• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Super Smash Bros Wii U and 3DS Thread 3: Ridley's Believe It or Not!

emb

Member
If they would just eliminate (most of) the charge time, I think Fludd could be pretty scary. Seems like it'd be a solid way to get indirect kills, kinda like the cape.
 
Starbits are Rosalina's/Luma's thing.

And we definitely won't see catsuits except maybe as a trophy?
Yeah I guess Rosalina represents the whole Galaxy motif now. Her Final Smash will be beautiful :*)

Eh, I guess FLUDD's ok. I just will have to wait for Cat Maio in SSB5 I suppose.
 

ffdgh

Member
Going by the gifs i think rosa's item vaccum special is actually her down b since she crouches for a spit second before she uses it against fludd.
 

Gartooth

Member
I still believe in Toad dangit! I just want someone to rep the Mario platformers more. ;_;

Oh and FLUDD needs to go away, one of the most useless and gimmicky moves in Smash ever.
 
I hear the competitive play argument, but to me -- statistically the items have always appeared to be random. That is, each competitor has random gains and losses from their inclusion. To me, this is even enough and arguably adds the same % of luck to smash as say, a card game like magic, poker, or even most sports. I recognize that hardcore competitors out there want to remove luck completely from the equation if they can -- but that's where I feel like I divide with many gamers in general. Competition is not what makes a game fun to me. It is an aspect of fun, but fun is the umbrella, competition one of the umbrella's strings.

Edit: And by the way -- yeah I've done what you ask. The game seems bland in that case to me, but I recognize that's not the case for everyone. Maybe I'm just getting old. After all, I've been playing the game religiously since the first iteration, and items have always spiced up the battles crazily.
I can understand that to be sure, but items don't exactly affect everyone the same way, even randomly. Characters with more mobility, which are usually already some of the better characters in that game, have an advantage when it comes to getting items than the slower, more bulky characters. And the randomness factor is, to many people, a negative thing - there is nothing more frustrating than losing a match because both your rival and you got Poke Balls, but you got a Goldeen while your rival got a Lugia.

Items definitely have their place. In more casual play, such as FFA on random stages, they add a lot of variety and silliness to the wacky gameplay. Which is great, to be sure! But when you're trying to play seriously, randomness has much less place. Randomness inherent in card games and the like is more equivalent to some of Smash's more minor random elements - where each player starts off in Brawl, or Mr. G&W's Judgment number. Items are more like if you were playing a TCG and, instead of building your own decks, each player was assigned a random precon. Which is a lot of fun! But it shouldn't be considered more "valid" than the more competitively pure version of the game.
 
if little mac isn't a playable character then thats the biggest L for the franchise
that crowd noise is for him :'(

do it Sakurai




I still believe in Toad or Bowser jr, give the mario franchise 4328309432 character represents B^)
 

Gartooth

Member
2014 Year of The Toad. Believe it.

I don't know whether or not the Mario series will get anymore new reps in Smash now that Rosalina is in, and if it does then the character might end up unlockable. Still, I maintain that aside from Paper Mario, Toad remains the best choice for a Mario series rep. Freaking Luma got a more important role in Smash than Toad, so the idea that "Toad isn't a fighter!" can die now that we see a cute little star person who cries and calls out for mommy put on some angry eyes and beat the crap out of people.
 

RomanceDawn

Member
If they would just eliminate (most of) the charge time, I think Fludd could be pretty scary. Seems like it'd be a solid way to get indirect kills, kinda like the cape.

I've seen people do some amazing things with it in Brawl. Still I hope it becomes even more useful.

I've never had strong feelings either way toward Rosalina because of her design. It's just so boring and too Peachy for me. But seeing how Sakurai has included Galaxy's second player Luma, the star bits, gravity, spinning star, and the wii mote aesthetic… The design behind her gameplay mechanics is just astounding to say the least! She truly deserves in.

Often times I see move sets posted for characters and more often than not they are just fairly generic moves inspired by that characters games. This however, just like the Villager is on an entirely different level of creativity.

I wonder if Sakurai has any social or sanitary issues. He's gotta be deficient some where to be such a creative genius.
 

justchris

Member
I was hoping for Rosalina, but was worried there might be too much Mario representation already, and then we got Rosalina and I can't stop smiling, oh god, somebody help me.
 

Platy

Member
Holy crap!
ibdhafQK2nbzDj.gif

Didn't noticed the item black hole in the trailer !

