• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Manga News/Discussion |OTL| Not a lick of constructive conversation here

Status
Not open for further replies.

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
Happy Marriage!? vol 3

So in Good Ending we have whinny high schoolers who are afraid of confessing to each and in this manga we have a married couple where one side is afraid of doing it, or kissing for that matters. Funny how even marriage can't stop contrived reasons from advancing the romance plotline. I mean progress is being made, but it's so slow. In this volume, Chiwa finally started having real conversations with Hokuto during breakfast. So that's some progress I guess.

There was a lot of backstory and focus on Hokuto's family, but it all fell flat and felt forced. "oh let me take you to my mother's grave, that will show you how sentimental and cool I am" lol. And then there was the bad rich smug family business during their annual dinner. I really wish the manga would just forget all about Hokuto's side of the story and keep focusing on Chiwa cause she is clearly the only interesting character in the story so far.

This seems interesting.

But then when I google Image search I immediately spotted PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm) and immediately terminate all my intentions of reading it.

There's nothing more repulsive to me than PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm). One of the reasons I find it so hard to read through 7 Seeds too, despite some members here swearing by it.
 

survivor

Banned
This seems interesting.

But then when I google Image search I immediately spotted PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm) and immediately terminate all my intentions of reading it.

There's nothing more repulsive to me than PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm). One of the reasons I find it so hard to read through 7 Seeds too, despite some members here swearing by it.

Oh yeah, Hokuto is Mr. Perfect. He got all the ladies going crazy for him, he is rich, smart, handsome, charming, and with a mysterious and tragic past. He even saved, Chiwa, from danger twice like the true hero he is. Maybe if he saves her a third time, they will finally get to do it.
 
Or perhaps he started out trolling but began to legitimately believe in what he's saying.

You can't just call everyone with a misinformed opinion a troll.

DTL is a troll? You mean gimmick poster? He's not a bad poster, he's just cute. I eagerly await his posts in the JJBA thread. I always refresh the page hoping he would have made a post by then.

You would love this guy on GameFAQS who types paragraph upon paragraph detailing how brilliant Medaka Box is.

EdgeKnight tries too hard.

I am regularly astonished by this thread's capacity for hate. I mean, to not be moved by something, okay, but to actively hate on such a regular basis. I just don't have it in me. What is it about shounen manga that attracts people whose lives have forged them into such raging engines of loathing, I cannot imagine. I don't think there is anything on earth that I hate anywhere near as much as some people hate Naruto the Ninja and his Black and White Comic Book.

This thread is hardly unique in it's hate for Naruto. Many forums like Gaf, share it's hatred of Naruto. Even narutofan hates Naruto. Bleach Asylum is one big "omg Kubo is a genius", and Arlong Park is tsun-tsun.
 
Kuroko no Basuke 206

Unlike Naruto, this flashback is still delivering. Akashi's talk, while harsh, provided some really good motivation for Kuroko. And it's always great to see everyone's initial expression whenever Kuroko revealed his passing prowess, especially since this was his first time doing it in a actual match.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
DTL is a troll? You mean gimmick poster? He's not a bad poster, he's just cute. I eagerly await his posts in the JJBA thread. I always refresh the page hoping he would have made a post by then.



EdgeKnight tries too hard.



This thread is hardly unique in it's hate for Naruto. Many forums like Gaf, share it's hatred of Naruto. Even narutofan hates Naruto. Bleach Asylum is one big "omg Kubo is a genius", and Arlong Park is tsun-tsun.

If everyone hates Naruto, then why does it sell so well?
 

Fox318

Member
If everyone hates Naruto, then why does it sell so well?

6wdXnDIh.png
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
Blade of the Immortal 200

Fuuuuuck.

Not makie. :(

Anotsu is one lucky son of a bitch though. So many gunshots and none of them hit him.
 

Laughing Banana

Weeping Pickle
If everyone hates Naruto, then why does it sell so well?

Cognitive Dissonance? (the hating part, I mean)

Oh yeah, Hokuto is Mr. Perfect. He got all the ladies going crazy for him, he is rich, smart, handsome, charming, and with a mysterious and tragic past. He even saved, Chiwa, from danger twice like the true hero he is. Maybe if he saves her a third time, they will finally get to do it.

Aw man, that's like the Perfect Laughing Banana Repulser(tm) there. Not gonna touch it then even with a 1 km pole.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
Super Manga Hipsters love pretending Naruto sells like shit in Japan even though it doesn't.
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
Nobunaga no Chef 6

oEQtwo9.png


Holy christ Ken why are you running towards enemy archers.

That stupid big pot he's carrying around will probably save him though.

