IbizaPocholo
NeoGAFs Kent Brockman
0:00 Intro
01:16 GTA
06:31 GTA 2
09:49 Liberty City Stories
13:12 Chinatown Wars
20:50 Vice City Stories
25:32 GTA V
32:00 GTA III
40:53 Vice City
47:55 San Andreas
55:25 GTA IV
Summary of GTA Series Ranking and Analysis (1997–2013)
This video provides a detailed retrospective and ranking of the main Grand Theft Auto (GTA) games developed by Rockstar Games from GTA 1 (1997) through GTA 5 (2013), excluding spin-offs, ports, and GTA Online. The ranking is subjective and based on gameplay, innovation, story, and overall impact on the gaming industry, with emphasis on how the series evolved over time.
Chronological Timeline and Key Highlights
Key Features and Insights
1997 GTA 1 - Top-down perspective, large urban environment (Liberty City, Vice City, San Andreas)
- Arcade-style point system
- No overarching story; selectable characters
- No in-game map, only physical map
- Missions disappear if failed, no retries
- Live system (limited lives)
- Pain sprays reduce wanted level
- Aggressive cops and difficult navigation
- Two mission packs: London 1969 & 1961
- Groundbreaking but now dated and frustrating to play1999 GTA 2 - Set in "Anywhere USA" with retro-futuristic art style
- Introduced gang system and faction dynamics
- Repeatable missions
- Day/night cycle option (PC)
- Improved visuals and less disorienting driving
- Still no in-game map, but layout simpler than GTA 1
- Cops remain relentless
- More replayability due to gang mission choices
- A better but still flawed sequel2002 GTA Vice City - Set in 1980s Miami-inspired Vice City
- Protagonist Tommy Vercetti voiced by Ray Liotta
- Strong 80s aesthetic and soundtrack (considered best in series)
- More vehicles: bikes, planes, choppers, boats
- 35 weapons categorized
- Ability to enter buildings and change clothes
- Aggressive police with spike strips
- Missions more cinematic and plot-driven
- Some missions notoriously difficult
- Two large islands with some visual similarity between areas
- High nostalgia value and regarded as one of the best2004 GTA San Andreas - Massive map (~30 km²) with three cities: Los Santos, San Fierro, Las Venturas
- CJ's story of gang rebuilding and family drama
- Deep customization: clothes, stats (strength, stamina, etc.)
- Weapon skill leveling
- Dating system and side missions
- Mix of serious drama and absurd missions (tonal whiplash)
- Notable missions like "Wrong Side of the Tracks" and jetpack heist
- Long driving times due to map size
- Lacks mission checkpoints
- One of the most ambitious and iconic GTA titles with over 27 million sales2008 GTA 4 - Protagonist Nico Bellic with a serious, grounded story
- Liberty City rebuilt with high detail and realism
- New Rage engine with realistic vehicle physics and damage
- Cover-based shooting system and refined combat
- In-game smartphone for communication and mission management
- Smaller, more focused map than San Andreas but denser
- Deep character interactions and memorable side characters
- Mature tone with some humor
- Two DLC expansions: The Lost and Damned (dark, addiction theme) and The Ballad of Gay Tony (flashy nightlife)
- Widely regarded as the best GTA game in terms of narrative and gameplay balance2013 GTA 5 - Introduced three protagonists: Franklin, Michael, Trevor
- Large map over 4x bigger than GTA 4
- Emphasis on cinematic storytelling with scripted missions
- Heist missions with crew selection affecting outcomes
- Criticism for limited mission replayability and rigid mission structure
- Some large empty areas on the map
- Mixed tone with serious and goofy moments
- Strong gameplay in combat, driving, and character stats
- Pushed console hardware limits
- Highly popular but ranked lower due to perceived lack of freedom compared to predecessors
Detailed Analysis and Key Insights
GTA 1 & 2: Foundations with Limitations
- GTA 1: Introduced open-world chaos with a top-down view, but lacked modern conveniences like in-game maps and mission retries. The live system and relentless cops made progress frustrating. Despite its dated mechanics, GTA 1 laid the framework for future titles.
- GTA 2: Improved visuals and gang dynamics added complexity and replayability. However, navigation remained confusing without a map, and police difficulty persisted. The unique art style and gang interplay made it a distinct entry.