RIDICULOUS TIER for "itens on" matches
 

ec0ec0

Member
Maybe they'll get Chibi-Robo to replace R.O.B. now that he has that new Chibi Robo Photo game announced.

highlighting this so mods wont miss it, and can BAN him. I will protect you R.O.B.

EDIT: i have already waited TWO minutes, AND HE IS STILL NOT BANNED!?
 

emb

Member
Didn't noticed the item black hole in the trailer !

RIDICULOUS TIER for "itens on" matches
I don't know about all that. Looks like a good ability, but it also looks like she's really open while doing it (unless it also blocks direct attacks).
 

Toxi

Banned
She represents the Mario Galaxy series, that's why
Huh, props to Nintendo for recognizing one of their most quality game series of all time. Maybe we'll finally get some real Metroid Prime representation.

She looks really interesting because she can constantly attack from two directions, and I'm hoping she's a heavyweight.
 

justchris

Member
She sort of plays like a combo of Ice Climbers and Olimar, except she's also her own special star. She can summon Lumas, but it appears they have their own special moves separate from hers, whereas Nana & Popo always do the same attacks (unless you desync them, hope desyncing is still in).
 

Caladrius

Member
I don't remember her dress being iridescent like that.

Anyway, I'm happy with this addition. It isn't Waluigi like the more unrealistic part of me was hoping, but they've made her enough of an interesting fighter that I'm not bent up over it.

Now we get to wait 6 more months for another newcomer!
 

FlynnCL

Unconfirmed Member
Maybe they'll get Chibi-Robo to replace R.O.B. now that he has that new Chibi Robo Photo game announced.

But R.O.B. is awesome and has one of the most fun playstyles in Brawl.

Plus, if R.O.B. is gone then we'll also miss out on Kirby's crazily cute imitation of him. :(
 

Timeaisis

Member
Sorry for all of the incoming GIFs!

A Luma is Born!
iihioTjSCNTJA.gif

I think that is Rosalina's Down-Special Neutral-Special. My guess is that Rosalina's base attacks don't have a lot of range, and Luma will remedy that giving Rosalina a lot of range and versatility. And maybe using Down-B again will make the Luma go further away or come closer.

Launch Star!
idrQfG6jqhGSJ.gif
ibnzzSzIsc7R4z.gif

That is most definitely Rosalina's Up-Special (recovery). I think that it may be possible to use Luma to attack even though Rosalina can't do anything, but because she can't do anything and it seems Luma copies what Rosalina does, that theory is probably a bust.

Holy crap!
ibdhafQK2nbzDj.gif
iYVyKXWzKk8YE.gif

I think that is Rosalina's Neutral-Special Down-Special. Seems pretty crazy. Also has that Wiimote pointer like effect in the Galaxy games, which is cool.

Luma Helps Rosalina With Attacks!
iMcsuALFJqfUb.gif
iPD5LElSDx5Hi.gif

I think this was fairy obvious, but still pointing it out. Luma makes Rosalina's attacks stronger. The ring attack looks like an Up-Tilt, while the other is a Down-Smash.
And as everyone noticed, Rosalina has mini Galaxy-like things appear.
Also, one woman/star WOMBO COMBO!

Luma Helps Rosalina Out Of Sticky Situations!
i1V9YzyVNVNBC.gif
iuryary1GBrRj.gif
iY5sGCbLBFzYM.gif

Seems like Luma is the real hero here. Taking dat charge shot to the face!

ihgREGwvNzrSb.gif

Goodbye Luma, you're a true hero keeping the Galaxy princess safe. ;(

Luma Attacks!
ieNpuofEgsCpW.gif

Rosalina sends Luma spiraling to the left, and then Luma finishes off
the evil
Villager using star bits to pop his balloons. And then goes back to Rosalina.

Luma Takes Down Evil Tree!
ibdNg0j9xbvTFG.gif

Luma takes down the evil Villager's evil tree! There is nothing more to this and is just here as a joke lol.
If you look at the mirror, you can see Wii Fit Trainer warming up to kick some ass.


Thanks to ffdgh for correcting the Down-Special/Neutral-Special parts.


Rosalina looks top tier to me.

