On the theme of inconsistency, Tom Chick didn't write an official review for Tomb Raider due to a certain conflict of interest (i.e. mock review or consulting for SE or whatever), but he did say on their forums that he would give it a 5/5. He also wrote two articles for the site about how amazing TR is (story and all) when the embargo lifted, and called out other reviewers who criticized TR's story and cast of characters. The issues of combat vs narrative vs tedium vs reality applied to BI and TLoU in his reviews could easily be applied to TR, but yay for refreshing contrarian opinions I guess.