• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Sony is officially helping with funding and development with Shenmue 3

NervousXtian

Thought Emoji Movie was good. Take that as you will.
I don't mean to be pedantic (I think that's the right word) but why does any of that matter? Backers get the game for less than the retail price and it wouldn't have been made without them.

Why does it matter?

I'll tell you why it matters.

People defended KS in the start because it put the power back in the Devs hands, not investors hands or publisher hands.

I remember all the talk back in the day about how this approach for games meant we'd get the true visions of the devs, not the market research driven approach a publisher would take.

That's all gone with shit like this. If in fact the KS is 1/10th the budget, who has final say on things? You don't know. Maybe it's Sony, maybe it's Yu who is given autonomy to use Sony's money how he see's fit.

KS used this way is pretty much a whale fishing excursion. Currently the Avg is $78.

Yes, people get something for that money. Yet the whole idea that you're funding something that wasn't getting funded is out the window.

Just call it a fucking pre-order then if that's what it is. That's mainly what KS has become.
 
Smh@ this thread, you're getting Shenmue 3! With a legitimate investor behind it! Nobody wanted to touch this shit with a 10ft pole and now it's getting made, cmon yall.
 
3e19b17f17fe977ac5c53f8eb2d963f1.jpg


Have some of you lost your effing minds!? I am at a loss for words. The fuck is going on here? This is Shenmue 3 for Christ's sake.

Who cares how it got funded. I am getting my dream game after all these years. Stop fucking destroying the hype and good will. I can just see this mothballing and gaming websites reporting it spreading like misinformation fire storm. Please don't anyone pull your pledges. We need more backers to give this game the maximum funds possible.

Why would you hate this? Why do you want to take away my perfect game from me and other fans after the hell we have been through to finally get this to happen?

I am shaking in anger and tears are streaming down my face.I have lost all hope at some modern gamers today.

lol oh dear
 

Krejlooc

Banned
3e19b17f17fe977ac5c53f8eb2d963f1.jpg


Have some of you lost your effing minds!? I am at a loss for words. The fuck is going on here? This is Shenmue 3 for Christ's sake.

Who cares how it got funded. I am getting my dream game after all these years. Stop fucking destroying the hype and good will. I can just see this mothballing and gaming websites reporting it spreading like misinformation fire storm. Please don't anyone pull your pledges. We need more backers to give this game the maximum funds possible.

Why would you hate this? Why do you want to take away my perfect game from me and other fans after the hell we have been through to finally get this to happen?

I am shaking in anger and tears are streaming down my face.I have lost all hope at some modern gamers today.

Don't worry, the people bitching about this are a small, vocal minority.
 

watership

Member
Well people are reacting as if Sony had the power and the final word.

They very likely didn't. The KS campaign was planned and was gonna happen. And you can't blame Sony for not asking Yu to ditch its KS and fund it completely.

Cynical/conspiracy theorist/crazy me thinks this kickstarter was going to happen anyway. Someone at Sony got wind of it, approached the people doing it and said "Hey, announce it at our conference. You'll get a huge boost. Just ....let me fix this platform list for you" (Scribbles out Xbox One).

Same sort of arguments would be happening if MS did the same thing.
 

Ralemont

not me
It's all about transparency. For example, Playtonic was 100% up front with their Kickstarter by mentioning that Yooka-Laylee was being developed whether the Kickstarter was successful or not due to funding already existing - and that the Kickstarter was simply a means of fleshing out an already existing game.

Instead of basically saying "We're just trying to do a noble thing here! Here's a Kickstarter we're simply trying to give some exposure too!", they could have been up front and likely gotten the same amount of excitement.

I guess I just see this from a practical angle. If Sony was indeed going to fund this no matter what, then people were always going to have a chance to change their pledge. If their support was dependent on the KS's success, then the reason for the KS was obvious.

In BOTH cases, through Kickstarter I'm getting the game for less (maybe half) what it would cost me for retail if Sony had just funded it from the beginning with no KS.

In either case, there's no victim, no scam. Better transparency in Case A? Sure, I guess. But that's about a 1/10 on the "is this a problem?" scale.
 

crazyprac

Member
What an embarassing thread. It's fucking shenmue. It's actually being made and people are bitching and whining. Lmao this e3, this forum, what a wonderful day!!!!

