Ps4 being another Ps2 is a HUGE compliment, actually.
X1 definitely isn't a X360-2, imo. Gone is the cheaper price, gone are the superior multiplatform games and Japanese support will probably be nihil this time around.
I'm going to get both consoles eventually. But as a gamer, the Ps4 is currently far more appealing to me. The rpice is perfect, the games are good, Sony has one of the best dev teams out there. The multiplatform games are superior as well. PS+ is a bit meh at this point for the Ps4, but I'm sure it's going to change soon.
I am surprised they are even giving free games for the PS4 so early in the cycle. I was expecting PS+ to purely be a subscription for online (and PS3 and vita freebies) until next year when the library builds up.