Tom Nook Sawyer
Member
Doesn't most of this apply to the Smash 4 roster leaks?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Reddit: leaked Paper Mario TTYD 3D? (Real or Fake)
- Thread starter DoktorEvil
- Start date
Doesn't most of this apply to the Smash 4 roster leaks?
Different strokes. While I agree that the Zelda games are definitely improved in the transition from N64 to 3DS, I have kind of an archivist mindset about it. My feeling is that, in a media that's saturated with re-makes, re-releases, and re-boots, video games are the medium that actually benefits the most from this trend. I prioritize image quality, and I love to see classics translated to modern standards in that regard. I had no bones about paying an extra $10 to get the Wind Waker HD compared to Ocarina 3D.
But, anyway, this is fake as all get-out.
KuwabaraTheMan
Banned
Obvious fake. But it still hurts.
shadowsdarknes
Member
Id guess fake. It doesn't really seem like a game that needs to exist.
There shouldn't be a technical reason why this would be locked to new 3DS. Any platform lock would be arbitrary rather than necessary, Xenoblade.
this could literally just be him playing a video of Thousand Year Door on the 3DS or something.
3DS
GCN
This is definitely fake I'm thinking though.
DoktorEvil
Banned
Don't toy with everyone's emotions here. Reveal your source.
HUELEN10
Member
Rarely do I call out something like this, but no one is a saint...
What the heck is wrong with you?
W-What.... I don't understand....
DICKS AHOY
Banned
you're not good people
Regulus Tera
Romanes Eunt Domus
Good times, good times in those smash threads.
Beelzebufo
Banned
I'm going with fake, but that'd be super cool. Hopefully it's not New 3DS exclusive, but I'd guess it would be if we're just getting it now.
Jesus Christ man. Does sugar taste like acid to you as well?
Can you see nature in more than monochrome?
Why is shulk a shop'd mac?
Regulus Tera
Romanes Eunt Domus
The character selection screen looks fake, not up to Sakurai's wife's standards!
Watch Da Birdie
I buy cakes for myself on my birthday it's not weird lots of people do it I bet
But with the Smash leak that was new content for a game we knew was in development, and only a month away...getting a leak made sense.
This is a leak of a ported old game, meaning it'd be very easy to fake at a bare minimum since everything is there more or less, and hasn't even been announced yet so it's unlikely we'd see it being played on a 3DS like that.
I don't think they're comparable.
This is a leak of a ported old game, meaning it'd be very easy to fake at a bare minimum since everything is there more or less, and hasn't even been announced yet so it's unlikely we'd see it being played on a 3DS like that.
I don't think they're comparable.
I guess this will be good for those that have never played it before? So let's hope it's not fake for them.
I could go either way. It'll be 10,000x better than Sticker Star but it'll still be a 11-year old port of a sequel that demands a true sequel with party members and everything.
I could go either way. It'll be 10,000x better than Sticker Star but it'll still be a 11-year old port of a sequel that demands a true sequel with party members and everything.
DICKS AHOY
Banned
why is game & watch comforting wario in the character select screen
TheRedSnifit
Member
This is a bannable offense, right?
Lucky Seven
Banned
Where are the opening logos? No IS logo? No flashy intro?
Hahaha...it makes me nostalgic for some reason.
Hero of Legend
Member
The clip above is fake:
See the bars on top? They're cropping the text bubble, also Nintendo would expand the view point, not crop it.
See the bars on top? They're cropping the text bubble, also Nintendo would expand the view point, not crop it.
The Hermit
Member
ok I´ll bite
#teamreal
Its cool because I´ve never played TTYD
#teamreal
Its cool because I´ve never played TTYD
SolidChamp
Banned
This isn't fucking fair!
grandjedi6
Master of the Google Search
The bottom screen wouldn't be lite up during booting. Therefore: FAKE
Solid SOAP
Member
I think a redone Paper Mario 1 with better visuals and a harder difficulty would be more exciting than a port of Thousand Year Door, tbh. If this is even real, it looks exactly the same. A remake of the original game that gives it a facelift would be infinitely cooler and more worthwhile than... the same game we've played verbatim.
AzureTranquility95
Banned
I'd like to hear your reasoning. I used to like both games equally, but through the years and after many replays, It's getting to the point where I prefer PM64 over TTYD. I was never sure why, though, since TTYD is better than PM64 in almost every way, or so I assume.
Maybe your insight can light a candle on all this.
Are you sure you're not thinking of literally any other game in the Paper Mario Series?
Felix Andrews
Member
Fake.
But if you're listening Nintendo, make it real.
But if you're listening Nintendo, make it real.
Or at the very least start reissuing Gamecube games on Wii U / NX Virtual Console.
Eehhh. This pretty much proves it for me
Well, there you have it.
This person gets it.
PM64 is one of my all time favorite games.
While playing TTYD I felt no joy.
Hero of Legend
Member
The gif in the OP is to me not yet debunked. The bottom screen of the pic below does seem iffy so that might be fake.
All of these could be different sources. But all at the same time though does reduce the odds of it being real. Especially if the two in the OP are from the same person. Hell it's lose-lose; if it's the same person then the "off-ness" of the bottom screen debunks it. But if they're different sources, that makes it too convenient for them to come out at the same time as if this ruse was planned from the start.
All of these could be different sources. But all at the same time though does reduce the odds of it being real. Especially if the two in the OP are from the same person. Hell it's lose-lose; if it's the same person then the "off-ness" of the bottom screen debunks it. But if they're different sources, that makes it too convenient for them to come out at the same time as if this ruse was planned from the start.
AzureTranquility95
Banned
I wouldn't say my time with the game was joyless past the first 10 or so playthroughs, but I start to notice how PM64 had way more charm overall. I can see the argument for TTYD's story being "deeper", however, just because a story is deeper doesn't necessarily mean it's better.
Not trying to say TTYD lacks charm but it definitely lacks something that PM64 had. What exactly, I'm not quite sure.
Dr. Buni
Member
It is not wrong. That is called an opinion. This kind of post shouldn't be allowed here... I don't think TTYD is terrible*, but why not respect the other poster's opinion?
*It was only boring as hell. Both Paper Mario and Super were far more entertaining and charming.
Spyder_Monkey
Banned
Yeah, you're wrong.
EndlessFloydian
Member
This is totally fake, unfortunately, as most of these types of 'leaks' are.
But I am completely on board, so long as this doesn't take away from the development of Paper Mario Wii U.
I'd love a Thousand Year Door remake. I never finished it the first time as my memory card was corrupted and I just never had the heart to start all over again and risk a corruption repeat. So, Nintendo, since you're listening, cue this up next after Xenoblade please~
Smash ESRB of course being the exception.
But I am completely on board, so long as this doesn't take away from the development of Paper Mario Wii U.
Which is an RPG.
With Partners.
Or else.
I'd love a Thousand Year Door remake. I never finished it the first time as my memory card was corrupted and I just never had the heart to start all over again and risk a corruption repeat. So, Nintendo, since you're listening, cue this up next after Xenoblade please~
I think I need to go and lie down for a bit...
Similar threads
- Locked