I've played it to completion and, save combat, it has nothing on TW3. Even CDPR's DLC has better characters and stories, and one of them is like ten hours long. Horizon is a very good game and GG have surpassed the expectations that even longtime fans like myself had, but Horizon isn't the world beater you're making it out to be.
I have to simply disagree here. Even if you see things like that, Guerilla are much more technically better developers than CD Projekt Red. And thats a non-arguable fact.
Horizon loads faster, looks marginally better and has better framerate on Guerilla's first attempt at Open World.
And I only mentioned the technical side of things. You accuse me of putting Horizon as a "world beater", but then you say its got nothing on TW3. You cant say it has "nothing". It clearly does.
So allow me to highlight some of them up for you, Aloy was much more enchanting, relatable and likable to me in the first hour of playing Horizon than I ever did playing as Geralt. The story telling of Horizon is told much more vividly, is told more interestingly and is more captivating than TW3's. Guerilla upped the ante by far with crafting mechanics by making crafting and ammo replenishing be viable as fuck, on the go, instead of having to pause gameplay flow to bring up a slow menu to adhere to the player's needs.
And let me just point out to you, Robo dinos are miles better than the human or monster enemies on TW3. Fighting gigantic robots all with their own personality while some other mechanical giants ambushed you along the way was incredibly hectic, exhilarating and unforgettable. Making for an incredible spectacle of bombs, arrows, elemental fireworks, the ground fucking shaking and missiles, lasers and bullets going haywire all over the place. To add to that, watching the environment around you getting destroyed makes every combat encounter in Horizon seem exactly what you would expect from an greatly agile person confronting these gigantic things. (and this is all taking place without 1 single framerate drop)
I never, ever,
ONCE...had a moment like that in The Witcher 3.
It was slash, slash, do a broken dodge, slash, magic and win....and goes on like this for more than 80+ hours. Its unbelievable shit.
I had to force myself to finish that game. I shouldnt have to do that with any game. Period.