Cynical/conspiracy theorist/crazy me thinks this kickstarter was going to happen anyway. Someone at Sony got wind of it, approached the people doing it and said "Hey, announce it at our conference. You'll get a huge boost. Just ....let me fix this platform list for you" (Scribbles out Xbox One).

Same sort of arguments would be happening if MS did the same thing.

And here we continue!
 

Percy

Banned
Shenmue III is happening... made possible by convincing Sony to help fund it after the fans themselves poured out their support for the project. It's the quintessential happy ending.

... And yet people are still complaining.

Looking at some of the people bothered by this, I daresay it's mainly the 'Sony' part that's proving to be a bitter pill to swallow.
 

Salsa

Member
why should the thread be closed

I guess im going outside the point here but im legit surprised at some of the reactions from old members. this is a discussion forum, you're not supposed to shift it to your liking or to feed whatever's convenient to you or how you wanna feel. it's a fucking place on the internet with many people in it, you don't own it and no one should be here expecting circlejerk party

that's a ridiculous attitude to have with the internet in general

people complaining about "outrage culture" by saying "shut this down lets all be hyped and don't overthink anything" is the 'outrage culture' part of this. shit's ironic
 

Jonnax

Member
I this is so dumb. A niche IP that has been dormant for 14 years?

How much money do you think Andrew House and Kaz Hirai would be willing to spend? 10¢ if they had any business sense.

Who is getting angry about this? Do they want a Shenmue game made for $2mil just as long as it's pure?
 

Pikma

Banned
This doesn't even make any sense. You've totally lost it.
Why do console exclusive exist? Is there any advantage in having them as hardware developers? Yes, they do and Sony is taking advantage of the fans' money to have a console exclusive while completely removing the risks that usually come with said kind of products. That's my argument, PC has nothing to do with it, not sure why you mentioned it.
 

Wagram

Member
Then what was the damn point of the kickstarter? To gauge response, there are other ways to do that, many other ways.

What the fuck.

I wonder if a twitter message can fund bills. I really should figure out how to do that because the salt would fund my bills for life.
 

hawk2025

Member
Cynical/conspiracy theorist/crazy me thinks this kickstarter was going to happen anyway. Someone at Sony got wind of it, approached the people doing it and said "Hey, announce it at our conference. You'll get a huge boost. Just ....let me fix this platform list for you" (Scribbles out Xbox One).

Same sort of arguments would be happening if MS did the same thing.

lol

Never change, watership.
 
This is a bigger franchise and everyone wants it. Like Bayonetta.

I take issue with this statement. The noise around Shenmue has always been loud, but it's very telling that it wasn't funded prior to fans pledging their own money. It's a bit of a stretch to say Shenmue is some giant franchise that gamers everywhere are clamoring for. People are getting hung up on the amount of money being pledged, but fail to realize the money in the Kickstarter is coming from just under 35,000 people. We're in the era of games that need to clear hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of units sold.
 

JP

Member
Yu Suzuki (Kickstarter) said:
If we do not reach our funding goal, Shenmue 3 will not go forward. I know that the goal of making Shenmue 3 with the fans, and seeing Shenmue in the hands of gamers all around the world is a lofty one. We are balancing our ambitions for a grand sequel with the pragmatic realities of developing a game of this scale. It will not be easy, but I have dreamed of making this sequel for 14 years – it is time to bring Shenmue back! And to make it come true, it will need the love and support from each and every one of you!

So please join us in making Shenmue 3 – let us grow our community and build a new, exciting Shenmue experience!
It seems that if the goal hadn't been met than the parties involved (Ys Net, Sega & Sony) would not be moving forward with this. Maybe Sega wouldn't move forwards with this without that $2 million being there for them to allow their IP to be used.

Of course, they were always going to get $2 million in pledges and once they have the bankroll there, they'll be able to move forward with production.
 

Harmen

Member
Years from now this will be one of the most embarrassing threads in history

A game that no one ever thought would be made is happening and people are angry

Same goes for Bayonetta 2.

And if anything, that game exaclty shows why publishers stay away from these games and how kickstarter can help out to make fans vote with their wallet. Bayo 2 bombed and barely did anything to the WiiU's state. Shenmue 3 is by all means not a title Sony needs for the PS4 to be a success. Be happy that there was a means to realize the dreams of Shenmue fans.
 

