Does his review spoil any stages that haven't been officially revealed in trailers?
-
Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.
Sonic Mania |OT| Dreams Come True
- Thread starter Hot Coldman
- Start date
Cell_Biology
Member
Double-dipped on the Switch, I'm weak!
Have the PSN/Switch versions, will probably get a physical copy too if that ever happens.
Have the PSN/Switch versions, will probably get a physical copy too if that ever happens.
balladofwindfishes
Member
Hard to believe the last 2D sprite based Sonic I've played was Sonic Advance. I've played plenty of 3D Sonic games (and Sonic 4, whatever the heck that was), but it'll be nice to return to sprites.
Pretty excited to play this tonight. Going to be a lot of deep, heavy nostalgia for me. Sonic 2 was one of the first videos I ever played.
Pretty excited to play this tonight. Going to be a lot of deep, heavy nostalgia for me. Sonic 2 was one of the first videos I ever played.
Beat the game, it's fantastic as expected.
I kind of wish they had put more than just Blue Sphere stages in the signposts though, I started getting really tired of playing them about halfway through the game. The giant ring special stages are much better, but extremely hard. I only got
on my first playthrough.
I kind of wish they had put more than just Blue Sphere stages in the signposts though, I started getting really tired of playing them about halfway through the game. The giant ring special stages are much better, but extremely hard. I only got
4 emeralds
Robin64
Member
Yep.
The levels have been absolute joy to play, they're so good. The special/bonus stages are frustrating for me, though, and a lot of the bosses are crazy hard. Maybe on a second playthrough they'll be easier for me now that I know the tricks to beating them.
End of the second zone:
End of the sixth zone:
I'll pick it up when I get home from work today.
You definitely could not get a port of this game running on a Genesis without severely stripping it down. You'd need a Saturn.
End of the second zone:
I hate Puyo Puyo, LoL. I had to pausescum my way through Mean Bean Machine on the Ultimate Genesis Collection for Xbox 360. I lost this boss fight after a several-minute struggle, then handed the controller to my girlfriend, who is a Puyo Puyo MONSTER. She destroyed the boss with ease, it was disgusting how easy it was for her, haha.
End of the sixth zone:
Fuck that Metal Sonic boss, man. Two parts, no less! The second half wasn't bad, but the first half was ridiculously hard. Took a while to even figure out to bounce the little white robot Sonic up at Metal Sonic when he's spin dashing, and even once we figured that out, it was very hard to pull off WHILE dodging the damn constant energy balls. As soon as the next zone started up, I turned it off for the night ... it was past 2 a.m.
You definitely could not get a port of this game running on a Genesis without severely stripping it down. You'd need a Saturn.
Conrad Link
Member
I hear sound effects from the Master System Sonics in one of the bosses! 
Little things like this just show the love and care that went into this game.
Little things like this just show the love and care that went into this game.
Metal Khaos
Member
If they could go the route of something like Cup Head and make it look all hand-drawn style in the vein of the opening animation, I think that could look cool.
Fleet_of_Foot
Member
I have PS4, xbox, and Switch. I'd really like to get this on Switch but I'm wondering if I should be waiting for a Digital Foundry comparison video. To those who bought on Switch, are there any performance issues?
BlondeTuna
Member
My Sonic catalog is on the Xbox.
I feel like this would be more fun on Switch.
Choices!
I feel like this would be more fun on Switch.
Choices!
Tizoc
Member
I think the team had ideas for a new stage theme but then found their themes already applying t pre existing sonic stages
I have unfortunately not played past Green Hill Zone, but I haven't noticed any issues in either handheld or docked modes.
I really wanted to play more, but I committed to playing 1-3&K before getting deep into it and only got through 1, 2, and about a third into 3&K before I had to hang it up last night.
But even the "old" stages have heavily changed level layouts and a lot of new art, not to mention remixed music of course. It doesn't feel at all like I'm playing the same old stuff; more like visiting new parts of previously existing areas.
Android18a
Member
Both! One for home, one for on the go. Sega gets the message to make another one. Win-win-win.
You could almost consider the old stages to be "Act 3" and "Act 4". But the Act 4 is generally pretty unrecognisable from the previous 3 acts for many stages. Except
Hydrocity
Conrad Link
Member
Seriously though,
that moment when you realise what is happening, so f**king awesome.
lol @ that Chemical Plant Zone boss,
Plays rock solid fine only had one screen freeze issue in my playthrough.
Robin64
Member
None. From the mouth of Taxman himself, it's a full 60fps on every machine out there.
plays perfectly fine, constant 60fps and looks fantastic docked and undocked. The only issue is it takes an extra couple seconds to open the home menu when the game is running
TheAggroCraig
Member
I've run into two bugs so far.
After chemical plant act 1's boss, the game straight up crashed... Lame, not a huge deal.
Second bug was after beating Stardust Speedway act 1. After beating the first act my goal post spawned a ring box which I was to the left of, and Sonic just ran into the box instead of running to act 2, so I got to replay that stage also, hurrah...
