notion that TP is very story driven. That makes me excited.

 

[AniHawk]

jeremy, shane and crispin. and that's pretty much all the info I have about the EGM side of things.

That's all I wanted to know. Thanks.

 

[Unison]

It would be funny if everyone hated Zelda and attacked Parish for massively overrating the game. :lol

 

[Link]

What was the last game to get a 10/10/10 in EGM? Halo 2?

 

[QuickKick89]

It would be funny if everyone hated Zelda and attacked Parish for massively overrating the game. :lol

See, now if it was GTA, Halo, Madden, or Final Fantasy, then yes.

However, nobody hates Zelda, except anti-Nintendo trolls.

 

[Maridia]

I called it!

now IGN and Gamespot have to give it 10/10s and i'll be 100% right.

are there spoilers in the review?

:lol


If it's the ****er from the GS video doing the review, I predict that your predictions sink like the Titanic.

 

[Muppet345]

That's all I wanted to know. Thanks.

I haven't been here long. I hate asking this, but who is skip? :3

 

[Vic]

hmm...I wonder how much 9's Famitsu is going to give for this game. One? two?

 

[Ginko]

nice!

looking forword for the next 1up yours.

 

[ethelred]

:lol


If it's the ****er from the GS video doing the review, I predict that your predictions sink like the Titanic.

Gerstmann will probably give it an 8.2.

hmm...I wonder how much 9's Famitsu is going to give for this game. One? two?

Hopefully the series will get its third 40.

 

[AniHawk]

I haven't been here long. I hate asking this, but who is skip? :3

toastyfrog = jeremy
scoot = luke
skip = andrew?

 

[GhaleonEB]

What was the last game to get a 10/10/10 in EGM? Halo 2?

Halo 2 and GTA: SA did it in the same issue. I don't think anything else has pulled it off since. The next issue has Gears and Zelda, and we know they both get at least one from the 1up reviews.

 

[unifin]

:lol - I knew what the score would be before I opened the topic -

Only 67 replies? Must be a 10.

 

[Error]

hmm...I wonder how much 9's Famitsu is going to give for this game. One? two?

Im pretty sure famitsu will give it a 40/40 to TP

both WW and OOT got perfect scores in Famitsu.

 

[Firestorm]

toastyfrog = jeremy
scoot = luke
skip = andrew?

I thought skip = Sam Kennedy?

 

[Maridia]

Gerstmann will probably give it an 8.2.



Hopefully the series will get its third 40.

I don't really care whether it hits #1 at GameRankings or not, but that guy's lack of enthusiasm was awe-inspiring. I predict 8.6.

 

[quaere]

Well written. That review really sold me on the game, a lot more than some other recent 1up reviews convinced me certain games were flawed. And I haven't even played a Zelda game other than a couple hours of Ocarina of Time.

 

[Lobster]

How come the overall is 9.9...I don't get it.

 

[gamergirly]

What was the last game to get a 10/10/10 in EGM? Halo 2?

It's been about 2 years then

 

[Sathsquatch]

Gerstmann gave OOT a 10.

I kind of doubt that it can get a 10 at Gamespot, but I do think it will easily get a 9.6+. I thinks probably going to get above a 9.6 actually, making it the first game to do so at Gamespot since Metroid Prime four years ago.

 

[Link]

Hopefully the series will get its third 40.

Crazy how Zelda could end up with nearly half of Famitsu's perfect scores by itself.

 

[AniHawk]

Gerstmann gave OOT a 10.

I kind of doubt that it can get a 10 at Gamespot, but I do think it will easily get a 9.6+. I thinks probably going to get above a 9.6 actually, making it the first game to do so at Gamespot since Metroid Prime four years ago.

Metroid Prime got a 9.7 at Gamespot.

 

[tracky_dacks]

I expected no less.
This is going to be the highest rated game of the year.

I thought skip = Sam Kennedy?

Nope skip is Andrew Pfister (sp?).

 

[Pikelet]

Gamespot wont give this game a ten. Im betting a low nine, 9.4 at most

 

[psycho_snake]

It will be interesting to see what IGN and Gamesot gives Zelda: TP. If gamespot give it a really high score then I know its going to be a very good game. Their reviews are usually very reliable, nearly every game that gamespot has given a 9+ is an amazing game.

 

[aktham]

i lost faith in famitsu after seeing nintendogs get a perfect, not to mention some other crappy games that score well.

 

[btrboyev]

just 2 more days

 

[Stinkles]

10? Zelda exceeds normal gaming. 1Up bias proven at last.

 

[CajoleJuice]

Metroid Prime got a 9.7 at Gamespot.

And it kills you inside.

 

[EphemeralDream]

ohweback.jpg.

I haven't played a 3D Zelda in 5-6 years and I've almost forgotten how great those experiences were. Hopefully this game will reestablish those great memories as truth. Otherwise, great review although it does spoil some stuff gameplay-side.

 

[AniHawk]

And it kills you inside.

So very slowly.

 

[psycho_snake]

Metroid Prime got a 9.7 at Gamespot.

It was a well deserved score.

I expect Gamespot to give the game 9+, its even possible that it could reach 9.7, 9.8, but I dont think that gamespot will give it a perfect score. Ocarina of time only got a perfect score from gamespot because the game changed from 2d to 3d and Nintendo pulled it off perfectly. If TP is goign to get a perfect score, then the game has got to make a massive leap from all the other Zelda games.

 

[Spire]

Go Go Gamespot

 

[Bboy AJ]

GameSpy

 

[HolyCheck]

ugh... i clicked that... saw the score.. and panicked... then realized you tricked me.

 

[Pikelet]

...And that, along with they're recent videos on wii, is why i don't trust the gamespot review

 

[ethelred]

It was a well deserved score.

I expect Gamespot to give the game 9+, its even possible that it could reach 9.7, 9.8, but I dont think that gamespot will give it a perfect score. Ocarina of time only got a perfect score from gamespot because the game changed from 2d to 3d and Nintendo pulled it off perfectly. If TP is goign to get a perfect score, then the game has got to make a massive leap from all the other Zelda games.

Spoiler

Waggle.

 

[Link]

There are some bitter pricks in this thread. Can you spot them?

Anyone that hates on Zelda shouldn't be playing videogames.

 

[Tieno]

There are some bitter pricks in this thread. Can you spot them?

Anyone that hates on Zelda shouldn't be playing videogames.

Hey, I like Zelda and all, but it's not the end and be all game for everyone.

 

[Link]

Hey, I like Zelda and all, but it's not the end and be all game for everyone.

Anyone that hates on Zelda.....

 

[Bloodwake]

Good, but expected.

I would say that this is the GOTY right here for most publications/websites.

 

[AniHawk]

Jeff is bound to give it the 8.0 I thought Jeremy would give it. If I'm wrong, may we all be horribly crushed from above somehow.

 

[Ristamar]

Didn't Gerstmann give Wind Waker a 9.3? Judging from all the impressions and reviews I've seen thus far, I can't reasonably see how he'd score Twilight Princess lower...