-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Yu Suzuki: I expect individual backers to provide the majority of funds for Shenmue
- Thread starter ShogunDarius
- Start date
lol. Agreed. (wait, are you not kidding?)
Just ignore the article, and ridicule it when it comes up. Doing anything else seems like a waste of time, and lends to even more of a controversy which -- you guessed it -- contributes to clicks for their lame article.
If Sony haven't locked anything in, I'd really like MS to come in and say 'look, give us same day release with PS4 and we will contribute' - and I say this as a PS4 only gamer.
I don't think Shenmue fans give a hoot about exclusivity. Xbone fans would be glad to have the option and I don't think it sounds like it would cost MS alot versus the goodwill / PR theyd earn.
I don't think Shenmue fans give a hoot about exclusivity. Xbone fans would be glad to have the option and I don't think it sounds like it would cost MS alot versus the goodwill / PR theyd earn.
Tricky I Shadow
Banned
DIG DEEP, THINK SMART! LET'S MAKE $10 MILLION POSSIBLE!
Elfforkusu
Member
Hard to say, but probably in the $5-$7m range right now (depending how well it sustains momentum and peaks towards the end).
As for whether $10m is enough, I'll trust Yu on this one.
Nightengale
Member
UltraGunner
Banned
Damn, I thoight Sony were seriously helping out money wise 
This seriously bums me out.
This seriously bums me out.
hahaha
polygon isn't worth the time
it's totally a junk article though, and really quite spiteful when you think about it
With the amount money they had and time (14+ year and shemue 2 on Xbox) I wonder why?
Yup as I expected this anti Shenmue trolish campaign is one of those stupid console war. My childhood dream destroyed by a very vile and petty people.
King Beyond the wall
Member
I can't imagine a quirky niche japanese game with a considerable budget like shenmue being a success on the Xbox One. It would just be like dumping money down the drains for MS just to have a game that people can list as a big exclusive on the internet.
PandaPandaPanda
Member
they're not going to "bank roll" for all intents and purposes a risky ip that they don't even own
orthodoxy1095
Banned
Why would they want to fund it? If Sony doesn't want to properly fund it, why would Microsoft want to? It's just not a hugely profitable venture. It might even be appropriate to call it risky.
Box of Bunnies
Banned
You guys seem pretty hard dicked at the thought of it not being on Xbox.
Obviously that cant be some console warrior shit because clearly you just have the best interest of the game, that is primarily being funded by KS backers, at heart, which is why you want an entire segment not incentivised to back it as they would be if it was coming to their system.
Nightengale
Member
Yup. Even I can't help but feel some hate of myself for posting that image.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
I really don't care what platform it's on. It could be an Ouya exclusive and I'd still be throwing unhealthy amounts of money at it. I'm not really bothered by a platform being cut out. C'est la vie. If you care about the series, you'll fund it, regardless of system. I'd think not wanting to wait another decade is as good a damn incentivization as anyone needs.
I'm new be nice
Member
I can't get over how apt a descriptor "concern trolling" is.
And yes, it was strong here.
The Spoony Hou
Member
So what's the point of making it exclusive if Sony isn't doing much?
Chaos2Frozen
Member
It's coming to PC.
Nightengale
Member
This. So much.
It's Shenmue 3. The fact that it can & will exist is all that matters* Even assuming Sony is scummy, so what? Corporation are also people, they want to make money, what's it to (the haters) that you trample on the hopes & dreams of other normal people just to satiate your crusade against this 'made-up fantasy' corporate injustice? If you're an Xbox owner that loves Shenmue, you would kickstart this, and just tweet to Phil to ask for it to eventually come to Xbox. Not... do crap like what we've seen on GAF.
*unless the game's funded by blood-money or money that comes from criminal activities
Why would people who play on Xbox fund it? Your argument is flawed.
Coming to PC and marketing + devt + other support. See this is the problem to some people : why it have to be Sony why? Oh God why?
Tricky I Shadow
Banned
Fortinbras
Member
People are voting for Shenmue 3 on the Xbox feedback site.
The game is getting far more votes than the FF7 Remake.
wait how is it spiteful? because the article was sponsored by microsoft?
What? My console is the Xbox and I funded it. People can afford multiple mediums, it's not just "stick with one thing this entire generation." I appreciate Yu's work on Shenmue since playing Shenmue on DC and 2 on Xbox.
StrongBlackVine
Banned
This is disappointing, but there must good reasoning why no major company is willing to invest much in this game.
I really hate the concern trolling and shit posting so many were doing in the first thread. It is so much worse now with this information.
Honestly, I'd put more trust in Yu Suzuki as he already planned on making a game that would satisfy the fans way more than a light novel/comic would. So if you don't get that open world game, the game will not suddenly turn into something unworthy of being a Shenmue game.
He made Shenmue 1 and 2 after all.
Honestly, I'd put more trust in Yu Suzuki as he already planned on making a game that would satisfy the fans way more than a light novel/comic would. So if you don't get that open world game, the game will not suddenly turn into something unworthy of being a Shenmue game.
He made Shenmue 1 and 2 after all.
Gambit 1138
Banned
On a budget of $2 million we'll be lucky if its a linear, QTE-heavy Telltale esque game.
openrob
Member
Wait a lull little bit. Yu said they are creating some backing tiers above 500.
See what they have to offer!
Chaos2Frozen
Member
The same reason it took an entire decade for this kickstarter to happen.
The last game wasn't so hot sales wise.
I know many people own multiple consoles, I do. But a lot of people do stick with one console.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
The argument isn't flawed. This is a game that has been dead for 14 years. Not dormant. Not in mobile spin-off land. Dead. If you are a fan of the series, you will fund it regardless of the platform is on. You will find a way to play it.
For God's sakes, it's coming to PC. Pretty much everyone should have a way to play this. It's not going to break your computer specs.
no, just very poor understanding of the facts and no desire to do the appropriate research/follow up to give a clearer picture of what's happening
it's run and gun journalism
Nightengale
Member
If you're a fan of the console more than a fan of the series, sure.
If you're a fan of the series more than the console, you'd fund it.
Its only one of the sources of funding.
Hockeymac18
Member
I would love this for a few reasons:
1) Selfishly I would love to see this since I only have an XB1. I'll buy on PC, but would love to get on XB1, too (I'd even buy it on PS4 just to show my support, even though I don't have a PS4 - that's how much I want this game to succeed)
2) Shenmue is one of those games I believe that is really magically and deserves to be on as many platforms as possible. More people should have the chance to be exposed to this wonderful story and universe.
3) It'd make for a great story and demonstrate that this industry still has some people in it that actually want to see these types of games happen, even if they're risky and likely to fail financially - and two rival companies working together to make it a reality? Even more special.
I don't think it'll happen, but would love to see it.
orthodoxy1095
Banned
Precisely.
Poor sales of the previous games, at a guess.
Then the premise of the initial retort needs to be adjusted. Shenmue fans on the whole are very supportive of the project, regardless of where their ship has sailed.
Kwansu Dudes
Member
If that's so, why not donate anyway? PS4 will be cheap by its release or they can play on their PC. Seems like a very petty reason to not donate to a game that has been dormant for 14+ years and one that relies on individual backing. I don't own a Wii-U but if shenmue was exclusive to it, I'd still back it.
Well put.
Callibretto
Member
I was thinking I'll just wait till it release and buy it normally. But I think I'll kickstart this when I got home, even though I was never a fan since I never even played shenmue 1&2. But it's for a good cause.
Whoa.
maybe because it isn't. Shemue III is a multiplatform game.