Other than that the game is fantastic (not done yet) and I suck at the special stages which is fine because yay challenge!
After chemical plant act 1's boss, the game straight up crashed... Lame, not a huge deal.
Second bug was after beating Stardust Speedway act 1. After beating the first act my goal post spawned a ring box which I was to the left of, and Sonic just ran into the box instead of running to act 2, so I got to replay that stage also, hurrah...
Other than that the game is fantastic (not done yet) and I suck at the special stages which is fine because yay challenge!
ratcliffja
Member
It's fun so far aside from the infuriating special stages. I don't see how it's possible to beat any of them. The first zone boss was great, but the chemical zone boss was pretty boring.
jobrro
Member
If you clear the game
you can select GHZ, go to the nearest giant ring and attempt the special stage for the Chaos Emerald. When you get the emerald or fail, just exit out and you can head back via stage select to the same giant ring to try again or for the next emerald. Went from 2 emeralds to 7 this way. Cheesy but I was pretty terrible at some of the later special stages.
What you think it does. Sonic and Knuckles (like Sonic and Tails) or Knuckles and Knuckles (yes, lol). Not sure if it works on Tails.
That's fair, I'd love to see that too
alas I suspect the current resolution is a compromise for resources, given how time consuming pixel art is at that point.Hopefully you still dig the game's aesthetic all the same! As I say, it'll likely give you Sonic CD vibes
we found the one person who doesn't like it
Android18a
Member
I've got a question...I was a Nintendo kid, completely skipped the Genesis. Played S3&K at a friend's house once and it was fun but besides that I missed that generation. Missed Adventure 1 but I loved Adventure 2. From that point on I was disappointed with Sonic games until Generations hit where I loved the classic and modern stages, got the highest rank on both. Since then I've had Sonic Rush Adventure and downloaded Sonic 2 which were fun. With that said...
What makes this game great and as someone who missed that era, what will I get out of it? Is it still great if I don't have that nostalgia as others?
What makes this game great and as someone who missed that era, what will I get out of it? Is it still great if I don't have that nostalgia as others?
Yeah game is so goddamn good the level design is insane best in the series and possibly one of the best ever.
And those bosses... Amazing also this time you can still cheese em but not as easily as 1,2,3 where you could beat most bosses before they even could do a single attack when they spawned in.
And the OST is out of this world i love both
Press Garden
Robin64
Member
mrmickfran
Member
It pretty much transformed into Wing Fortress.
CampbellzSoup
Member
The pointy edge sliced me
Vince DiCola
Member
I won't get home from work for another 2 hours but I'll be playing as soon as I get home
ratcliffja
Member
If you want puyo puyo, there's a much better game for that already on the Switch and PS4. It would have been cool if they did something where you had to control Sonic directly to manipulate the mean bean machine, but as it was, it was a quick novelty that got tired immediately.
Good games are good games and great level design is great level design, nostalgia be damned. If you enjoyed the gameplay of Sonic 2, you will probably love this.
Both! One for home, one for on the go. Sega gets the message to make another one. Win-win-win.
You could almost consider the old stages to be "Act 3" and "Act 4". But the Act 4 is generally pretty unrecognisable from the previous 3 acts for many stages. Exceptat least which is pretty faithful aside from a few new/borrowed elements.Hydrocity
Yeah, that's basically what they are. (act 4 and act 5 for Green Hill Zone, heh)
I haven't played the zone (seventh zone) you have in spoiler tags ... it was just starting when I turned it off for the night. I had work today!
jobrro
Member
It's a super fun reference that barely anybody probably expected and only lasts a couple of minutes.
primasaurus
Member
Jeez, people with Switch's really getting behind this
I missed the trilogy for years i played a bit of sonic 1 and played through cd as a kid but i loved this game it's amazing.
I did however play the trilogy just before Mania's release and loved it tho.
If you enjoy 2d games and platformers you will love this game for sure it's imo the best Sonic 2D game yet.
Jaded Alyx
Member
Patrick Bateman
Member
I was on the fence with this game, but after watching this video by videogamedunkey I was convinced that it would great and it totally is.
This is my first Sonic-games in literally decades.
This is my first Sonic-games in literally decades.
Do the giant rings respawn infinitely after you beat the game (As in you mess up, you can restart and use the same ring again)? If not, this game will drive me absolutely mad trying to get the emeralds. I already don't like the fact you can only use the ring once and reloading doesn't respawn it on the first playthrough, if it's that way even after beating the game.... ugh.
I love how they segue into other appropriately themed classic levels like that, such inspired subtle design.
Yes you can basically gather all emeralds in green hill zone if you want.
ratcliffja
Member
I'm not saying it ruins the game by any means. I just hoped for more from that fight after hearing about it for a while now.
Edit:
I remember hearing that mean bean machine was in the game in some form for weeks now. That wasn't supposed to be a surprise was it?
yes
Metal Khaos
Member
I won't have a chance to play until I pick up my CE after work, but from past game, you typically get that one shot. You screw up, you need to find the next big ring.