• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

Denis Villeneuve signed by Legendary Pictures to direct DUNE

Status
Not open for further replies.
M

Matt

Member
I've never read Dune, but I have seen the other adaptations, and even with DV attached it's hard to be excited for this. Feels like it's old news, and the story isn't interesting anymore.

I know book lovers will tell me how wrong I am, so...go ahead. I'd love to be wrong and have reason to be excited.
 
N

Number_6

Member
We've had a good director on a Dune movie before...

This thing needs to either be 4+ hours long or multiple films. Like LOTR multiple films. Two sounds good, film them simultaneously. Three would be better, but more risky.

Weird changes aside, Lynch's Dune moved so slowly--until suddenly it went jarringly fast once Paul was in the desert.
 
P

Pluto

Member
kyser73 said:
I'd be happy with 3 90 minute features for each of the three books which make up what is generally known as Dune:

Dune
Muad'Dib
The Prophet

That length would be easy for audiences to digest, would enable each of the stories to breath & allow fora faithful adaptation IMO.
Click to expand...
If they do that the first movie ends with the bad guys winning and the surviving good guys on the run and the second with a dead baby iirc. I'm not sure that's where they want to leave the audience hanging for two years because a lot of them might not be back.

Dune pretty much screams "Make me an HBO series!", I'm worried a movie won't have time for a lot of character motivations, intrigue and talking scenes.
 
D

duckroll

Member
Who the fuck cares about a "faithful adaptation" at this point? Villeneuve loves the books, which means he has something he wants to say. Let him say it and it'll be better than any adaptation. I don't want artists adapting works for the sake of being faithful. I watch art for interpretation.
 
D

Dougald

Member
duckroll said:
Who the fuck cares about a "faithful adaptation" at this point? Villeneuve loves the books, which means he has something he wants to say. Let him say it and it'll be better than any adaptation. I don't want artists adapting works for the sake of being faithful. I watch art for interpretation.
Click to expand...


The example I always give of this is the Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy. Every single adaptation of that story is different, and they were almost all written by the author. None of them really suffer for it (except maybe the film, but that was still decent enough). Films aren't books, television or radio, people wishing for a story to be exactly the same and still good are asking the impossible.

On the other end of this spectrum you have Watchmen, which apart from the ending was pretty much the comic book. And it sucked.
 
B

Blade30

Unconfirmed Member
duckroll said:
Who the fuck cares about a "faithful adaptation" at this point? Villeneuve loves the books, which means he has something he wants to say. Let him say it and it'll be better than any adaptation. I don't want artists adapting works for the sake of being faithful. I watch art for interpretation.
Click to expand...

Yeah that's what I don't get either, if I read the source material and see an adaptation of it I don't want to see that everything is exactly like in the books but I'd rather see something new and different or vice versa.
 
eot

eot

Banned
Matt said:
I've never read Dune, but I have seen the other adaptations, and even with DV attached it's hard to be excited for this. Feels like it's old news, and the story isn't interesting anymore.

I know book lovers will tell me how wrong I am, so...go ahead. I'd love to be wrong and have reason to be excited.
Click to expand...

I mean, you're already aware of how misguided you come across. No one is excited about this because of the other adaptations, they're excited because Dune is probably the best sci-fi novel ever written. How about you go read it and then come back?
 
T

Tony Redgrave

Member
Thank God.

Correct Director: Check

What's left

Good art direction
Good casting
Be as faithful as possible to the essence and lore
Don't try to make a super franchise

If we get all these we might get a good Dune adaptation and a great one
in the extended 3.5 hour version
.

shira said:
The original book/story and movie and tv series are all pretty iconic.

I'm not even sure what he can bring to the table, it's like remaking Star Wars
Click to expand...

Not really, Lynch's may be iconic as fuck but it's not faithful at all.

The miniseries were a good effort but they were severely limited by their budget, this new Dune deserves some real millions thrown in to make it look beautiful.
 
S

Sgt. Kabukiman

Banned
shira said:
The original book/story and movie and tv series are all pretty iconic.

I'm not even sure what he can bring to the table, it's like remaking Star Wars
Click to expand...

Iconic? I adore the Lynch movie and really like the tv mini-series but nobody saw those. It's nothing like Star Wars.
All this means is that one of the best directors working today is going to get a gigantic budget at his disposal to adapt one of the best and strangest sci-fi stories ever told. Of course he'll bring something to the table, Villeneuve is the polar opposite of David Lynch.
 
R

Randy Monk

Member
drumpfharkonnen.jpg
Click to expand...

Make Dune great again?
 
O

Octavianus

Banned
Gaf, is Arrival really that good? I saw that one trailer and felt like I had seen the whole movie but I'm hoping that's not true.
 
R

Roussow

Member
I'm not familiar with Dune, but my only disappointment with this news is we aren't going to get a Villeneuve project as crazy as Enemy for a while.
 
R

Ricky_R

Member
Roussow said:
I'm not familiar with Dune, but my only disappointment with this news is we aren't going to get a Villeneuve project as crazy as Enemy for a while.
Click to expand...

I've enjoyed all his movies a lot except Enemy. I couldn't even finish it for some reason and I hardly do that regardless of how slow it may be. Maybe I need to try again, see if it clicks.
 
D

Daingurse

Member
Excellent. Currently listening to Children of Dune for the first time, and am really looking forward to this new adapation.

The spice must flow.
 
shira

shira

Member
Tony Redgrave said:
Not really, Lynch's may be iconic as fuck but it's not faithful at all.

The miniseries were a good effort but they were severely limited by their budget, this new Dune deserves some real millions thrown in to make it look beautiful.
Click to expand...

Sgt. Kabukiman said:
Iconic? I adore the Lynch movie and really like the tv mini-series but nobody saw those. It's nothing like Star Wars.
All this means is that one of the best directors working today is going to get a gigantic budget at his disposal to adapt one of the best and strangest sci-fi stories ever told. Of course he'll bring something to the table, Villeneuve is the polar opposite of David Lynch.
Click to expand...

Is this going to be a $200M+ budget special effects laden blockbuster?
 
F

Funyarinpa

Member
Randy Monk said:
Make Dune great again?
Click to expand...

From the end of the book:

The race of humans had felt its own dormancy, sensed itself grown stale and knew now only the need to experience turmoil in which the genes would mingle and the strong new mixtures survive. All humans were alive as an unconscious single organism in this moment, experiencing a kind of sexual heat that could override any barrier.
And Paul saw how futile were any efforts of his to change any smallest bit of this. He had thought to oppose the jihad within himself, but the jihad would be. His legions would rage out from Arrakis even without him. They needed only the legend he already had become. He had shown them the way, given them mastery even over the Guild which must have the spice to exist.
Click to expand...

Honestly it's almost prophetic...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

[Deadline] Dune: Messiah officially in development at Legendary
22
1K
NotMyProblemAnymoreCunt replied
Dune: Part Two - Review Thread
News 6 7 8 9 10
496
26K
Ulysses 31 replied
Denis Villeneuve teases a Dune Messiah movie: 'I will say, there are words on paper'
34
2K
Trogdor1123 replied
Tune in to the first Dune: Awakening Direct on March 4, 18:00 CET/12:00 ET!
News
3
557
March Climber replied
Denis Villeneuve wants to make 'at least three' Dune movies
35
2K
ZehDon replied
Top Bottom