-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Forza Horizon 2 · Review Thread
- Thread starter strata8
- Start date
Lol what??? The reactions here are NOTHING like that thread.
It's Hoo-doo....
Ignoring the fact that there was a Demo out, we had pre-embargo 1-hour streams and got a good impression of the full game because of that. I am sure we can say that Polygon does not like Horizon much, seeing they also reviewed the first game really low.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
Your not going to be giving up on this one I see.
Soon to be a livery.
Great scores so far, I'm very happy for Playground and Turn 10.
Yeah, it always makes me cringe to see that.
If you don't think it's a little embarrassing to post 'LOL' and hilarious reaction gifs for a 7/10 review score when you haven't played the full game and the reviewers have, then I don't know what to tell you. It's a weird mindset. Why not actually read the review.
Ah yes, you played a demo and watched a stream. Surely you are now fit to review the game.
Cringe.
mangochutney
Member
Well this review certainly fills itself with validity.Press-Start said:
Words get in the way. Give me the numbers!!!! You're right, it is funny. I mean if you read some of the 8s and 9s they often read no different to the 7s, but hey-ho.
I was more talking about how you worded it. I wrote above why the reactions could be like that. But comparing it with the UC3 dilemma is a little overboard.
Huh, where did I say anything about the review? I am not judging anything, just trying to explain it.
Banjo-Kazooie
Member
What if you have played the full game and find a 7/10 LOL worthy?
it is still upto the reviewer what score it gets, I mean a lot of people played the destiny alpha/beta and thought it was pretty good, yet a lot of review sites gave it a 7.
Horizon 2 sets an intimidatingly high bar for those games to meet on every front, but in one aspect it seems unbeatable. I can't imagine any of them are going to feel this happy.
What an excellent quote from Eurogamer, man. Having played the full game myself for a good few hours last night, I have to agree. I had a permanent smile etched on my face the entire time. The game is breathtakingly good.
What an excellent quote from Eurogamer, man. Having played the full game myself for a good few hours last night, I have to agree. I had a permanent smile etched on my face the entire time. The game is breathtakingly good.
HighResTomato
Member
Xbox thread... what do you expect from him?
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
That's good to hear, that's how I felt when playing the demo, and for the majority of my time spent with the first Horizon. It doesn't bode well for my productivity over the next month or so, though.
travisbickle
Member
If a racing game didn't get a few 6s and 7s you wouldn't be called crazy to think the games media had been paid off.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
So, any Xbox 360-specific reviews or impressions?
Banjo-Kazooie
Member
Don't forget to join the GAF Club! Road trip with your bros.
soundscream
Member
Daffy Duck
Member
Polygon brighten up even the darkest of days.
A week tomorrow, and I cannot wait!
A week tomorrow, and I cannot wait!
about polygon, I would be up for discussion if they are ridiculous or not,
IF they didnt give nfs rivals an 8.5
http://www.polygon.com/2013/11/18/5116316/need-for-speed-rivals-review
they did give it 8.5 though, so there is no discussion to be had whether they are ridiculous or not
you might say "different reviewer" but I will say that this shits all over their consistency -if they ever cared to have one.
digoutyoursoul
Member
The Uncharted 3 thread was people having meltdowns at Eurogamer over a great score 8/10. This thread isn't like that. I do think Polygon can be pedantic at times but each to their own. Congrats Playground Games.
Always-honest
Banned
InsideGamer (The Netherlands)
9+
+ Crazy amount of content
+ Complete freedom
+ Beatiful weathereffects
+ Useful voice-commands with Kinect
- Dynamic weather gets interupted
- Some minor flaws
9+
+ Crazy amount of content
+ Complete freedom
+ Beatiful weathereffects
+ Useful voice-commands with Kinect
- Dynamic weather gets interupted
- Some minor flaws
I didn't?
Of course i'm not saying that the situations are remotely the same, but it does remind me of that thread. Just the outrage at a lower digit coming from people who simply are not in the position to know whether that score is actually deserved or not. That is all.
soundscream
Member
It would have been some cheap non FFB piece of crap at that price.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
I don't see what the fuss is over the Polygon review, they have the right to their opinion, and besides, they seem to think that the game is better than the first Horizon. I could hardly give it a better compliment myself.
TheFLYINGManga_Ka
Member
Sounds great!
Hope reviews for 360 version is just over the horizon! I know, har, har!
Seriously, I hope its a good port.
Hope reviews for 360 version is just over the horizon! I know, har, har!
Seriously, I hope its a good port.
I just read it myself. And like I said in the other thread, I can see why one would knock the game for some "emptyness" for example. Then I read the NFS:R review and they gave that a 8.5 just because it lays a great foundation for future NFS games - despite it being broken...
Cheesecakebobby
Banned
Based on some of these reviews, Eurogamer's in particular, I have to wonder what it takes for a racing game to get a 10/10.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
Or a successor to the Wireless Speed Wheel, which would have been great. We really need one, and soon.
JackAubrey
Member
Excellent scores.
Congratulations Playground Games and Turn 10.
Congratulations Playground Games and Turn 10.
loaf of bread
Member
So same scores as the last one, nice. I'll probably be picking up Shadow of Mordor instead though and get this later.
REMEMBER CITADEL
Banned
The game needs to be reviewed in Croatia, and called Gran Turismo.
soundscream
Member
2.0 edition with the rumble triggers would be amazing.
Me neither. And the reasoning is the worst ("they do it for the clicks"). Sigh.
The game looks great, but some will disagree. Nothing to get upset about.
Everyone gets upset with polygon reviews. I think fair play to anyone's opinion. I actually like Arthur as well. I don't agree with him on this point, but hey. Dude gets a lot of hate but all of the rebel fm guys are cool in my book.
Can not wait for release date. Game seems to be incredible
Can not wait for release date. Game seems to be incredible
User 479360
Banned
shacklesmcgee
Member
Don't you guys love when a game gets all around good reviews? It just makes me happy for some reason.
Similar threads
- Poll
- Locked