Oresama Teacher 93

oJm9Ge3.png


I love this manga.
 

survivor

Banned
Aw man, that's like the Perfect Laughing Banana Repulser(tm) there. Not gonna touch it then even with a 1 km pole.
lol, for what it's worth the main girl is cute and makes a lot of funny reaction faces, but I don't suppose that's a strong selling point to make anyone read the manga.

Checks out. It's well known that all manga readers are secret fujoshi.

Everyone has a little :DTL inside of them
 

survivor

Banned
Nobunaga no Chef 6

http://i.imgur.com/oEQtwo9.png[IMG]

Holy christ Ken why are you running towards enemy archers.

That stupid big pot he's carrying around will probably save him though.
[/QUOTE]
It's funny how they gave him this stupid pot in the beginning of the chapter only to have it come useful at the end and probably end up saving the other dude's life.

[quote="Angry Grimace, post: 50799621"]

You mean "almost everything that isn't One Piece"[/QUOTE]
The only manga that isn't One Piece that manages to have higher individual volume sales than Naruto is Kimi ni Todoke and even then, you still end up with 1-2 Naruto volumes that are higher than KnT.
 

Antiwhippy

the holder of the trombone
It's funny how they gave him this stupid pot in the beginning of the chapter only to have it come useful at the end and probably end up saving the other dude's life.

.

Seriously, I have no idea how he's marching with that and armour on.

Thing must weigh TONS.
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
This seems interesting.

But then when I google Image search I immediately spotted PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm) and immediately terminate all my intentions of reading it.

There's nothing more repulsive to me than PERFECT SHOUJO MALE(tm). One of the reasons I find it so hard to read through 7 Seeds too, despite some members here swearing by it.

Isn't PERFECT SHOUJO MALE just Mamoru from Sailor Moon?
 
Takemitsu Zamurai 51-60


Apologies for dumping whole pages as images, but these were just so damn good, especially the first two. I am not worthy, Taiyo Matsumoto. It's a gutsy move to use such an atypical style in a narrative piece, but it works out so well. Look at Kikuchi, the big guy in the first two images--he flows across the page like a shapeshifting mass of violence made manifest. These aren't money shots, either; basically every page has something that's incredible to look at.

I included the third image because it's one of Matsumoto's many lovely landscapes of Edo that you could blow up, put on your wall, and call fine art and nobody would bat an eye.
 
Takemitsu Zamurai 51-60



Apologies for dumping whole pages as images, but these were just so damn good, especially the first two. I am not worthy, Taiyo Matsumoto. It's a gutsy move to use such an atypical style in a narrative piece, but it works out so well. Look at Kikuchi, the big guy in the first two images--he flows across the page like a shapeshifting mass of violence made manifest. These aren't money shots, either; basically every page has something that's incredible to look at.

I included the third image because it's one of Matsumoto's many lovely landscapes of Edo that you could blow up, put on your wall, and call fine art and nobody would bat an eye.

I'm at 50 right now and the fight scenes before were amazing. Hot blooded action indeed. It feels like the art focuses on the emotions rather than the physical body itself.
 
Late to the manga Wednesday but here goes

One Piece
If this is a Tournament arc i hope ends soon or end up in chaos .
Noting much happen other than a set up for the Tournament .

Naruto
To be expected from the Uchiha clan .
 

wonzo

Banned
Ran and the Gray World 12-18.5

Jin and Sango make a really cute and charming couple, if only Ran wasn't so obsessed with that sleazebag Outarou. Good on Hibi for standing up to that piece of shit. I also didn't see that little twist at the end coming at all, she must have one hell of an interesting backstory.
 

Kurita

Member
I had to confirm that, but he is carrying the dumb pot in the drama as well. It looks so ridiculous.


Surprisingly this is episode 2. They must have covered ~5 chapters in one episode.
It was hilarious to see him with this in the drama.

And to answer your question on the last page : fights are not that important in the drama. Obviously you'll see some action but since Ken doesn't really fight... Cooking is still the most important part.
 

Erigu

Member
[Naruto]

Wasn't Madara about to spill the beans about him being an Uchiha because of his sharingan, like, just in the previous episode? And now, it turns out he didn't have a sharingan yet?
It's nice that neither the author nor his editor can remember that far...
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
[Naruto]

Wasn't Madara about to spill the beans about him being an Uchiha because of his sharingan, like, just in the previous episode? And now, it turns out he didn't have a sharingan yet?
It's nice that neither the author nor his editor can remember that far...

I think he was just bragging about this eye's potential as opposed to actually having awakened them. Of course, if you want to complain about remembering the rules, the original rule was that not all Uchiha have them, which has already been retconned out.

