Think I'll grab PM64 then, hopefully actually get around to playing it someday! Should've mentioned I did rather enjoy TTYD and Super Mario RPG back in the day. So that makes Earthbound, NSMB2, Link's Awakening, Paper Mario, and Mario 64 so far. I'm digging this fire sale! Still have carts of Link to the Past and Super Metroid (Earthbound too, but that seems worth it to get a backup of).
Quick question before I order them actually... is it possible to use the Wii U Gamepad to play N64 games in Wii mode? Or do I need to bust out a Wii-mote? That would kind of kill it for me, since I don't have a classic controller, and Mario 64 on a wii-mote sounds not great.