• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Super Smash Bros Wii U & 3DS Thread 4: New Year, Old Arguments

Berordn

Member
I give a shit!! He's my most wanted newcomer.

It's a damn shame the games and character aren't more popular in the west.

I've been preaching the merits of Chibi-Robo in smash since SSBB, but I basically gave up all hope on the basis that he's just not known enough.
 

Drago

Member
I've been preaching the merits of Chibi-Robo in smash since SSBB, but I basically gave up all hope on the basis that he's just not known enough.

He's such a great candidate in a bunch of ways too. I do think he has a good chance despite the utter lack of western popularity (I think the games sell somewhat nicely in Japan though), not only for the big moveset potential and originality among other Smash chars but because Chibi Robo is one of the very few new Nintendo IPs in recent years (as in 2006-) that has become somewhat of a mainstay.

I'll be pretty disappointed if he doesn't get in.
 

PikaED

Member
So nobody else gives a shit about Chibi Robo?

I love Chibi-Robo, beaten both the original & Park Patrol (and just got Photo Finder).
(did not expect the framerate in Photo Finder to be that bad tho)

Though thinking about it, how would you make a moveset for the helper bot (in terms of representation)?
Considering all of the games had you play as different Chibi-Robo(s) [I know nothing about the second DS game, JPN only and all that] with different tools and such.

Do you use the latest Chibi-Robo, the first Chibi-Robo, or an amalgamation of all of the Chibi-Robo(s)?
 

leroidys

Member
I've been preaching the merits of Chibi-Robo in smash since SSBB, but I basically gave up all hope on the basis that he's just not known enough.
Yeah, I've known about the IP since the first game came out, but didn't realize what a great moveset Robo could have until now.

I love Chibi-Robo, beaten both the original & Park Patrol (and just got Photo Finder).
(did not expect the framerate in Photo Finder to be that bad tho)

Though thinking about it, how would you make a moveset for the helper bot (in terms of representation)?
Considering all of the games had you play as different Chibi-Robo(s) [I know nothing about the second DS game, JPN only and all that] with different tools and such.

Do you use the latest Chibi-Robo, the first Chibi-Robo, or an amalgamation of all of the Chibi-Robo(s)?

I think an amalgam would be fine, like G&W for example.
 
I know im late on this (Still on my horrible sleeping schedule....) but, Its good to see my only Heavy main back, he looks so much better now model wise, he seems to have grown bigger too. Love his new expressions.
 
This game should have 100+ playable characters. They already clone, half-ass and make movelists up out of nowhere for some characters and Brawl had terrible balance in its roster. If those problems will exist, they may as well appease fans by putting in a bunch of characters. If Nintendo would get with the times and support their games after release (which they did with that Super Luigi game), then they could adjust balance after getting a decent roster that takes good advantage of their rich history. The tourney scene would have their work cut out for them building a tier list, yet that would be an advantage for Nintendo if they paid attention to what the tourney demographic discusses. If people gravitate to only a select few characters to play competitively with, then it's business as usual.
 

I'M FINISHED!

Um exCUSE me Sakurai but CLEARLY the best choice for Smash Bros would be my fav niche character HOWEVER you are clearly INCOMPETENT and
I like the transformation mechanic and I don't see the need to separate the same character. It won't be surprising to me if there are no Legend of Zelda newcomers.

I don't know why people thought he'd be cut in the first place. (Is it because he's a "clone"?)

I thought there was a small chance he would be cut. Sakurai's interesting and very specific talks on character selection regarding Smash 4 scrambled my brain. I didn't see the need for two different Links, and before Toon Link was shown, we didn't know if "clones" would return. I was under the wrong impression that Sakurai was intending on sharpening the roster without utilizing too many variant characters. However, I will admit that I see the need for Falco and Wolf, and they could be considered variant characters, but I would argue that besides there being differences in how they exist in their franchises, they are also more unique compared to Fox than Toon Link is to Link. Also, I think it is better to compare Toon Link to Dr. Mario who wasn't deemed as high of a priority as others during Brawl's development. With that all that said, Toon Link is visually appealing and fits in well with the rest of the cast. I still wish Toon Link was more than just a "fast" Link with moves that perform somewhat differently than "slow" Link. I'm not even saying he needs a complete overhaul, three or four different moves alone would make a big difference. Anyway, all I think this means now is that the majority of the Brawl cast is returning, and for the most part, that is a-okay with me.
 

Ryce

Member
Speaking of Olimar, do we know if his move set got changed up at all? Pikmin is one of my favorite franchises, but I found Olimar to be incredibly boring to play in Brawl.
Really? Olimar's one of my favorite characters to use. I think he's really fun. But no, we haven't seen anything new -- his screen shots depict attacks he had in Brawl.
 
