• Hey, guest user. Hope you're enjoying NeoGAF! Have you considered registering for an account? Come join us and add your take to the daily discourse.

[Digital Foundry] New Scorpio Spec Leak: ESRAM Gone, GPU Features Revealed

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cartho

Member
If all this is true it puts Microsoft in a very tricky position. Sony will almost certainly cut the price of Pro this Black Friday. If Scorpio retails for £380 or something and Pro is cut to £250 (a £100 cut after a year is probably doable for Sony) then it's going to be a VERY hard sell if the difference is small.
 

HotHamBoy

Member
Why aren't more Xbox 1 owners relieved to know they won't have to worry about Scorpio getting exclusives?

I would be really pissed off if I bought an XB1 and couldn't play every game. I don't think everyone is planning on upgrading their console.

If you guys want a lot of power just build a PC..? I don't get it. Consoles shouldn't get exclusives until a real generational divide happens.
 

daveo42

Banned
People fail to realize that MS isn't going to radically change architecture 18 months out from a hardware release. While everyone likes to joke about how consoles are more like PCs now, far more planning goes into designing a building a console than going on PC Part Picker.

This is all a repeat of Neo, Orbis, Durango, and pretty much every other leak or speculation that of course because we are so far out from launch, changes could totally be made to match or beat the competition.
 
For new page

"The whitepaper we've seen - dated to just after Scorpio's E3 reveal - only confirms no ESRAM, boosted L2 cache and support for memory compression technology. Beyond that, all we have to go on is Microsoft's stated 320GB/s bandwidth, eight CPU cores - plus a motherboard rendering strongly suggesting 12GB of GDDR5 memory. How the final spec will shape up remains to be seen"

So the article is basically saying "we have some very minor info regarding the Scorpio's GPU, ESRAM and L2 cache, besides that...

68.gif
 

Icolin

Banned
Yup. They can beat MS on price at Christmas.

I think they'll bundle a game with the Pro rather than decreasing the price. Not Horizon or something that came out early in the year, but a new game like RDR2, Destiny 2, Battlefront 2, COD, etc.

Bundled games over price cuts.
 

Bsigg12

Member
so......basically a resolution bump.....lol


oh god, they better announce a hell of a first party lineup at E3. Because this truly is a midgen refresh.

What else would it have been? That is literally where we're at with consoles now.

Why aren't more Xbox 1 owners relieved to know they won't have to worry about Scorpio getting exclusives?

I would be really pissed off if I bought an XB1 and couldn't play every game. I don't think everyone is planning on upgrading their console.

We've known since they announced it that only VR would be exclusive.
 

Sulik2

Member
And no Zen makes the Scorpio pretty much pointless. Sigh. Microsoft making the same mistake they did last gen and not launching the next gen at five years.
 

RoboPlato

I'd be in the dick
That sounds about right although I think it will be less noticeable than the differences between the original consoles due to the increase in output resolution. Of course, that assumes that that both consoles handle checkerboard rendering equally, which they should.

I agree but since this is a pure tech thread, I didn't really want to get into the subjective nature of it.
 
Nothing in this seems truly surprising. It's a powerful console and a powerful mid-gen refresh but not a new console.

I'm interested to see how MS tackles PR messaging for 1080p owners vs. PS4 Pro. That's going to be a bit messy for them given that downsampled images aren't going notable differences between them on the two upgraded consoles
 
if true I'm going to be disappointed, I'm ready to throw down $500 on a superior console.

$399 for better than Pro I guess I can live with, the problem is I'm not impressed by the pro, so how much better can "a little bit better" be?

I have the One S, I have the 4k Blu ray drive, I don't know I think I might just coast through the rest of this gen on slim bodies for both companies unless one of them changes their mind and make exclusive games for either pro or Scorpio.
 

ethomaz

Banned
Xbox One - less powerful than PS4.
Scorpio - more powerful than PS4 Pro.

Anyone disappointed by that jump was expecting WAY too much.
Some fans wants a new gen because this gen is for them already lost.

They wanted a next-gen machine based on Zen + Vega.
 
This is interesting. So the GPU is powerful enough to bring a 900p xbone game to 4k, due some efficiences to rasterizer, and for 1080p titles should do it with power to spare.

Scorpio also supports checkerboard rendering, but Ms is recommending it only to effects, like transparencies, shadows, GI and AO, because you can increase the quality of these effects without a huge compromise in performance or visual due the checkerboard, so indeed a 4k console but with low resolution effects like pretty much is the norm.

Which article did you read, then? :-/

But no Project Scorpio SKUs allowed, so hopefully that'll shut people up with the "it's a new gen" nonsense, despite MS explicitly stating it'll be part of the XB1 family.
 
I also own all the systems including PS4 and XBO. Just saying.

Kinda reminds me off

They brought attention to your post history. It is embarrassing. Doesn't matter if you own other consoles or not, your posts sound like console warrior tripe.

Yep

Res differences between PS4 Pro and Scorpio will be inline with Xbox One and PS4 differences.

