Personally, I don't like being forced into playing a way I wouldn't want to. As much as I loved Black Ops 1, the Pro Perk requirements were obnoxious. I hate Capture the Flag, but had to play it to get certain Pro Perks to use in other game modes.
Similarly, if I don't want to play squads or I don't want to do arbitrary objectives, I just don't believe it's good game design to force me to do those things just so I can put a scope on my LMG. I mean, I get that they want people to play this stuff that they bothered to create and jump through hoops, but if it's not fun, I'm not going to do it.
You're right that one "advantage" over previous systems is that you can do things before you would've been able to because rank doesn't matter. But it's only an advantage because of the restrictions of previous systems. There's no reason you can't have a quick accumulation of points and the ability to unlock stuff at any rank you want.
I know you say that squad points aren't that hard to get, but I feel they are. I don't believe it's fun or exciting to put hours and hours into a game only to be locked out of tons of content that's just sitting there. I have four hours clocked and I have four guns to play with. It gets worse if I want to use them well with attachments.
Honestly, it feels like they're just prepping the next step: to charge real money to get around their harsh arbitrary restrictions.
Well the good thing is there's no more pro perks, at least I can't see. The only ops unlocks you get are for clothing items and the ghillie suit. And yeah I can see Activision using this as a means test to say "Hey what are people willing to put up with before we start charging for this stuff in game" but I think that would totally be the last dying gasp of COD and even though people are pooping on the sales, we're nowhere near where it was with plastic skate boards and tony hawk.
Try out the squad system, you can even make all your dudes look the same and name them to the same name
Use the initial 3 points to unlock the gun you want rather than spending 7 to 9 points and you'll have enough to get the attatchments. Perks on the other hand, you'll have to hamster wheel for it or get more points.
If you're really resistant squad mode you don't really have to actively participate in it. You can just look at your squad reports and see if you got a few more squad points. The better you rank up your "main" the better the odds your squad will get a winning record thus more xp. Its yet another time sync, but can't possibly be any longer than going from rank 1 to 50 (or whatever the cap is in this one). Then again I don't tend to max out and prestige within the first week of COD releases
Also don't we have Double Xp right now from buying or preordering the game? Don't forget to put your code in
Also to add to what you were saying about having to do arbitrary things, its pretty much the same thing as previous games. You had to rack x amount of kills to unlock x y and z, it was just tied to rank. They're never going to get rid of the time sink, however at least this time I can skip over red dot and go holo if I want instead of having to kill yet another x amount of dudes.
I think its a feeling of perception, which IS very important. It may take the same amount of time, but it "feels" longer because of the way the point system is designated. And even that perception can make or break an experience regardless of the illusion on a whole
I think we just see it in different lights is all.
The thing is, in the end, we'll have what we want unlocked and we'll be fine with it. Also, I'm not high enough level yet, but its possible that you get more squad points as you level up. I'm not sure if its just one point per rank, because 50 points to rank 50 would be paltry. Its possible you get more as you go, I mean for crying out loud to unlock the last squad member you need 400 points.
Also, come to think of it, speaking of killing x amount of dudes. this is the first COD I played where I'm not exclusively killing BROWN DUDES all the time or being the Brown dude getting killed all the time because of the character customizations. I REALLY, REALLY like that.