Pandy

Member
This is a bigger franchise and everyone wants it. Like Bayonetta.
I own a PS4 and was planning to play this on PC.
Maybe there are a few hurt XBO solo and WiiU solo owners in here, but this deflectionist bullshit is tiresome, and isn't contributing in the slightest.
 

Nokagi

Unconfirmed Member
And no real Shenmue fan will be upset by this. I dunno who or why these people are complaining but I guarantee you they haven't been waiting around 13-14 years for this game like most of us have.
 

Jinfash

needs 2 extra inches
What are you talking about with Sony publishing the game? When was this revealed?
This project will eventually have a publisher. Like many projects of its caliber. Assuming Sony taking publishing responsibilities, at least on the PS4 (digital/physical), is not a stretch.
 

RurouniZel

Asks questions so Ezalc doesn't have to
Guys, what if you have it all backwards ?

My guess is that Yu was going to launch a KS campaign for Shenmue 3 anyway. He already has the rights, he doesn't need anyone. And he was probably motivated by all the recent success like Bloodstained. And they would have campaigned for a PC only release (look at the KS campaign, the emphasis is completely on PC, not PS4).

Sony heard of this and went to Yu. They offered to give them E3 exposure and offered to pitch in for the financing on the condition that 1/ the goal is reacher and 2/ the game comes to PS4 as a console exclusive.

And that's pretty much it. It completely makes sense.

STOP TALKING WITHOUT YOUR TINFOIL HAT ON!

;P I agree this is a very likely scenario.

Same goes for Bayonetta 2.

And if anything, that game exaclty shows why kickstarter can help out to make fans vote with their wallet. Bayo 2 bombed and barely did anything to the WiiU's state. Shenmue 3 is by all means not a title Sony needs for the PS4 to be a success. Be happy that there was a means to realize the dreams of Shenmue fans.

This so much.
 

Amentallica

Unconfirmed Member
I'm trying to find a way to email Sony Playstation, but all I'm able to find is the complaint submission. I'm trying to suggest a kickstarter for Legend of Dragoon 2, damn it.
 

Wavebossa

Member
Kickstart (verb): provide the initial impetus to.
"if the project isn't kick-started soon, it's going to be dropped altogether"

This is literally what they did. They Kickstarted the project. The anger in this thread is largely due to people not understanding the purpose of Kickstarter at all.
 
Cynical/conspiracy theorist/crazy me thinks this kickstarter was going to happen anyway. Someone at Sony got wind of it, approached the people doing it and said "Hey, announce it at our conference. You'll get a huge boost. Just ....let me fix this platform list for you" (Scribbles out Xbox One).

Same sort of arguments would be happening if MS did the same thing.

Yeah, it's how business works. Suzuki gets much needed funding, and Sony gets a superb "win" over their competitor. I fail to see why people are getting worked up when its how the industry operates.
 

Pikma

Banned
Just sell your consoles, and buy a graphic card for your PC.
I own one already, this is not about the exclusivity in itself, that's pretty common in the industry, what bothers me is (partially or whatever you want to call it) funding one with people's money.
 

DC1

Member
I'm watching this thing dissolve right before my eyes... People the water is good and the meat is not human. Please enjoy the feast before you!
 

Erevador

Member
But, think about it.


All the complaining, and little controversies and discussions...

We will still get Shenmue 3.
So much impotent rage... and yet the money counter on the Kickstarter just keeps on ticking up.

All is well with the world.

Wanna play a game of lucky hit?
 

Karl Hawk

Banned
why should the thread be closed

I guess im going outside the point here but im legit surprised at some of the reactions from old members. this is a discussion forum, you're not supposed to shift it to your liking or to feed whatever's convenient to you or how you wanna feel

that's a ridiculous attitude to have with the internet in general

people complaining about "outrage culture" by saying "shut this down lets all be hyped and don't overthink anything" is the 'outrage culture' part of this

I'll only speak for myself, but if (A huge IF) this thread somehow forces Suzuki-san/Sony to cancel Shenmune 3, then I don't think most people who were looking forward for it will ever forgive GAF
 

A_Gorilla

Banned
Then what was the damn point of the kickstarter? To gauge response, there are other ways to do that, many other ways.

What the fuck.

Only Kickstarter forces people to put their money where their mouth is when it comes to supporting something. Its why KS projects get attention and other anonymous online petitions get laughed at.
 

