BuggeryBugz
Member
Thanks.
that's pretty shitty if it doesn't though. Was hoping for a PS4 type situation where you can plug in any headset and get in-game audio.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Announcing the XOne stereo headset adapter - FINALLY
- Thread starter Ubersnug
- Start date
Thanks.
that's pretty shitty if it doesn't though. Was hoping for a PS4 type situation where you can plug in any headset and get in-game audio.
enanogrande
Member
Add party member?
They don't at this point in time, doesn't mean it isn't coming. Probably will come at the same time as them sending surround signals over the optical out.
And yes, game audio will be coming out of the adapter. Polk has already said as much. Otherwise, the 4-Shot is fucked because it has no other cables.
MS wouldn't sell a stereo headset that doesn't output game audio. Would they? what would be the point? it's 80$...
one mutes chat audio coming in (the player), one mutes your audio going out (controller)? Dunno.
It's not a perfect implementation on the Wii U like it is with the DS4, though, since it doesn't universally send audio 100% of the time. Still, I was really thinking that this stereo headset adapter was sending game audio. I'm kind of astonished it doesn't.
molnizzle
Member
It seems that game audio is restricted to the official headset. If you use a different headset with the adapter, you'll have to plug into the back of the Xbone itself to get game audio (as well as the controller for chat).
It's right there in the press release:
buckeye4life
Banned
Without Xbox one adding dolby digital, this adapter will be useless for most, as it will be just stereo sound, correct ?
I don't understand how this can be done, what kind of magic has the official headset inside to allow game audio???
but isn't that the point of the adapter? To do whatever finagling is necessary to the incoming signal, and output it via a 3.5mm socket? The only point to having one would be to use existing headsets but you get chat only.
So you wait for this adapter so you can save money by using your current headset, then you have to wait for more 3rd party headsets which will cost you more money? Sounds silly.
molnizzle
Member
So? Most of us already have a universal headset solution, I shouldn't have to buy new hardware for something so simple. MS is just trying to force more proprietary bullshit down our throats and make us buy all new shit. Both of their competitors support full plug-and-play with any headset.
It was assumed that this adapter would provide the same functionality. Fucking bullshit.
It's a restriction, pure and simple. There's no reason why this adapter couldn't output game audio to all headsets, MS is simply restricting it to officially licensed products. They want you to buy new shit.
LukasTaves
Member
That doesn't make much sense XD
Doesn't the official headset also use just a default jack that plugs in the adapter? Can they even recognize the device through that?
I see. Thanks for clearing it up!
Um. His math was right. Yours was off. Play and charge kit does not include the controller ( although they have been sold together ):
* XBONE controller : 60$
* play and charge : 25$
* headset adapter: 25$
I'll let you add that up.
justsomeguy
Member
that seems stupid to me
edit: could it be because they can't do 5.1/7.1 via the controller and they assume people will want to connect 5.1/7.1 headsets direct?
enanogrande
Member
OP should update with the no in-game audio thing, and maybe a mod should change title to reflect this as well, if only to bring more attention to thread. Maybe we can get a proper clarification of how things will work (regarding that Polk headset) from someone at MS.
No game audio.
No game audio.
buckeye4life
Banned
Unless Dolby digital is added, your headphones will not work like they are supposed to, and u will have stereo sound.
So your assumption is that everyone who buys this adapter already has a set of Turtle Beach or Astro's lying around?
Because that is completely ridiculous. There are thousands of superior headphone brands out there and everyone already has their own audio-gear at home.
Well, if it is true, and it does seem to be, any EXISTING third party headsets have to be either connected to the XOne directly or into the TV to receive any in game audio. All this means is that my Turtlebeach X5's will work exactly how they do on my 360 just now. Chat cable into the controller and optical cable from the Xone to my X5's amplifier - so, no real impact to me really. If and when I do finally upgrade, the new headset will probably be compatible with the adapter for full audio and chat.
Still, I understand why alot of other people would be disappointed.
Still, I understand why alot of other people would be disappointed.
molnizzle
Member
Or maybe you were planning on buying the adapter so you could use your Apple EarPods (or whatever) with your Xbone like you do with your PS4 and Wii U?
