There is no shame in having fun. Cynicism is a cancer to the gaming community.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Okay, TeamCG. Come own up to your foolishness. #trolljima
- Thread starter MormaPope
- Start date
There is no shame in having fun. Cynicism is a cancer to the gaming community.
The One Who Knocks
Member
That looks absolutely real to me; it's pretty crazy.
ComputerMKII
Banned
Kojima has been making the same game since 1998, with incremental gameplay tweaks and more stupid fanservice. He is not creative and is very much submissive to his fanbase/market research. He can save his soul but only by saying 'fuck you' to the industry, abandoning his franchises altogether and make something new.
Graphics Horse
Member
Wait so nobody thinks the tweeted photos could be CG? Why not? they can do amazing things with CG these days, Kojima Productions is the leader in the field!
Hold on a sec. Notice anything funny about that vid? Take a closer look. Sisko's left hand is bandaged while he's saying it's real. Now the bandage could link to Joakim and being on the left hand that is the language and memory side of the brain unlike the right which is where you would fabricate your lies all the while he's saying "It's real!". Hmmmm very interesting.
She looks fake in every single shot she is in.
If Joakim is CG I'll be really really surprised.
Amazing job if he really is CG though, can't wait to find out.
If somebody ends up making love to my avatar for me (avatar request thread), I will wear my avatar badge of awesomeness/shame for at least month after this ordeal (#Teamcg by the way).
SlipperyFishes
Banned
I'd forgotten about this, but elements of that advert really fell into the uncanny valley.
0:22-0:24 and 0:48-0:50
Undecided.
Somebody didn't get MGS2.
Salacious Crumb
Junior Member
Relaxed Muscle
Member
I think at moments is pretty convincing and in other the Uncanny Valley hits hard.
In that Gif is hitting pretty damn hard.
In that Gif is hitting pretty damn hard.
Looking at it on a monitor, but now that I'm looking at it with scrutiny everything below the face looks weird, sure. But that's really if I'm looking at it actively searching for any flaw. At first glance, practically nothing about it looked unnatural.
MGS2 isn't just a troll -- it's a hate letter.
LightofRohan
Member
True that! Those guys suck! Cant make a 100% real person. Fail.
It's pretty impressive what they were able to achieve 5 years ago! Yikes.CountAntonius
Member
I want to believe.
Hmm. Hard to argue with The Sisko.
Salacious Crumb
Junior Member
You can spot the irregularities straight away when you look for them. On the other hand people have put every millisecond of this interview under a microscope and the best anyone can come up with to convince us that it's CG is a strange shadow on the guys chin and his lips look a bit puffy.
#Teamreal
Graphics Horse
Member
What do you mean by below the face?
True that! Those guys suck! Cant make a 100% real person. Fail.
It doesn't suck, but there's no way in hell that would pass off as real.
Hot Coldman
Banned
yo that's creepy as shit yo
I'm part of #TeamReal, by the way.
Uh... below the face? The face looks natural to me but the movement below it looks off.
Lostconfused
Member
I think it's real. Anything that seems wrong with the facial movement can be explained by the bandages being tied to tightly around the face or causing discomfort.
It's the face that looks fake to me =\
How do you explain him talking with just his lips?
YouEnjoyMySelf
Banned
Loving all the people who don't "get" MGS. Kojima's "got" you in the best way possible.
Graphics Horse
Member
It's just that the face was the only part that's CG.
This
looks real to you?
What are you looking at it on, a smartphone?
It looks good, but it still has both the rubberyness and awkward body movements of CG.
SkylineRKR
Member
I never saw that Audrey commercial but its both creepy and intruiging. But you can quite easily see its CG.
Really? Well, fuck, now I'm thinking my ability to perceive fake people from real is botched. Maybe this Mogren guy is CG after all...
Hahaha. The face is real, the body is real. It was filmed on location with a look-a-like actress and then a effects company called Framestore went through all of Audrey's previous films, tv appearance and old photos and fitted this to the footage. Performance capture and real time CG animation are poles apart. This thread I think is making us all go a little bit mental.
SkylineRKR
Member
Then it looks incredibly awkward. She looks off compared to the others in there. But perhaps because its serving as a double.
Graphics Horse
Member
I don't know what it is but something is just different between the face and the rest of the body. I just can't put my finger on it......
VeryGooster
Banned
Back and forth back and forth
bravo
SnakeLinkSonic
Member
Kojima's already won.
Turned thread of gamers into a bunch of nitwits arguing over Audrey Hepburn and some random and likely made-up Swedish game developer.
Turned thread of gamers into a bunch of nitwits arguing over Audrey Hepburn and some random and likely made-up Swedish game developer.
lol
Back and forth back and forth
It has never BEEN easy.
Salacious Crumb
Junior Member
All that work and it doesn't look half as convincing as Mogren, these guys should've gotten in touch with Kojima.
Sounds like a pretty CG face reading the above link.
VeryGooster
Banned
This thread is the new AI construct. Our devices from which we post on GAF are the new Metal Gear. This is MGS5, right now.
Have you followed Kojima's career? This would be a tame conspiracy for him.
No the metal gear hd collection is on my list. Its probably up my alley since I have always been facinated by cold war conspiracys.
Oh god, this man isn't initiated.
What? He literally just said why, because the bandages are wrapped.
I'm creating a new team, TeamNewTech, that says that this is some sort of new motion capture technology, or something like that. I don't know.
SnakeLinkSonic
Member
D
Deleted member 80556
Unconfirmed Member
I don't think there'll be much fun if it's just real.
To be honest, if all the fucking interview was to say: "I'm sorry Geoff, I cannot confirm that" and just show that they're using the Fox Engine, then that was pointless.
Geoff should've said: THEN WHAT THE HELL CAN YOU CONFIRM?!