Liberty City & Vice City Stories: Portable Expansions
- Liberty City Stories (2005): A PSP/PS2 title largely reusing GTA 3's map with minor additions. It lacked innovation and mostly featured familiar characters and weapons.
- Vice City Stories (2006): Added empire-building mechanics focused on rackets, better capturing the 1980s vibe and expanding the original Vice City map. Known for its challenging missions and strong atmosphere but limited by repetitive gameplay.
Chinatown Wars: Innovative Handheld Experience
- Released on Nintendo DS and PSP (2009), Chinatown Wars combined a top-down angled perspective with clever touchpad interactions, such as car hacking and manual weapon assembly. It featured a complex drug-dealing economy and a GPS system, significantly easing navigation.
- Despite some tedious elements like slow gun purchases, it is praised for its innovation and faithful GTA gameplay on handhelds.
GTA 3: The Concrete Foundation
- The first 3D GTA game revolutionized open-world gaming with a living, breathing city and dynamic environment.
- Introduced fully voiced characters, motion-captured cutscenes, and a mini-map.
- Some limitations included no swimming, no motorcycles, and somewhat clunky controls depending on platform.
- The silent protagonist Claude Speed allowed player self-insertion but lacked personality.
- Despite dated mechanics, GTA 3 remains a groundbreaking milestone and a favorite to revisit.
Vice City: Nostalgia and Atmosphere
- Known for its iconic 80s soundtrack and vibrant setting.
- Enhanced vehicle variety and weapons.
- Missions with mini-plots made the story feel more cinematic.
- Some missions are notoriously difficult.
- While not drastically different from GTA 3, it refined and expanded the formula with charm and style.
San Andreas: Ambitious and Expansive
- Monumental increase in map size and gameplay depth.
- Added RPG-like stat systems, vehicle variety, and dating mechanics.
- Memorable missions and characters, including crossovers with GTA 3 figures.
- Some gameplay elements (gang territory control, stats) seen as repetitive or unnecessary.
- Tonal inconsistencies but overall a classic with massive scope.
- Highest-selling GTA game until GTA 5.
GTA 4: Best Execution of the Formula
- Introduced realistic physics, detailed NPC behavior, and a gritty narrative.
- Strong character development with memorable companions and choices affecting story outcome.
- Smaller but richer map focusing on immersion and realism.
- Cover-based shooting and refined combat mechanics.
- Smartphone integration was innovative.
- DLC packs added variety in tone and gameplay.
- Widely regarded as the most balanced and polished installment despite fewer sales than predecessors.
GTA 5: Popular but Less Freeform
- Massive world with three distinct protagonists.
- Emphasis on scripted, cinematic missions reduced player freedom.
- Heist missions offered crew selection and strategic play but tapered off in impact.
- Large portions of the map felt empty or uninteresting.
- Mixed tonal shifts and less mission replayability.
- Still a technical and gameplay masterpiece with strong combat and driving mechanics.
- Most played GTA game but ranked lower here due to rigid mission design and less emergent gameplay.
Summary of Key Conclusions
- GTA 3 is recognized as the concrete foundation of the modern GTA series, revolutionizing open-world design.
- Vice City combines nostalgia, atmosphere, and excellent music to create a timeless experience.
- San Andreas is the most ambitious with its sprawling map and deep customization, though sometimes bloated.
- GTA 4 is praised as the best execution of the GTA formula, balancing narrative, gameplay, and realism.
- GTA 5, while massively popular and technically impressive, is critiqued for its scripted and less replayable missions.
- Early entries (GTA 1 & 2) are historically important but mechanically outdated.
- Handheld titles (Liberty City Stories, Vice City Stories, Chinatown Wars) offered unique experiences but varied in innovation and impact.
Additional Notes
- The video emphasizes the evolution of mission design, combat, navigation, and storytelling across the series.
- Rockstar's voice acting and celebrity involvement increased significantly after GTA 3.
- The ranking and impressions are subjective and invite debate, especially concerning GTA 5's placement.
- The commentator looks forward to GTA 6 and its potential impact on the series.
This comprehensive analysis highlights the GTA series' growth from rudimentary top-down chaos to complex, immersive open-world narratives, marking Rockstar's continued innovation and occasional missteps.
Last edited:
