I guess my PS3 was special or something because at no point in either game I felt like the framerate was hindering my experience.
Image quality was not great but it wasn't that bad either. Both had better AA than the games that came before, in particular GTAV.
In the end I think sacrificing the sharpest picture for scope was a good decision.
TLOU was more tolerable but GTA5 was 20+ fps during driving, it felt like slo mo most of the time there, GTA6 will probably be the same unfortunately.
Both had a pretty bad IQ, maybe some games were worse (Crysis 3 anyone?) and last gen in general had a pretty bad IQ in lots of games, but my eyes almost came out of their socket trying to look into the distance in GTA5 (and not too far, the immediate distance), it was just a blur with all those jaggies.
TLOU's bad IQ destroyed some great looking sceneries, some textured looked especially rough.