I think there will be a little more in the xbox favor. With more ram can have higher quality textures. So not only will it have a slight edge on resolution but textures might look better overall.
 

vpance

Member
That doesn't help existing XB1 games. They have to work on Scorpio as is. I assume the abstraction is such that they can simulate things in the absence of ESRAM without significant performance issues. But it's a fairly big change in memory architecture, it'll be interesting to see if any XB1 games used ESRAM in a way that makes performance a little different or if the change is indeed completely hidden.

Unless, every old game requires a patch to run on Scorpio..

Sounds unlikely, so I guess they figured out how to emulate it. Otherwise that would be a PR and development disaster.
 
I feel like this pro/Scorpio was a last minute thing to keep their system relevant and now their stuck with the Jaguar that's already causing issues. It would be interesting to see how they will do this next gen.
 

twobear

sputum-flecked apoplexy
In fact reading it this corresponds almost exactly with by far and away the most sensible predictions about Scopio (same CPU, better GPU, ESRAM replaced with unified memory).
 
The narrative was that Scorpio would leave Switch in the dust. That won't be the case. I was just pointing that out. Not saying in that post that one is better than another. Sheesh guys lighten up.

I am actually surprised that Microsoft is still pursuing checkerboard now that pro numbers are in and tepid.

The Switch is barely more than a more efficient Wii U with Nvidia architecture. That you'd think a comparison to Scorpio was valid, let alone to even the PS4 Pro, is amazing and delineates your behavior in the topic perfectly.
 

Septic360

Banned
So its basically a more powerful PS4 Pro- which is what we were expecting minus some shattered dreams re: Zen.

So now the whole "OMG ITS A NEW GEN" talk can die.

The most powerful console in the world....but less powerful than some wanted....
 

Interfectum

Member

HotHamBoy

Member
Didn't they say Scorpio is a new generation and not a mid upgrade? I get the impression that this is XBO Pro.

They never said that.

They went out of their way to say otherwise.

if true I'm going to be disappointed, I'm ready to throw down $500 on a superior console.

$399 for better than Pro I guess I can live with, the problem is I'm not impressed by the pro, so how much better can "a little bit better" be?

I have the One S, I have the 4k Blu ray drive, I don't know I think I might just coast through the rest of this gen on slim bodies for both companies unless one of them changes their mind and make exclusive games for either pro or Scorpio.

I really think you are among the minority.
 

AP90

Member
So jaguar cores overclocked to the max.. Yay..
=(

So does this mean $400 at launch with at least a 1TB or higher for storage? I would say $350, but that does not come across as premium..
 
The Switch is barely more than a more efficient Wii U with Nvidia architecture. That you'd think a comparison to Scorpio was valid, let alone to even the PS4 Pro, is amazing and delineates your behavior in the topic perfectly.

It's also a handheld in a tiny box. I'm not sure why it's even brought up against big consoles like this. Makes no sense to me.
 

JlNX

Member
From July 2016? is this really accurate information to go of for a product launching in holiday 2017? especially given people here describing the console at E3 as vapourware let alone a month after that being anymore solid. Plus that article has a lot of speculation from very little information. We are still as clueless as before and anyone taking this as any sort of solid confirmation of anything is looking for just as much attention as that article wants clicks. I'm sure when early dev kits go out we will start to hear more solid details from leaks. Wasn't it rumoured to be February?
 

LordOfChaos

Member
I'm curious, eSRAM has much faster latency than GDDR5, for a GPU, latency generally isn't too important as massively parallel devices, but if a game was coded very specifically to the tune of the eSRAM I wonder if we'll see some oddities on unpatched games.

Sony was paranoid to the point of keeping the CPU and GPU clocks exactly the same in the Pro for unpatched games, removing the eSRAM without the game knowing seems like a bigger deal.
 
How does keeping the same CPU architecture affect VR? I know PSVR gets by, but that was tailored to the PS4, uses reprojection and also has a lower res screen. Can MS run occulus properly with the Jaguar?
 

krang

Member
I knew it wouldn't be Zen.

I guess things could have changed in the 6 months since this paper was released, but I doubt it.
 
If this thing doesnt have a much better cpu, im jist going to spend the same money on a new gpu for my potato masher pc.

Already have a ps4 pro and xbone but wanted to upgrade to scorpio. Not really interested in doing that if the cpu is still jaguar based.
 
Some fans wants a new gen because this gen is for them already lost.

They wanted a next-gen machine based on Zen + Vega.
It's not about "losing" a generation for anyone other than fanboys. People are disappointed because we wanted an upgraded CPU instead of a crappy jaguar and we wanted native 4k for the latest games. This also only pushes back the release of the real Xbox successor.
 
The Switch is barely more than a more efficient Wii U with Nvidia architecture. That you'd think a comparison to Scorpio was valid, let alone to even the PS4 Pro, is amazing and delineates your behavior in the topic perfectly.

*sigh* look we all know the pro and Scorpio systems won't have exclusive software which means that the series are throttled by the base versions. There are tons of PS4/vita games.

If the rumors were true that this was a huge leap it would apply more pressure on competitors to keep up. That won't be the case. Which means Switch should be able to get plenty of multi platform releases technically.

Absolutely on topic.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top Bottom