whew, good thing you're on the case. town almost lost this one
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Werewolf |OT| Was it all just a Dream?
- Thread starter Palmer_v1
- Start date
whew, good thing you're on the case. town almost lost this one
Normally, you don't quote somebody else's post to defend your own position. You said we were "probably in LyLo" then didn't say shit about it afterwards. It's fine if you've changed your mind, but you don't get to say I'm deflecting when I press you on it.
Whenever I target someone, I get a PM that tells me what commands they can use at night. You have protect and kill. I am looking at the PM right now and you just keep saying "why's you lying?" Just counterclaim, dude. I don't know how you think this makes you look Town.
Here's what I will do if it appeases the town. I'll use my ability on Time tonight.
1. If I die and he does not, he's a wolf.
2. If we both die, you'll see Mak is lying.
3. If we both survive, he's confirmed town. Saw is lynched today, she'll flip wolf. If we flip Mak or sept tomorrow, there can't be 7 wolves according to bats, so there we go.
I will only agree to this if town agrees to lynch sept / mak / fire upon my death because I seriously am dubious of this town's ability to make logical decisions.
1. If I die and he does not, he's a wolf.
2. If we both die, you'll see Mak is lying.
3. If we both survive, he's confirmed town. Saw is lynched today, she'll flip wolf. If we flip Mak or sept tomorrow, there can't be 7 wolves according to bats, so there we go.
I will only agree to this if town agrees to lynch sept / mak / fire upon my death because I seriously am dubious of this town's ability to make logical decisions.
And I'm telling you, my role does not have a kill command. I am literally saying that right now. There's your roleclaim. I don't kill people. So the fact that you are lying about that, yeah, I'm going to press you about that.
It's very clear to me you are trying to get a roleclaim out of me. If you've "caught me in a lie" like you say, isn't it enough that I've denied your accusations? If people believe you are who you say you are, then you've already won the battle. The fact that you keep prodding me for a roleclaim when I've denied the pertinent part of your accusation (that I can kill people, which again, I cannot) leads me to believe you just really, really, really want me to claim. And why? Hmmm....
Also, I don't really care about "looking town" right now, I care about finding scum, and guess what? I found one and his name is Makai.
I don't have much of a problem with this honestly. Sawneeks hasn't done much to defend herself. Makai and Timeaisis can be sorted out in the next day.
My confirmation bias is getting exponentially stronger.
YES I AM THE PROBLEM HERE
So my role is Guard Apprentice. I'm your backup doctor! I activated once cabot died, who I, by the way, didn't know was the doctor until he died. My first night action was N3.
Here's who I protected:
N3: Burbeting
N4: Batsnacks
N5: Boo Boo'n
N6: Boo Boo'n
My justifications: I protected Burb because of his role and because he was the deputy. I'm pretty sure he was sucessfully protected because we only had one death. On N4, I should've protected Burb but I chose batsnacks in a moment of doubt. This was a mistake, as Burb died. On N5 I protected Boo because of his reveal and because he was providing us information, also because he was pretty much confirmed town by then as well. Yesterday, I protected Boo again for basically the exact same reasons.
I protected Boo twice because he's basically the only confirmed town we have with a useful power role. My big plan today was to deputize boo, protect him again to ensure he stays alive and we still retain one town PR.
There you go, guys.
Here's who I protected:
N3: Burbeting
N4: Batsnacks
N5: Boo Boo'n
N6: Boo Boo'n
My justifications: I protected Burb because of his role and because he was the deputy. I'm pretty sure he was sucessfully protected because we only had one death. On N4, I should've protected Burb but I chose batsnacks in a moment of doubt. This was a mistake, as Burb died. On N5 I protected Boo because of his reveal and because he was providing us information, also because he was pretty much confirmed town by then as well. Yesterday, I protected Boo again for basically the exact same reasons.
I protected Boo twice because he's basically the only confirmed town we have with a useful power role. My big plan today was to deputize boo, protect him again to ensure he stays alive and we still retain one town PR.
There you go, guys.
For the record, I didn't want to have to claim, but there you have it. Do you see Makai is lying now? It doesn't add up.
Two nights where I protected people we've had one death overall: when I protected Burb (who was town) and when I protected Boo (who is very likely town).
Two nights where I protected people we've had one death overall: when I protected Burb (who was town) and when I protected Boo (who is very likely town).
I have no idea. We should've had 3 KILLS that night but we only had one. I admit I was responsible for protecting ONE OF THOSE. I have no idea what happened to the next one. Probably hit someone who was NK immune.
What, are you saying scum has two night kills? The multiple deaths in the early days were explained by batsnacks and swamped. Give us your theory for why Rats didn't kill anyone.
The same people? lol
I'm curious who else aside from czar assumed Time was a doctor before he claimed. Maybe I'm the minority here but I didn't assume there were 2 doctors and didn't think about the possibility of an "apprentice doctor" role. I figured it was a roleblock or some 1-shot ability.
Vote: Makai
Vote: Makai
I started the vote for Crimson.
Night?
Why do you think that? Just curious.
Also, you don't have to speak in all caps, anymore, Tim. It's over now.
People fake claim, even town. You did. A town doctor/roleblocker could very feasibly fake claim ordinary town at first. You could have just said what you thought when I asked instead of doing some multi-post question and answer exposition.
But anyway time's claim is solid and makai's role could explain why rats didn't kill.
Uh...how? I'm like a nerfed role cop.
Why would I out the town doctor if I didn't need to?
You brought it up
. Time was never getting lynched today. Saying "Time isn't lying" as if it's a fact in response to my post about the possibility of Time lying is going to get my attention.I haven't defended myself because I messed up pretty bad and am now in an impossible situation. Idc if you lynch a Neutral or not so whatever.