Beelzebub

Dabuh.
 

Lain

Member
Ran and the Gray World 12-18.5


Jin and Sango make a really cute and charming couple, if only Ran wasn't so obsessed with that sleazebag Outarou. Good on Hibi for standing up to that piece of shit. I also didn't see that little twist at the end coming at all, she must have one hell of an interesting backstory.

So you too don't appreciate Otaro's evil ways?! The only thing Hibi has over him is getting his hands on those puppies.

The extra made the teacher look even more dangerous and badass to me. Ran should pay attention to how she behaves.
 

Erigu

Member
[Naruto]
I think he was just bragging about this eye's potential as opposed to actually having awakened them.
It sure looked like he was confident he already had better eyes than Hashirama.

Of course, if you want to complain about remembering the rules, the original rule was that not all Uchiha have them, which has already been retconned out.
There would be a bunch of stuff like that, yeah...
Also, remember when Madara was the founder of the Uchiha clan? Kishimoto sure doesn't!
 

Angry Grimace

Two cannibals are eating a clown. One turns to the other and says "does something taste funny to you?"
[Naruto]

It sure looked like he was confident he already had better eyes than Hashirama.


There would be a bunch of stuff like that, yeah...
Also, remember when Madara was the founder of the Uchiha clan? Kishimoto sure doesn't!

My guess is that he hadn't written the entire story yet when he had Sasuke say that stuff.
 

Mael

Member
It's not like anyone, except Big One, actually thinks Bleach is one of the worst manga ever or anything.

Bleach wishes it could be as bad as Air Gear or Rage Town.

I don't know about Rage Town but Air Gear really is nothing but Rule of Cool for 37 Volumes or something.
It never claims to be anything deeper or different.
It does that very well and that's all.
At least it has backgrounds (well drawn at that and on top of that it has actual variety in how the characters fight).

Naruto

Neither Hashirama or Tobirama die at this point. I'm guessing Tobirama brings Izuna back to appease Madara. In fact, Izuna probably is the reason Madara knows how to free himself from the user of Edo Tensei.
Good point.

[Naruto]

It sure looked like he was confident he already had better eyes than Hashirama.

Not a retcon, Uchihas are known for their good eyesight after all.

There would be a bunch of stuff like that, yeah...
Also, remember when Madara was the founder of the Uchiha clan? Kishimoto sure doesn't!
Turns out Hashirama wasn't the founder either...
then again it was Tobi and we all know how reliable he is as a narrator.

Big ass picture with relations between mangaka
Wait Katsura worked with Toriyama?
 

Mael

Member
He was literally about to say it was because of the Sharingan before he stopped himself.

The way I see it, they all have sharingans that grant better eyesight and the only difference between the awakened and not is that the tomoes help seeing movement better or something...
I'm not a Uchiha specialist.
 

Erigu

Member
Turns out Hashirama wasn't the founder either...
He was said to be?

then again it was Tobi and we all know how reliable he is as a narrator.
For Madara, it was Jiraiya who called him the founder of the Uchiha clan, actually.
(him, and the latest ad for the new PlayStation 3 game... whoopsie)


Maybe he simply didn't tell the others about it, because he wasn't a big fan of the war and didn't want to be put on the front line.
Wasn't the whole point of him awakening the sharingan in the latest episode that he had "lost his friend" hence eyepower?
 

Defuser

Member
Aku no hana ch 18 - 26

With the anime nearing I decided to pick back up from where I have left off due insufficient chapter release back then.

Man, Nakamura is still the crazy perverted bitch I remember. With that kind of mindset, I ain't surprised if she's probably into freakish sex like S/M.etc

Wait what the fuck? Is she raping him?!?!?!
 

Mael

Member
He was said to be?

Well wasn't that what Tobi said in the flashback to the Sauce?

For Madara, it was Jiraiya who called him the founder of the Uchiha clan, actually.
(him, and the latest ad for the new PlayStation 3 game... whoopsie)

Guess that was not him then...

Wasn't the whole point of him awakening the sharingan in the latest episode that he had "lost his friend" hence eyepower?

Yeah that makes no sense otherwise.
We know that strong emotions awaken the sharingan (since part 1 even!) so that makes sense.
 

Wiseblade

Member
Maybe he simply didn't tell the others about it, because he wasn't a big fan of the war and didn't want to be put on the front line.

See, now this makes way more sense.

Wasn't the whole point of him awakening the sharingan in the latest episode that he had "lost his friend" hence eyepower?

But then, boasting about the Sharingan makes no sense. And Madara had already suffered enough lose at that point to awaken his Sharingan.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom