as someone that actually enjoyed (and finished) FF13 on ps3, what can I expect from 13-2 and Lightning Returns? Will I probably like those aswell?
What did you like about XIII?
XIII-2 had weaker combat because everything was so easy. Monsters were tedious to level but I don't know if you'll like the system. Noel and Serah were surprising better characters than the XIII ones in terms of character development and personality but the time travel story is all over the place and the logic isn't quite there. The villain had somewhat better motivations though. The music had more variety and was really good. Locations are now larger areas that feel more like dungeons, I supposed. And there are towns. Downside would be that they used time travel to reskin areas (sometimes giving them a different weather) so locations can feel repetitive. I think the most was 3 variations of the same place. Graphic wise it was also not as polished as the first. The game tried hitting all the notes that were missing in the first, like against a checklist so you get something that seems to contain a bit of everything but feels like a good assignment from a team of good RPG making students.
LR has a different battle system and you only control Lightning. The game is pseudo action based with dodging/blocking and importance placed on the timing of attacking, blocking and dodging, while still keeping to an ATB gauge. Lots of customisation options that can feel slightly tedious. I didn't really like the ability upgrade system because it feels like a gaccha system like those freetoplay games on mobile. I really liked the battle system but the game didn't give it enough space to breath. Too few enemies, too short a main plot with lots of side quest padding. Time system almost only there to lengthen the game and confuse you in the "oh no I missed the time gap and have to wait till the next day" kind of way. They speak of it being an open world but it really is just 4 different large locations with a few dungeons here and there. The game is too small so the battle system feels wasted. Feels more half baked than XIII-2. Graphically the worse of the three games and one were you can genuinely believe if someone compares it to a PS2 game. Story is even more nonsensical.
I did find all 3 games to be fun though.
To extend my comparison of XIII-2 to a school assignment,
XIII was an assignment which was pieced together with very beautiful but empty prose right on the night before it was submitted, not because the students were lazy but because the group members all did their own thing until it was too late.
XIII-2 was on the other hand made by a group of students who kept looking and making sure they meet the requirements of what the teacher wants and manages to sort of make it without excelling at any particular aspect, too afraid to drop an idea or two to expand on the ideas that were better.
LR felt like it was made by people who decided to not do much research, didn't really paid attention in class and decided to write something that was very based on material and ideas that didn't need to be expanded upon (i.e. LIghtning and the XIII world). The students here are not particularly gifted, some probably didn't care. You end up with an assignment that felt half baked, with bad ideas, incomplete and just winging it because they had to do something.