It's not like the debate has gone anywhere productive in the past 10 pages anyway
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Okay, TeamCG. Come own up to your foolishness. #trolljima
- Thread starter MormaPope
- Start date
It's not like the debate has gone anywhere productive in the past 10 pages anyway
Damon Bennet
Member
the bandages look incredibly cgi to me, whereas the lips and eyes look rather real to me. hmmm
im on team cgi, i guess!
im on team cgi, i guess!
Haha there's a new one
"Dude's real, we didn't have any bandages laying around tho so we just got the CG team in here real quick to make it look authentic"
Rickenslacker
Banned
Okay, I'm willing to budge a little.
The iPad's CG.
The iPad's CG.
Wishmaster92
Member
Can we at least all agree that this is a photoshop of Kojima:
It's not kojima, I can tell from some of the pixels and from seeing quite a few shops in my time.
SquiddyCracker
Banned
I'm guessing:
WrenchNinja
Member
Your mind makes it real.
Relaxed Muscle
Member
Funny, the guy who made the thread is slowly becoming one of us (TeamCG) lol
We take them, we break them, we re-make them......in our image.
Smooth Operator
Member
Don't let me down Kojima
QisTopTier
XisBannedTier
So Joakim is playing Star Ocean?
Except we've all gotten out of the game and have no memory of it!
!
I've already said it, Joakim Mogren is Joshua Graham.
D
Deleted member 13876
Unconfirmed Member
!
Bland textures.
fixed.
Å
Åesop
Unconfirmed Member
!
"Splinter Cell Vs. Mortal Kombat Ultimate Fighting" on FOX Engine confirmed
Yeah. I said it moved very fluidly compared to the rest of the motions, which made it look slightly odd. I didn't say it moved for no reason. I also said that it doesn't necessarily mean that it's CG. It was the only thing that appeared off to me, but it could simply be due to the compression, framerate, etc.
!
CG?
Can we at least all agree that this is a CG of Kojima:
.
Ether_Snake
å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®
Also, Ground Zeroes and Phantom Pain trailers both feature hints at them being VR simulations of past events.
Maybe this game is set when Big Boss was plugged to the John Doe AI. You relive his memories.
Poetic.Injustice
Member
We're still years away from reaching this level of CG.
The video game entertainment business is worth more than the book, music and movie industry combined. There is 3 games every second being sold.
Hollywood is old news.
its 35 pages later but i'll still respond:
that's not my point. My point is that the top CG production companies work on Hollywood. ILM shits on any videogame. They get more money to work with.
TheNamelessOne
Member
Yes, but the movie industry doesn't have to do it in realtime.
Puppet Shadow
Member
Clearly a fake pic. Notice how the shower curtain rod is not along the edge of the tub, but about 8 - 10 in towards the wall? No one would hang it like that, it makes the shower too narrow for no reason at. Must not have been locked in place and moved along the Y axis while it was compiled.
Idiots...
Idiots...
AuthenticM
Member
What makes you think this ? I didn't see anything suggesting anything like that.
I thought that you were saying that video games didnt have the "power" of hollywood. They do. Hell, look at Ellen Page Simulator, that's pretty freaking good for 2013.
Ether_Snake
å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®
Argh I don't feel like going over the clips and timestamping everything again but basically:
1- Every time the camera or Snake stares at a bright light, there is a hissing sound heard. This happens in both trailers.
2- When Snake or the camera looks at advanced technology, the screen starts to fade out and "lens-flares"-like effects appear that are unrelated to what is happening on screen. This happens in the GZ trailer.
Basically, the patient is in coma/reliving memories in Virtual Reality, and when his eyes are exposed to bright lights in the memories or when he sees advanced technology, it triggers a waking-up effect until he stops staring, probably a side-effect from his brain starting to "remember" that what he is seeing is fake when exposed to things that are similar to what is around him in the real world (advanced technology and bright laboratory lights above his table).
A bit like how you wake up if you die when you are dreaming, because surely you couldn't be dying for real.
I thought that you were saying that video games didnt have the "power" of hollywood. They do. Hell, look at Ellen Page Simulator, that's pretty freaking good for 2013.
Are you saying Beyond's graphics are compareable with the interview?
D
Deleted member 13876
Unconfirmed Member
I dunno, someone add bandages to that gif so we can be sure.
I'm saying that this is 2012 images. Maybe they new stuff for the lips and eyes. I'm far from saying its real, I'm saying that its possible. Technology move faster and faster.
Puppet Shadow
Member
Eh, that one looks fake right away though, at least to me. Yesterday I was in FutureShop and they were playing a clip from 'The Last of Us' on all their TV's, and even when I first noticed it out of the corner of my eye I was wondering what cartoon or game it was. Bandage guy is way better.
Ether_Snake
å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®å®
If the Fox engine is being developed on PC, basically without technical constraints first (as it should be done in a forward-thinking dev studio), then they can certainly do better. Kojima and Co have ALWAYS been obsessed with details. Look at MGS2 and how the fricking icecubes in the buckets you could shoot would melt slower if they fell close to one another! Imagine with unconstrained tech. Wouldn't surprise me that this crazy attention to detail is what allowed them to make CGI Joakim.
This is something Kojima couldn't have had the chance to do until a major shift in development philosophies which seems to have taken place recently for his team, deciding to focus on technological advancements and realism in the spirit seen in some Western studios. I have no doubt he and his team could do better. They've always had the potential to do it.
AI MATRIX: SECTOR 07-A942
VR PROGRAM. "PHANTOM_PAIN.MME"
PURPOSE:
TREATMENT OF NEUROLOGICAL DAMAGE SUSTAINED IN COMBAT
TREATMENT OF COMBAT-RELATED PSYCHOLOGICAL STRESS
????????? OF COMBAT ABILITY FOLLOWING IMPAIRMENT
IMPLEMENTATION OF ?????????
aka: all the game might be a VR mission...
If I met Bandage guy in a bar, I'd buy him a drink.
As good as Ellen Page looks there, you're never gonna see a character like that standing next to a real human being on a movie.
I mean its easy, just see what Hulk looks like on The Avengers and what Hulk could look like on a videogame (not talking engine btw, just pre-rendered CG). Videogames just dont invest the expenses to pull that off. Movie CG is where CG thrives, specially when it comes to photorealism.
Phonomezer
Banned
toddhunter
Member
Are we talking PS2 level tech or current gen? Because there is a bit of a difference.