Speaking of Olimar, do we know if his move set got changed up at all? Pikmin is one of my favorite franchises, but I found Olimar to be incredibly boring to play in Brawl.

Really?!? How so? He's my favorite character.

Anyway, if he ends up having only three Pikmin, I could see his recovery being replaced with a Flying Pikmin or something.
 

leroidys

Member
Really? Olimar's one of my favorite characters to use. I think he's really fun. But no, we haven't seen anything new -- his screen shots depict attacks he had in Brawl.

Really?!? How so? He's my favorite character.

Anyway, if he ends up having only three Pikmin, I could see his recovery being replaced with a Flying Pikmin or something.
He probably gets more interesting (like everyone) the closer you get to mastering him, but for average play it's all a-attacks and side b.
 

-Horizon-

Member
This game looks so much better than Brawl (artstyle), it's not even funny.

I'm REALLY looking forward to seeing Zelda Wii U.

Yeah, Brawl had to go all gritty real plumber overalls on us.

The more cartoony look of this is much better.

What if Zelda U because Yarn Zelda?!
 

dvolovets

Member
Has it ever occurred to you guys that King Dedede looks like Peter Griffin?

1520602_10202046855547031_1357100491_n.jpg
 
He probably gets more interesting (like everyone) the closer you get to mastering him, but for average play it's all a-attacks and side b.

I've found the side-B is always too risky for me. I prefer grabs: the whites deal great pummel damage and fatties/blues produce amazing KOs with it.
 

Anura

Member
I've found the side-B is always too risky for me. I prefer grabs: the whites deal great pummel damage and fatties/blues produce amazing KOs with it.

Olimar's grabs are just really good! Crazy range thanks to the pikmin without the drawbacks of a grapple.
 

Fiktion

Banned
Because you only quoted one picture, and what is point of you posting here and ask if it should have new thread or not. It don't make sense if you are planning to not listen to anyone if they said no.

I was checking to see if anyone else wanted to make it obviously.
 

FlynnCL

Unconfirmed Member
This game looks so much better than Brawl (artstyle), it's not even funny.

Yeah... Dedede in Brawl just looks so lifeless in comparison to his Wii U self. I'm still amazed at some of the screenshots. The lighting and animation is fantastic.

I can't wait for some more Pokémon reveals, as we only have Pikachu so far. Sakurai has said that including Pokémon characters is really hard thanks to a lot of issues among parties. :/
 

IntelliHeath

As in "Heathcliff"
Yeah, I don't even know what the fuck is going on so I just changed back. Hopefully Wario gets revealed soon BECAUSE I'LL BE DAMNED IF I LOSE HIM TOO.

Here is the list that people already called for.

IntelliHeath: Laughing Dog, Isaac, Dark Pit or Takamaru
ffdgh: Peach
KMD: Little Mac
Crab: Marth
Alistair Roo: Luigi
Azure J: Mike Jones
Shadow Hog: Sonic, or Tails (Because, Fuck Sonic.)
GiantEnemyGoomba: Shulk or X
PBAlfredo: Ness
Gleethor: Samus
Showmeyamoves: Captain Falcon
Red Arremer: Ridley's head
ScraftyDevil: Hades, Agent J, or Scrafty
dryuriev7777: Palutena
Kouichi: Waluigi
Ezalc: Matthew, Sukapon or Ray 01 Legend/Mk II
BlakImpaler: Chrom, or Lucina
Kurtofan: Wario (classic)
PorygonVandal: Luigi [Second]
Codeblue: Ike
Javier: Lucario
JStein022: Tom Nook
Icelandic_Jazz: Mr. Game & Watch
Drago: Lucas, Balloon Villager or Wario (WarioWare)

Professor Beef: Kirby
Senator Soufflé: Chibi-Robo, or Dillon, if both didn't get in then King Dedede
SuperAngelo64: King Dedede [Second]
JBtheHunter: Pac-Man
NexusCell: Rosalina
MisterLuffy: Mario or Zero Suit Samus
Anth0ny: Sheik
AnkiRendan: Pokemon Trainer
Nocturnowl: Donkey Kong
BroBuzz: Ice Climbers
Diddy Kong: Diddy Kong, who else :p
Starphoenix: Waddle Dee
Poltergust: Yoshi
FUNKNOWN iXi: Master/Crazy Hand
NotLiquid: Wonderful 101/Wonder Red
Gonzo The Great: Tingle
Astrosanity: King K Rool or Toon Link
Dr.Thunder: Ganondorf
Cuban Legend: Red Bowser
Red Rudolph: Monster Hunter
BGBW: Geno, Goku or Haruka
JulianImp: Waluigi-Colored Luigi
Hasardeur: Tetra, Krystal, or Dixie Kong
Vermillion: Miyamoto's new IP
qq more: Squirtle