Kierian

Neo Member
Kickstarter is used to generate funding and to show demand for projects that wouldn't exist without it, right? Shenmue got funding from the demand shown, so I don't see anything wrong with this situation.
 

Corto

Member
GUYS... I solved this! People just need to think of Sony helping the funding of Shenmue 3 as a surprise stretch goal for the Kickstarter campaign. "If we reach 2 million dollars in under 10 hours, Sony will write a check."
 

The Cowboy

Member
Years from now this will be one of the most embarrassing threads in history

A game that no one ever thought would be made is happening and they can get it for $29 if they want, and people are angry

I really think the cost part needs to be added, its just so crazy that we can get a game that has been requested for over a decade for only $29 and some people are complaining about it.

We can get Shenmue 3 for $29, TWENTY NICE DOLLARS!!!! - this is AWESOME.
 

Faustek

Member
3e19b17f17fe977ac5c53f8eb2d963f1.jpg


Have some of you lost your effing minds!? I am at a loss for words. The fuck is going on here? This is Shenmue 3 for Christ's sake.

Who cares how it got funded. I am getting my dream game after all these years. Stop fucking destroying the hype and good will. I can just see this mothballing and gaming websites reporting it spreading like misinformation fire storm. Please don't anyone pull your pledges. We need more backers to give this game the maximum funds possible.

Why would you hate this? Why do you want to take away my perfect game from me and other fans after the hell we have been through to finally get this to happen?

I am shaking in anger and tears are streaming down my face.I have lost all hope at some modern gamers today.


Here, yeah I can sorta dig this. I mean we have people who would chug down dong like it was water in the dessert for a 2D tales of game so I'm really not bothered but they should have said so straight away in the ks instead of it coming out later.
And I can't blame people for not getting it. I mean not everyone can keep tabs on everything that has happened.
 

Krakn3Dfx

Member
I think this is awesome, if Sony is willing to drop in a big bag of money after seeing interest is real, they should totally do that. This E3 had been like Christmas and my birthday all rolled up together. Even though I'm not heavily invested in Shenmue, I still went in at the $29 level because it just feels like something I want to be a part of.

After reading all the negativity in this thread, I may bump it up to $60.
 
Sigh.
What retail price? How do you know what it's going to retail at? We have no idea of the budget, so why would you expect anything more than a $5 dollar digital download title? How do you know it wouldn't have been made without them?

We know nothing about this, and until we do, being dismissive of the concerns of others without possessing any facts yourself is a fairly daft position to adopt. It may have no bearing on the outcome now, but a 'real' Shenmue fan would be concerned that the franchise was going to be treated properly, instead of being blindly happy that some game with the right name was being made.

EDIT: None of this is a problem if Sony (co-)funded it themselves. Business is business, but I'm not going to back a project I'm being kept in the dark about.

This should be standard Kickstarter Red Flag territory, but people are defending it because of the names involved.

I'm guessing at a retail price of >$30 because that is the price of a game of the quality I'm expecting for shenmue 3. Also, when has a kickstarter product been less expensive after its been funded?

And I would be more concerned about the franchise being treated properly if it had been kickstarted without any Sony involvement.

I apologize if I'm being dense, but what is the red flag signifying in this case?
 
I take issue with this statement. The noise around Shenmue has always been loud, but it's very telling that it wasn't funded prior to fans pledging their own money. It's a bit of a stretch to say Shenmue is some giant franchise that gamers everywhere are clamoring for. People are getting hung up on the amount of money being pledged, but fail to realize the money in the Kickstarter is coming from just under 35,000 people. We're in the era of games that need to clear hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of units sold.

Oh I know it isn't an actual big franchise like Uncharted, just in our world it's one of those talked about games.
 

DeepEnigma

Gold Member
You are assuming that Sony was going to fund this game from the start if it met the $2 million dollar goal.

There is nothing on the Kickstarter page that says it. We didn't know about this partnership until Suzuki said it on the stream.

So I stand by my claim that Sony intentionally deceived fans that Shenmue 3 needed real backers to fund the game.

You are right, they only brought him on stage just cause reasons,

Come on man.

The game did not save the DC, and it did not save itself on the XBox or boost those sales much. History speaks volumes. (not saying it was a bad game, just in bad circumstances for it's time)

If Peter Moore didn't use it for his MSFT in, then we probably would have had a 3 already on the PS2 or 3.
 
Top Bottom