+ Item Magnet neutral b
+ Luma partner that can attack a different area/enemy and desync with Rosie
+ An attack redirect of some kind (see Mario's FLUDD attack gif)
+ Good recovery
+ Luma can block attacks and save Rosie from grabs
+ Luma edgeguarding without putting Rosie at risk
- Probably pretty weak without Luma partner
- Probably low range or lack of versatility without Luma
- Luma is likely weak/easy to kill
- Slow Luma spawn animation

To me, that means, if you can get good at keeping the Luma alive, Rosalina will be a beast.
 

Platy

Member
It also sets up a hilarious moment where she accidentally sucks up a bomb with some other items.

hehe yes !

Specialy awesome if it works like the DaBoss imagined with it being both an item magnet AND a reflector like atack.

Bomb on stage ?
Charged blast on Rosalina ! xD
 

Toxi

Banned
Sorry for all of the incoming GIFs!
Awesome analysis. I get the feeling that if Rosalina combines these factors with her usual heavyweight status, she's going to be very high on the tier list. Think Ice Climbers with more survivability.
 

Kyzon

Member
Luma Helps Rosalina With Attacks!
iMcsuALFJqfUb.gif
iPD5LElSDx5Hi.gif

I think this was fairy obvious, but still pointing it out. Luma makes Rosalina's attacks stronger. The ring attack looks like an Up-Tilt, while the other is a Down-Smash.
And as everyone noticed, Rosalina has mini Galaxy-like things appear.
Also, one woman/star WOMBO COMBO!
[/B]

Looks like she attacks with her Forward Air attack after Luma launches, also I'd guess that the upward wand wave is her up tilt as opposed to the halo thing which seems to act as an up smash.

If you have a gif, you can add her Down Air as a Meteor Spike as well.

We've got a goldmine of footage for her. I'd have to really sit down to analyze everything, but I have a good gist from what we've seen.

Everything else you've said seems spot on though.
 

IntelliHeath

As in "Heathcliff"
Rosalina GIFs look sooo awesome. I can't really wait for the game to be release so I can give her a try. I'm concerned about Palutena's chance now.

Next week. Zelda reveal for JP launch of Link Between Worlds. We'll have a screenshot of the three princesses.

I hope so. I really do.

hey, the pokeball is smaller now

Yeah, it seem so. Also we got confirmation for two items, Green Shell and Fire Flower.
 

DaBoss

Member
IntelliHeath pointed out a problem with the Luma Summoning and how I put it as a Neutral-Special. That would mean Kirby would also be able to do that, which is very unlikely. But we did see Kirby act friendly with Luma in the trailer.

Also, here is why the Gravity Field move is a Down-Special:
i5260bO2OYGr8.gif

Looks like she attacks with her Forward Air attack after Luma launches, also I'd guess that the upward wand wave is her up tilt as opposed to the halo thing which seems to act as an up smash.

If you have a gif, you can add her Down Air as a Meteor Spike as well.

We've got a goldmine of footage for her. I'd have to really sit down to analyze everything, but I have a good gist from what we've seen.

Everything else you've said seems spot on though.

Actually, you can see the yellow-ish hue that happens when you charge a smash attack with the wand wave thing.

I did have one uploaded, forgot to put it, thanks for reminding me lol.
iAJHf9EhVcLI2.gif
 
Does anyone else wish that they would change Link's design to the one from Hyrule Warriors? Say what you will about the game, but the design for Link in that game is great! Hell to get it into Smash 4 it would only be some small edits to the existing model.
 
Looks like she attacks with her Forward Air attack after Luma launches, also I'd guess that the upward wand wave is her up tilt as opposed to the halo thing which seems to act as an up smash.

If you look closely, it seems like the upward wand wave has the glow/effect of a chargeable smash attack, where the ring does not. I'd say the ring is definitely the up tilt.

I might be wrong, but I think the wave of the wand is a throw. You can see Rosalina grab pit and a visual effect appear around him just before she waves her wand.

She definitely throws first, but when the Luma hits, you can see the up smash.
 

DaBoss

Member
Looks like she attacks with her Forward Air attack after Luma launches, also I'd guess that the upward wand wave is her up tilt as opposed to the halo thing which seems to act as an up smash.
Here's a GIF to show what we mean:
ibqbKNcfyMNXyC.gif

And it seems to be a hand slap and not a wand wave.
 

Kouichi

Member
Does anyone else wish that they would change Link's design to the one from Hyrule Warriors? Say what you will about the game, but the design for Link in that game is great! Hell to get it into Smash 4 it would only be some small edits to the existing model.

I was thinking the same thing. It's my favorite Adult Link design.

The blue scarf is so cool.
 
Top Bottom