Derpcrawler
Member
I really wish they will allow adapter work the same way as DS4 (stream everything through 3.5mm jack). That's best feature of PS4 for me.
press release:
stereo headset -
stereo headset adapter -
edit: also
sounds pretty clear that they are different things. The stereo headset lets you balance in game audio, and play games while granny is sleeping. The adapter gives you chat audio only.
it is confusing that they refer to the accessory as the stereo headset adapter and use language that clearly implies it is the same adapter that comes with the full stereo headset. And yet they offer different functionality..
stereo headset -
stereo headset adapter -
edit: also
sounds pretty clear that they are different things. The stereo headset lets you balance in game audio, and play games while granny is sleeping. The adapter gives you chat audio only.
it is confusing that they refer to the accessory as the stereo headset adapter and use language that clearly implies it is the same adapter that comes with the full stereo headset. And yet they offer different functionality..
Dreams-Visions
Member
SOLD.
? They're not two different things. They perform the same functionality. That's why it specifically says "already have a set of stereo gaming headphones...."
Both are for pushing all the audio through a headset like the PS4 and its DS4. One is an all-in-one solution and the other is just the adapter.
? They're not two different things. They perform the same functionality. That's why it specifically says "already have a set of stereo gaming headphones...."
Both are for pushing all the audio through a headset like the PS4 and its DS4. One is an all-in-one solution and the other is just the adapter.
buckeye4life
Banned
Negative, unless dolby digital is added to the xbox one. Without dolby digital, most mixamps downsample to base stereo sound, which is not the case with the 360
I think a LOT of potential buyers are going to think that it does. This shit's hilarious.
BuggeryBugz
Member
This.
Surely it's not that hard to implement. I thought that's what the adapter was for.
Derpcrawler
Member
Yeah, that what confuses me. Description for adapter is different to the description of Headset. Will be disappointed if those are different adapters and cheap one without stereo headset doesn't allow all audio to go through controller.
Daffy Duck
Member
So this finally gives me the ability to use my Astro's as a device to chat on, and it manages game chat audio volume?
I assume this connects to my Mixamp out of the traditional port the 360 used?
I assume this connects to my Mixamp out of the traditional port the 360 used?
enanogrande
Member
Yup. The only thing I'm still confused/hasn't been fully explained is how these 'future' compatible headsets will work.
Here are some details from Polk.
http://www.polkaudio.com/forums/sho...ther-HEADSET&p=2007855&viewfull=1#post2007855
http://www.polkaudio.com/forums/sho...ther-HEADSET&p=2007855&viewfull=1#post2007855
statham
Member
maybe you can only adjust the chat audio volume but not ingame sound audio volume with the adapter?
either way, I'll probably get the official ones.
gimme pre-order pages.
That's using the assumption they were planning on doing the same thing Sony has done, which they aren't.
You can still connect your headphones through other means.
la flama blanca
Banned
People just accept the fact that you need an "adapter". Quite silly, lol.
Yeah, apparently if i'd want to use my Sennheisers i'd still have to be wired from Xbox to the couch.
It just makes no sense to me as to why they wouldn't support regular 3.5mm audio output. Is it just so they can peddle their proprietary garbage or is there a hardware-reason why it cannot?
Well, what else can we do? Without it, we can't use our existing headsets....
It's a different port on the controller, of course it would need an adapter.
molnizzle
Member
That's the point. Thing is, What Sony (and Nintendo) did is a "no brainer" and the new standard. Everyone is going to assume that this adapter will provide the same functionality, because otherwise what the fuck is it for? Everyone thought that the entire reason for the adapter was to allow for plug-and-play with standard headsets. Because obviously that's what it would be for, right?
MS is gonna get some pretty huge backlash from this.
that headset is 7.1 surround sound, and wireless. Big difference.
That is correct. Keep them wired.
Microsoft has never stated the adapter would be for anything otherwise.
And people with expensive and good headphones???
It really is. Sony really jips themselves out of opportunities to fleece their customers but I ain't complaining. Using my Apple earbuds to stream in-game audio is the best feature ever.
No they won't. People who have been waiting to use their old headsets will be happy.
People who created alternate visions in their heads may be disappointed.
did you read the quotes from the press release? I highlighted the parts where the descriptions are *clearly* different. The headset talks about balancing chat:game audio, and playing games without disturbing your family. The adapter section talks only about chat audio and adjusting chat volume.
They will use them the same way they have been using them. The headset adapter never had anything to do with them.