Troubled Bat: Medusa, Sami, Kumatora or Bowser Jr.
foxuzamaki: Fox
Regiruler: Arlon the Serene
Jagsrock: Mewtwo
Masked Man: Masked Man (Of course. :D), or Lucas [Second]
SuperSah: Metaknight
PK Gaming: Pit
Qurupeke: Rush
Zen_Arcade: Little Mac [Second]
Hot Coldman: Knuckles
MagiusNecros - Magnus
Baron von Loathsome - Isa Jo or Saki (Sin and Punishment)
 

Village

Member
Yo, homies on the proverbial streets of smash.

I have a question/proposition thing.

OK So you know the yellow devil and how everyone is arguing if its a stage hazard or boss.

Why can't it be both?
 

Caladrius

Member
Yo, homies on the proverbial streets of smash.

I have a question/proposition thing.

OK So you know the yellow devil and how everyone is arguing if its a stage hazard or boss.

Why can't it be both?

What happens if the Yellow Devil stage hazard comes around while the Yellow Devil boss is there?
 

DaBoss

Member
Why isn't that list organized by characters instead of usernames?

I guess that the more unknown characters wouldn't be a popular choice.
 

IntelliHeath

As in "Heathcliff"
Why isn't that list organized by characters instead of usernames?

I guess that the more unknown characters wouldn't be a popular choice.

I doubt it. I think it was just a messy list that kept added new people at bottom of the list. Here is the updated list.

Akibastman: Professor Layton
Alistair Roo: Luigi
AnkiRendan: Pokemon Trainer
Anth0ny: Sheik
Astrosanity: King K Rool or Toon Link
Axass: Paper Mario
Azure J: Mike Jones
Baron von Loathsome - Isa Jo or Saki (Sin and Punishment)
BGBW: Geno, Goku or Haruka
BlakImpaler: Chrom, or Lucina
BroBuzz: Ice Climbers
Codeblue: Ike
Crab: Marth
Cuban Legend: Red Bowser
Diddy Kong: Diddy Kong, who else :p
Dr.Thunder: Ganondorf
Drago: Lucas, Balloon Villager or Wario (WarioWare)
dryuriev7777: Palutena
Ezalc: Matthew, Sukapon or Ray 01 Legend/Mk II
ffdgh: Peach
foxuzamaki: Fox
FUNKNOWN iXi: Master/Crazy Hand
GiantEnemyGoomba: Shulk or X
Gleethor: Samus
Gonzo The Great: Tingle
Hasardeur: Tetra, Krystal, or Dixie Kong
Hot Coldman: Knuckles
Icelandic_Jazz: Mr. Game & Watch
IntelliHeath: Laughing Dog, Isaac, Dark Pit or Takamaru
Jagsrock: Mewtwo
Javier: Lucario
JBtheHunter: Pac-Man
JStein022: Tom Nook
JulianImp: Waluigi-Colored Luigi
KMD: Little Mac
Kouichi: Waluigi
Kurtofan: Wario (classic)
leroidys: Dr. Gadd, Andy, Wonder Red (Third)
MagiusNecros - Magnus
Masked Man: Masked Man (Of course. :D), or Lucas [Second]
MisterLuffy: Mario or Zero Suit Samus
NexusCell: Rosalina
Nocturnowl: Donkey Kong
NotLiquid: Wonderful 101/Wonder Red
PBAlfredo: Ness
PK Gaming: Pit
Poltergust: Yoshi
PorygonVandal: Luigi [Second]
Professor Beef: Kirby
qq more: Squirtle
Qurupeke: Rush
Red Arremer: Ridley's head
Red Rudolph: Monster Hunter
Regiruler: Arlon the Serene
ScraftyDevil: Hades, Agent J, or Scrafty
Senator Soufflé: Chibi-Robo, or Dillon, if both didn't get in then King Dedede
Shadow Hog: Sonic, or Tails (Because, Fuck Sonic.)
Showmeyamoves: Captain Falcon
SkullHydra: Cloud, Sephiroth or Lightning. Wonder Red (Seconded)
Starphoenix: Waddle Dee
SuperAngelo64: King Dedede [Second]
SuperSah: Metaknight
Troubled Bat: Medusa, Sami, Kumatora or Bowser Jr.
Vermillion: Miyamoto's new IP
Zen_Arcade: Little Mac [Second]
 
Top Bottom