I don't think it's matter of conspiracy substain EG has more 'sympathy' toward MS brand. Sorry for the ot.
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Digital Foundry vs GTAV on XONE - performance analysis
- Thread starter mocoworm
- Start date
You can turn off DoF on PS4? I might actually consider double dipping now, I had no intention of doing so before.
Fake. The ratio on map is all wrong. Left screen looks like it's from 360.
Who made this comparison?
Spanky
Neo Member
Does seem odd that DF post this on release day just for XB1, the conspiracy theorists among us might wonder if they are hoping to try and boost the sales of it for XB1 by releasing this little bit of info early on release day - after all there is precious little other news for GTA5 on XB1.
Trees look the same, though, and those should be new for this release.
I wouldn't be so sure its not real. We'll find out pretty quickly.
1970 Chevelle SS
Neo Member
I hope they also come back and do a comparison for the PC in a couple months.
RandyBobandy
Banned
Wouldn't that be the reason they're doing it? PS4 version has had streams for days and there's been zip on the XB1 version. Makes sense to do it
Windom Earle
Member
How so?
Could be BUT it's highly probable xone would have less grass compared the ps4 version, especially because it's 1080p. I'll be surprise to the opposite.
If the XB1 version is the only one they've had for any length of time, its not surprising. We'll see a proper comparison soon enough once they've had time to analyse the PS4 version.
lol, holy shit
captainraincoat
Banned
Have both versions
cant honestly tell any difference apart from the eyebrows on some of the players looking worse on the ps4 version
i am suprised
cant honestly tell any difference apart from the eyebrows on some of the players looking worse on the ps4 version
i am suprised
here is a comparison video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5GVTwWTaGs
Looks practically the same except for color differences. But it's only the opening sequence.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K5GVTwWTaGs
Looks practically the same except for color differences. But it's only the opening sequence.
Still an obvious fake comparison. PS4 version is suffering from pop-in issue as well it's not a God-spec machine. The difference between the 2 systems hasn't been huge as Sony fans would've liked.
JonathanPower
Member
Bad coding is not CPU restriction.
psn
Member
captainraincoat
Banned
It looks washed out on the ps4....hope its not just my eyes
RandyBobandy
Banned
Is it just me or do the textures look sharper on the X1 version?, it could be just the slightly darker tone making it look like that though.
It does look washed out there. On my tv it does not look that way however.
psn
Member
The version your friends play at. I love the DS4 functions, like the red and blue flashing LED when youre chased by the cops, touchscreen and speaker integration. But I would go where my friends are.
Yeah, right.
Theoretical performance doesn't mean jack when we have concrete evidence of real time performance on many cross platform games.
Sony fans are trying way too hard to make it look like PS4 is 2x better than X1 when it really isn't. Making fake comparisons to make that true doesn't really help either. Now that's just sad.
Here is the original source for the foliage comparison:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1t9xAI5g7Ao&feature=player_detailpage#t=395
Doesn't look like it's fake.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1t9xAI5g7Ao&feature=player_detailpage#t=395
Doesn't look like it's fake.
Cutscenes isn't the best way to compare versions.
Compressed Youtube footage is one of the worst ways to do a comparison like this, where the differences between the two are likely to be in the details and not something overtly noticeable.
captainraincoat
Banned
either way they did a good job considering the hardware difference
i really hope we get a red dead revolver HD or a sequel this gen
Mr Moose
Member
I stand corrected. Difference is minuscule.
I read in a different thread that reviewers were able to request what version they wanted, I do not know why so many chose the PS4 version perhaps its due to the PS4 outselling the XB1 so that's where the majority of their readers are, digital foundry being digital foundry simply wanted to know how the XB1 version held up and judging by other threads so does GAF
Not for me unfortunately.
You just put me on hold.
justsomeguy
Member
What is going on here? DF vs. Xbox One and there's PS4 talk everywhere. I'm so confused.
Fullscreen AA is incredibly taxing. Don't think some foliage reducing would open up the power for it.
Yeah. I would take a direct port with better AA vs what we have now.
Conspiracies!
Yeah too bad that last gen Mafia 2 and Read Dead Redemption got trashed on PS3 for such "minuscule" difference
No way for me find that exact area but I made a clip anyways.
http://xboxclips.com/video.php?uid=...dboy&vid=ba224531-beb9-46d7-8361-f6489c593895
Just some random area I chose to show off the density of foliage. In this particular area, you can see that there are patches where it's empty, but then there are also areas where the grass is thick.
Anyway, examine away!
http://xboxclips.com/video.php?uid=...dboy&vid=ba224531-beb9-46d7-8361-f6489c593895
Just some random area I chose to show off the density of foliage. In this particular area, you can see that there are patches where it's empty, but then there are also areas where the grass is thick.
Anyway, examine away!
psn
Member
So you declare a multiplatform game as evidence? We had enough games that show a 40-50% advantage. The benchmark from the GDC is not just theoretical, it's a benchmark.
So you can prove that those multiplatform games you're talking about are 100% optimized for the ps4 to be a concrete evidence of the capabilities of the console? Or is it possible that devs could stop optimizing when they reached their goal and use the time to optimize it for other consoles / pc version?
1970 Chevelle SS
Neo Member
Fight the good fight.
BeforeU
Oft hope is born when all is forlorn.
Friends? Then it comes down to features
You want pause/ resume, achievements and rumble trigger? Then Xbox One
You want trophies and DS4 features? Then PS4.
Yeah too bad that last gen Mafia 2 and Read Dead Redemption got trashed on PS3 for such "minuscule" difference
Did it really? I have noticed some performance hits in some games like MW2 but still enjoyed my PS3 when I switched from 360 due to RROD issues.
Yeah looks like the foliage is dialed back quite a bit. (the optimist in me tells me, the placement is different... *cough* *cough*)
Would have preferred 900p and more foliage to be honest.
Similar threads
- Locked