For movies like this? Of course. Not to mention she isn't a on-screen movie actress by any stretch of the imagination.
No studio in their right mind would ever pick this:
over
Especially one one is a movie actress whose career is on the up and up and the other is a voice actor. GAF makes no sense.
I agree that Tara is too old but to say she doesn't fit the litmus test of good looking is a stretch. It's rare to find someone who is gorgeous like Robbie and is setting a stupidly high standard. Tara is more than fine but she is too old for any potential sequels.
She has the look, but I don't know about the talent. I hope she delivers. Surprise me, Robbie.
She's more than capable.